Open 100 - F + E x 2 + TOG OVER! before 712

[sekinj]

Wall-E: Please explain to me the reservations you had regarding pops lynch? what were the basis of your vibes?

vote count

tenchi (1): wall-e
wall-e (1): tenchi

not voting: everyone else

Prods going out to everyone who hasn't posted yet

still trying to find replacements for peter? and budja

[Wall-E]

I essentially thought pops had softclaimed mason.

[Tenchi]

I hope we don't become deadlined because of lack of activity. I hope we get replacements before we get a new deadline.

Now Wall-E:
"You jumped onboard the HP wagon for an arguably weaker reason. "

Nope. There's no "wagon" on him. I was actually the only second one to vote for him after a VERY LONG DISCUSSION.

There were two sides to the discussion you quoted: one thinks his question was scummy, the other thinks his question was pro-town. It was generally concluded that it was a null-tell. I was voting him for not a weaker reason, but for

another one

-- his absence during the discussion of his own words.

It's like he's letting townies munch over some null-tell statement hoping that one of the townies slip up. He should've got in there and clarified what he meant and gave his opinion instead of just watching us go at it.

I forgot he's Townie. But that's what I thought when I gave him my vote.

"Pre-empting Peter?'s case with, "I'm going to STFU now" doesn't erase or invalidate his points in ANY WAY."

It doesn't. That's why I addressed his points already in this page.

Now, his timing and weak suspicion of me gives me reason to vote for him.

"I'm 60% sure you're scum, Tenchi, and that's way more than enough for me to keep my vote on you."

I'll take it. I've made a couple of unclear statements and I know I have to answer to them. However, you should try to not only bank your arguments on the assumption that I am scum. But I guess, that's where the 40% is, right? :\

My gut tells me to

UNVOTE

.

[Tenchi]

EBWOP: Now, his (Peter?'s) timing and weak suspicion of me gives me reason to SUSPECT him.

Now that I think about it more, that series of events tells me something...

Vote: Peter?

I reserve the right to hold my reason until Peter posts and actually contributes some more, or remove it if something else comes up. (Think of this as a public sticky note)

[Wall-E]

Interesting.

Can we get some more weigh-ins on Tenchi, Peter? and... oh hell, the weather outside? Anything at all will make me happy.

[sekinj]

I essentially thought pops had softclaimed mason.

that's all you have to say on the subject? No reason why you thought the rest of us were making a mistake?

[Wall-E]

If you read my posts in isolation you'll see me denouncing the lynch.

[sekinj]

exactly. and I'd like to know why you denounced it. what made you think it was a bad lynch?

[Tenchi]

*facepalm*

I forgot Peter is getting replaced.

But I'll still keep my public sticky note there. I'm more inclined to hear what a Peter? replacement will say.

[Wall-E]

I thought pops was a bad lynch because I thought he'd soft-claimed mason.

[Wall-E]

He said, "Nobody is going to defend me except myself". If he was mason, there'd probably someone directly or indirectly helping him, and he probably would have avoided such a comment and left that up in the air. Ideally, even if he's vanilla he would have a avoided such a comment and left it up in the air.

I don't think it's untownie to point out the remark. It is tangibly valuable info, that if Tenchi is mislynch he's not mason mislynch. And I really doubt I've helped the scum figure out who's mason too much. It's not like a reverse-psychoanalyzed and quadratic pattern of his postings to deduce that he might not be mason, and released my findings. He said, in front of town, scum and all, "Nobody is going to defend me except myself".

So the rest of us are clearer, are you claiming mason, pops?

Right here. Nobody'd mentioned masonry up to that point, and when I pointed it out a moritorium was declared on the whole issue, making me even more strongly suspect pops was softclaiming. I originally wanted a cop to investigate pops on N1, and was hoping that by calling some attention to it the cop would do so, but after some people yelled at me for talking about it I washed my hands of the issue, then later I said something like, "I disagree with this lynch, but can't say why."

I hope that catches you up on the events of D1, sekinj.

Mod: Can we get some prods?

I realize it's Christmas soon, but don't forget about this game people!

[Tenchi]

I'm sorry but I really want the others to say something. I feel something is REALLY missing from the whole equation.

[ThAdmiral]

activity is loooooowwwww

But i'm going to *sigh* wait until after the christmas AND new years periods before trying to replace anyone else. It's a long wait, I know, but hopefully activity will pick up nicely after that

I'll still try to get in people for peter? and budja

[ZazieR]

Still here. I'll try to posts my thoughts about some players soon, but I have to babysit a lot lately. And I'm much more popular than my sister and brother .
So it could be that I have less time for mafia due to that.

However, I'm gonna stay with my

Vote Budja

for my reasons already given. I hope we get a replacer soon. Perhaps I should ask my stalker .

This was actually more a note to let you guys know that I'll continue playing this game and let you hear my thoughts soon.

[Wall-E]

My top 3 scummy players:
1 Budja (tatatadum...)

-Not answering questions aimed at him.

I can agree with this reason 100%.

-Voting as Soveliss saw hp's question as scummy (why Soveliss and not somebody else who gave comments about hp's post)

What?

-Comments about over-focusing on Tenchi

Combined with the next one, yes.

-Saying Tenchi is highly scummy, without telling why he thinks this.

Combined with the previous one, yes.

-'

Keeping friends

', better known as not scumhunting. He also gave his 'list' of suspicions once. However, his list had only Soveliss on it as Pops was neutral to him.

Can you reference the underlined bit? Where did Budja do that? The second thing is not a scumtell by any means.

-His comments about 'Tencho making errors all over the place'.

So? Apart from being kinda funny, what of it?

[Tenchi]

*Noting that Zazie got replaced in our other game and is still active for this one*

[Wall-E]

HEY GUISE WAT'S UP IN THIS HEAR THRED?!

[Tenchi]

*picks nose*

[ZazieR]

-Voting as Soveliss saw hp's question as scummy (why Soveliss and not somebody else who gave comments about hp's post)

He voted Soveliss as Soveliss said that HP's question was scummy. I find that rather odd. But as HP's allignment is now revealed, it isn't a big point against him.

-'Keeping friends', better known as not scumhunting. He also gave his 'list' of suspicions once. However, his list had only Soveliss on it as Pops was neutral to him.

See 'better known as not scumhunting'. He only mentioned Soveliss on his 'list' of scummy players. And his reason was for vote hopping without reasons. The other player mentioned was neutral. However, before that he FoSed Tenchi and in that same post, he said that Tenchi was making errors all over the game. I will explain why this bothers me later.
And it also caught my attention as he wasn't trying to get Soveliss lynched, the one player he actually found suspicious. That's off to me. It seemed more as if he was following the crowd.

-His comments about 'Tenchi making errors all over the place'.

He FoSed Tenchi. He also admitted that Tenchi was suspicious to him. If that's the case, then why would you call his actions errors? It gives me the impression that he knows Tenchi's allignment. And I don't see why it's funny.

Zazie and Korts' flirting.

Is it me, or does Tenchi like voting players who make a case against him?

Your point about post 315?

Mod did everyone pick up their prod?

[ThAdmiral]

I'm prodding everyone who hasn't posted since my last post.
I also reposted on the replacements thread to hopefully get some responses.

[Wall-E]

This is the Tenchi, Wall-E and ZazieR thread.

[Seraphim]

I'm picking up my prod. I want to hear from replacements before continuing, however.

[sekinj]

hi... I'm here... busy withthe holidays...

[Tenchi]

-His comments about 'Tenchi making errors all over the place'.

He FoSed Tenchi. He also admitted that Tenchi was suspicious to him. If that's the case, then why would you call his actions errors? It gives me the impression that he knows Tenchi's allignment. And I don't see why it's funny.

I wish you said it this clear before.

Is it me, or does Tenchi like voting players who make a case against him?

It's something I want to change in the New Year.
(Same thing I felt, hence I unvoted Wall-E. But I still think there's something up with Peter. I want him/his replacement to post their reactions to what has happened so far. Same with Budja.)

[ThAdmiral]

Budja has been replaced by StrangerCoug