Open 906: AAAAAAHHHH I Ran out of Game Names!!! [Game Over]

[fireisredsir]

i literally did ask the question i wanted the answer to very directly

[Gimli]

ISO'd mango now

its really not a great ISO is it, a lot of superficial posting, blending in, not doing much

from all I read of this game this is POEd down as the most likely candidate for scum d1

we flip?

VOTE: mango

[JacksonVirgo]

i literally did ask the question i wanted the answer to very directly

And I gave you the answer, I thought it was very likely an agenda. That’s the single thought behind the post

[KayJayQueue]

I don't want to read anymore of this

How far did you get?

[Gimli]

Can you TL;DR the read on me

posturing on sailor moon's cat readslist was pretty scummy. you were scumreading things in a way I take as forcing a scumread and not genuine thought process. your reaction to jake was the worst alongside mango, imo. just toe tipping around it, unsure what to do, hiding and backtracking in a way that fits an unsure scum play and not an unsure town play. there's a town version of being unsure that I feel ain't what you're doing.

I felt like your push on jupiter was good, but it was on a townie, and if you're a decent scum player (like your in game posture suggests you are) then that's an easy push to make. I liked that you backtracked a bit on how strongly you felt about it, which made me doubt the scumread.

I'll again note you're playing a very positionally minded game and I've seen no solve from you that makes me feel like town evaluating.

there's something to be said about POE as well at this point. there are many other slots are whole lot townier than you are.

of course, wanting to fade black when she was obvtown doesn't help your case much.

[Gimli]

I don't want to read anymore of this

How far did you get?

I missed some 5-6 pages

consider me caught up

[fireisredsir]

i don't think black was obvtown tbf

[Gimli]

I wouldn't replace into a scum slot tbh

too much effort and this is my last week of having time to mafia proper

[Gimli]

I mean

I asked to rep in cause I felt black was a townie

[KayJayQueue]

I wouldn't replace into a scum slot tbh

Unless you have outside information this comment doesn’t make sense. You don’t know the slot you’re repping into. You can think you know but you can’t be certain.

[Gimli]

I don't really think the scumreads on me make a lot of sense, but whatever. This game hasn't been very enjoyable so I wouldn't mind not playing it anymore

black wouldnt post this as scum

[Thomith]

also I'm sorry for ignoring you thomith but I think you're just having a problem with the perspective of someone who's been playing the game for 2 hours, while you're here for a bit longer than that

I gave my thoughts in real time on why I said it could be TMI, I didn't immediately assume she was talking about jackson. I called KJQ pocketed by scum because of her reads in general. I do understand it was obvious to everyone else that I was *supposed* to be talking about jackson, but that was not as obvious to me!

speaking of being pocketed by jackson, I am pinged by page... 31? when KJQ says she is scumreading fireisred (or something) and jackson calls his town to her. it feels like jackson is trying to blend into a towncore by defending townies from other townies as scum.

I'm not saying you were "supposed" to be talking about Jackson so sorry if it seemed like I was putting those words in your mouth, I was just explaining why I don't think it's weird for Kay to be assuming you're talking about Jackson, since she just said he was her main town read.

[Gimli]

I wouldn't replace into a scum slot tbh

Unless you have outside information this comment doesn’t make sense. You don’t know the slot you’re repping into. You can think you know but you can’t be certain.

I'm confident enough in some emotional towntells and whatnot, I just played too much mafia ig

[KayJayQueue]

I don't really think the scumreads on me make a lot of sense, but whatever. This game hasn't been very enjoyable so I wouldn't mind not playing it anymore

black wouldnt post this as scum

Meta isn’t foolproof.

[Gimli]

also I'm sorry for ignoring you thomith but I think you're just having a problem with the perspective of someone who's been playing the game for 2 hours, while you're here for a bit longer than that

I gave my thoughts in real time on why I said it could be TMI, I didn't immediately assume she was talking about jackson. I called KJQ pocketed by scum because of her reads in general. I do understand it was obvious to everyone else that I was *supposed* to be talking about jackson, but that was not as obvious to me!

speaking of being pocketed by jackson, I am pinged by page... 31? when KJQ says she is scumreading fireisred (or something) and jackson calls his town to her. it feels like jackson is trying to blend into a towncore by defending townies from other townies as scum.

I'm not saying you were "supposed" to be talking about Jackson so sorry if it seemed like I was putting those words in your mouth, I was just explaining why I don't think it's weird for Kay to be assuming you're talking about Jackson, since she just said he was her main town read.

I get it, I don't think it was weird either

I kinda thought it was weird at the time because of catching up and tripping over my own thoughts

[halfasleep]

I wouldn't replace into a scum slot tbh

too much effort and this is my last week of having time to mafia proper

I mean

I asked to rep in cause I felt black was a townie

mmf. this is a weird comment to make and assumption to make if true? based on individual player meta?
probably no AI but it is odd.

[fireisredsir]

im fairly sure she has made a very similar post as scum before although i don't really want to go dig for it

the point more was that i don't think "pushing obvtown black" is that valid of a reason for suspicion here

[halfasleep]

gimli did my exchanges with kay after scumreading her affect your read on either of us?

[KayJayQueue]

I’m not going to just trust someone’s meta read on someone else when it’s the person literally repping into the slot they are meta-reading. No matter the alignment, it’s exactly what you would say but I’d say even more so if you were trying to convince others you were town as scum over town as town. I think there’d be other things you could use to explain your town alignment that went beyond “trust me bro”.

[Gimli]

I wouldn't replace into a scum slot tbh

too much effort and this is my last week of having time to mafia proper

I mean

I asked to rep in cause I felt black was a townie

mmf. this is a weird comment to make and assumption to make if true? based on individual player meta?
probably no AI but it is odd.

like I wouldnt rep into jupiter cause who knows, right?

but the way black played, from the little I read as I was keeping tabs on the game, I was confident she was a townie

I happened to be right so props to me

and yeah I guess I could've given a scum role and I'd be sitting here powering through it

it doesn't matter, I gave like 8 reasons for scumreading virgo and this was the bottom of those

[Gimli]

gimli did my exchanges with kay after scumreading her affect your read on either of us?

no. I'm not sure I even remember these posts anymore, sorry. I know I just replaced in but goldfish memory.

I find, for instance, that you won't immediately accept my townread on you to be great evidence that you're a townie. I liked your approach early on, your reads list, your reaction to pressure on you etc. you're my strongest townread maybe alongside fireisred.

[KayJayQueue]

You’re not making me feel any different about my scumread on the Black-slot. I was open to having just been overly convinced in my own reads so I was willing to entertain your perspective on the slot. But you’ve really just solidified my read.

[JacksonVirgo]

Can you TL;DR the read on me

posturing on sailor moon's cat readslist was pretty scummy. you were scumreading things in a way I take as forcing a scumread and not genuine thought process. your reaction to jake was the worst alongside mango, imo. just toe tipping around it, unsure what to do, hiding and backtracking in a way that fits an unsure scum play and not an unsure town play. there's a town version of being unsure that I feel ain't what you're doing.

I felt like your push on jupiter was good, but it was on a townie, and if you're a decent scum player (like your in game posture suggests you are) then that's an easy push to make. I liked that you backtracked a bit on how strongly you felt about it, which made me doubt the scumread.

I'll again note you're playing a very positionally minded game and I've seen no solve from you that makes me feel like town evaluating.

there's something to be said about POE as well at this point. there are many other slots are whole lot townier than you are.

of course, wanting to fade black when she was obvtown doesn't help your case much.

Just because I am more reserved than you’d like does not mean I’m scummy. I act in a way that I feel benefits the town, I’ve learned a decent bit ago that my regular gung ho way of playing was only as effective as I am lucky and I am no longer doing that. I am playing coy, I am playing reserved and above all I am playing in a way that I deem beneficial no matter what that looks like. I’m not afraid to greatly exaggerate my confidence if I deem it necessary to do and I have done that plenty here. My read on Jake started incredibly weak, I wanted to put my foot in the door to force myself to make a stance on him and as such I did just that. It was doubled as a joke as well because Im a funny aussie guy but it’s still useful.

Reading me based on the accuracy of my read is also incredibly foolish. I cannot stress how much I resent that.

[JacksonVirgo]

Unconventional? Sure. scummy? No

[KayJayQueue]

Im a funny aussie guy

I agree with Jack on this one!