I was the first to think unconfirmed masons should be called neighbors. I am glad Bird111 decided to run a game with them. This an apropriate game to be my last game before my temp mafia leave.
http://www.mafiascum.net/wiki/index.php?title=Mason
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 36#1123736
And I say its neighbors instead or neighbours because I am american!
Onto business, I believe the final group of neighbors to both be town. Carn seemed to honestly suspect Armlx earlier in the game. In the context of them both being scum in the same group, I can't see CarnCarn as being willing to bus armlx his scum buddy. Can't see him as having that kinda a motive if they had never played before and armlx didn't seem to have any pregame talk with his neighbor scum planning a back and forth bus which scum usually plan out pre-game. So the idea of them being on the same team complimented by intentions of them early bussing each other seems outlandish.
Armlx's neighbor claim after the entire situation seems to fit well as an honest explanation to others more so than a fake claim. You can call wifom if you want but I don't think he would so easily link himself to his buddy Carn when they would also have to be paried with either EJ or Detspeed as the third buddy.
Basically I am now certain they aren't scum in the same group. And that they are in fact neighbors. They were first neighbors to claim and their entire back and forth looked genuine. Onto the context of them being scum in different groups yet still neighbors. Idea sounds crazy from page one and continues on that way. Why would Carn scum seek to lynch his neighbor buddy so earlier when it could out him as a neighbor and therefore place him under alot of pressure; if Armlx wasn't revealed as scum, him turning up innocent makes Carn look guilty. Only reason Carn could genuinly take such a risk was if he did not care if he was pressured and if he genuinly didn't care then he was more intent on catching scum then avoiding suspiciouns. Scum normally care more about looking inocent then hunting scum and since Carn seems to fall into the reverse catgory he must be town.
Only possibilities allowing symetry in scum groups are:
1. Both scum same group not neighbors
2. Both scum different group still neighbors
3. Both town still neighbors
4. One of them is an sk
And so since option 4 is just a joke
, only option 3 allows Carn to be town and therefore Armlx must also be town. Basically something simular to what was said in post 348. With that settled its onto finding out who is scum among everyone else.If 3/3 then everyone else is scum but me. If 2/2 then most of everyone else is scum. I think I already know who is in each group of those left. I'll show you these cases in my next post.
Carn, Who should claim next?
