Mafia 88- Return to New Catania- Game Over!

[Xtoxm]

You're just asking for it there.

[OhGodMyLife]

I'm actually a little bit surprised by the lack of attention directed at SensFan in favor of other less egregious lurkers too.

[The Fonz]

Have prodded SensFan, Magisterrain and skitzer.

[SensFan]

Whoops. I'm on this game this weekend.

[Xylthixlm]

unvote, vote SensFan

[tubby216]

unvote, vote SensFan

a bit premature don't ya think? i would have waited til monday to vote sens

[skitzer]

Sorry, haven't really had anything to post on, but I do find the Sir Tornado kill surprising from my POV.

Vote: Der Hammer

[Ectomancer]

You scumbags need to give reason for lynching Der Hammer. I'm not putting up with this crap much longer.

[Xylthixlm]

a bit premature don't ya think? i would have waited til monday to vote sens

He's stalling. It only takes ten minutes to read the last page and post a quick impression.

[tubby216]

@xyl,

ok

[The Fonz]

DH has requested replacement.

[tubby216]

when did i do that??

[tubby216]

oh nevermind, fixed

[vollkan]

I assume this was your question that I missed elmo:

Hey, Vollkan, have you ever considered having two numbers in your lists, one for scuminess and one for confidence? E.g. if you've got someone who's made one post at 65, that's maybe a bit different to someone who's posting frequently and has been at 65 all game. Battle Mage at 65 is different to PJ at 65. Etc. That's how I tend to think of people, anyway. (Okay, I have a third for "level of scrutiny required", but that'd be overdoing it.)

Interesting idea.

For my next list, I will try that. In addition to the scumminess ranking, I will give another number also between 1 and 100 reflecting my confidence in the scumminess ranking.

(FTR, a while ago I tried using a single number to express my expected probability of a person being scum, but it just didn't work for me, probably because it conflated behavioural scumminess and confidence)

[quote="Elmo"
p.s. why is iam scyummy?
[/quote]

I don't think I did say you were scummy...in fact I gave BM a 49.

p.p.s. did you not do another list yet or did I miss it? not like this game needs one... 50 lurking 50 lurking 50 lurking 50 lurking 50 lurking 50 lurking 50 lurking 50 lurking etc.

I haven't done one yet. (And yeah, the lurking in this game is problematic)

And DH has requested replacement...hmm...As he said in an earlier post, he has requested it in other games, but he said he was happy to keep playing this one. I'm not inclined to treat his flaking as scummy, because I think it's more likely than not that his personal problems have spilled over here as well.

[Shanba]

Cases are boring. I think wagons of consensus are win though, ^5 OGML.

I agree with Elmo. ^5

Shanba, do you think I am player A, B or C in your description of the budding Xyl wagon?

A, B and C were not based on real people. I have no fricking clue which one you choose to interpret yourself as.

Xyl: did you read my attack on ckd? Read his posts in isolation, too.

Elmo: Ok, fine, that's your prerogative, but in that case I can only conclude that the whole thing is bullshit.

TBH, I was more suspicious of him for

not

requesting replacement in this game (though in a vague, pretty subtle kind of under the radar way). I'm sorry, I'm not at my most lucid right now.

[The Fonz]

Final Fonz votecount for now:

Xylthixlm (2): Elmo,Xtoxm, OhGodMyLife
curiouskarmadog (2): Shanba, Iamausername
militant (1): Ectomancer
SensFan (1):Xylthixlm
Der Hammer (1): tubby216

Not voting: Claus, (curiouskarmadog), (Der Hammer), (Natirasha), vollkan, Hoopla, magisterrain, Yosarian2, militant, skitzer, (farside22), SensFan

As of tomorrow,

MafiaSSK

will be taking over as primary mod. Send questions/replacement requests/ etc to him until further notice.

[Xylthixlm]

Shanba, your case on ckd is good.

[magisterrain]

ok , back from hellish week in RL
rereading

[MafiaSSK]

Hello.

[iamausername]

Whoops. I'm on this game this weekend.

O RLY

[tubby216]

Whoops. I'm on this game this weekend.

O RLY

i agree

unvote vote sensfan

[Xtoxm]

I'm tempted to think Sens, Skit > Xyl

[Xtoxm]

Unvote Vote Skit

Didn't like his post at all.

[Xtoxm]

I've seen Sens do this before as town, fwiw.

[Yosarian2]

I like the idea of everyone putting down, now, who they think is guilty and everything before you claim, but you should realize that when you claimed at the start of the day, you basically ensured that that a normal day wouldn't actually happen.

Oh, I agree.

Still, funny that you say you like the idea. Your "Oh, I suspect tubby. Same reasons as yesterday - no other opinions about the game, no sirre." Seems to go straight against it.

How so?

So you suspect tubby, and no one else, and still you haven't bothered thinking who would be possible partners to him?

Well, no, I don't usually try to make connections based on my suspicion of one person this early in the game; that's best done after the person is lynched and comes up scum. Doing it before that point is at best pointless, and at worst a major distraction.

No opinions about the lurkers you love to hunt so much?

(shrug) I'm not really saying much myself today, because we're all waiting for you to finish claiming so we can move on with the game, I think. If you really want my opinion on someone first, let me know and I'll be glad to go back and re-read them.