Having now taken a couple of hours to sit down and think through the situation, I can think of three (3) reasons why I'm not dead even though Gamma claims to have tried to NK me. These would be that we have:
Two docs (virtually impossible in a 12-player game where we have not been led to expect such a thing)
OR
A town RB who (correctly) distrusted Gamma's scum-finding abilities (relatively improbable, IMO)
OR
A mafia RB who lent perhaps a bit more credence to Gamma's skills than is really deserved (most likely, especially since somebody *cough*WhereIsTony*cough* was speculating about it D1)
There are, naturally, the options that Gamma either submitted somebody else as his kill choice or didn't send one in at all, but I find these difficult to believe - Gamma doesn't seem like the type to miss a night choice, he has (we think) no reason to lie, and if he tried to kill someone else, we still have the same question of "why aren't they dead?"
I haven't seen anything to cut down on Tony's scumminess or cause anyone else to leapfrog past him, so I think I'll join RF and
vote: WhereIsTony.
And since you've all driven me to L-1, I suppose this is as good a time as any for me to claim...
I am a
Bari Sax
player. My PM seems to hint I'm a miller, but it doesn't outright tell me so.
WhereIsTony wrote:I have always believed and still do that the scum are likely to have a blocker.
It is the most commmon scum role.
especially in games with Vig.
Vote ToD
reasons
1. Wall'E claims to have reasons
2. Gamma who is at the very least unlikely to be scum wants him dead
3. RF who i have long suspected (since the nekka days defends him)
Strictly speaking, the most common scum role is goon, and I'd guess that after that, next most common is godfather. And your reasons for voting me are... suspect. Sure, you're willing to blindly follow Wall-E -
oh, wait a minute - and you seem to be forgetting Gamma's previously demonstrated brilliance at finding scum to vig. [sarcasm] You're making yourself look better and better, Tony. [/sarcasm] Oh, and there's more: You say you've suspected RF "since the Nekka days," but check this out:
Here, you have her listed not first, not second, not third, but... *counts on fingers*
eighth?
How is that being suspicious of her? You're not helping your case much, Tony. (And thank you, RF, for pointing out what Tony has
not
listed as any of his reasons for voting me.)
