Mini Theme 2330 - A Questionable Almost-Normal Game - Postgame

[Black]

Enchant might be scum. It's unlikely and tabling.

Light Drew Ranger Black is my scumpool with Ranger being the least likely.

What happened to your PC scumread?

[Doctor Drew]

Enchant might be scum. It's unlikely and tabling.

Light Drew Ranger Black is my scumpool with Ranger being the least likely.

Can you elaborate on Black and I?

Also is funny that both of you kinda scum read each other(talking about you and Ranger), and you both have me as a solid scum read.....I feel like there is something to that, what exactly I can't put my finger on it though

[Titus]

Enchant might be scum. It's unlikely and tabling.

Light Drew Ranger Black is my scumpool with Ranger being the least likely.

What happened to your PC scumread?

I waffle on it. One thing that isn't how I would react isn't a slip and I don't know PC enough to determine if it is or not. The behavior I see around light and myself is a bit more disturbing. PC's not a townread but not a biggest scumread.

[Titus]

Enchant might be scum. It's unlikely and tabling.

Light Drew Ranger Black is my scumpool with Ranger being the least likely.

Can you elaborate on Black and I?

Also is funny that both of you kinda scum read each other(talking about you and Ranger), and you both have me as a solid scum read.....I feel like there is something to that, what exactly I can't put my finger on it though

Black I just recently commented on. However the trajectory on me/Light is awful.

You're in a position to opportunistically vote on Lap, I don't TR you, you fit a rule of 3 if Ranger is scum.

[Doctor Drew]

Enchant might be scum. It's unlikely and tabling.

Light Drew Ranger Black is my scumpool with Ranger being the least likely.

Can you elaborate on Black and I?

Also is funny that both of you kinda scum read each other(talking about you and Ranger), and you both have me as a solid scum read.....I feel like there is something to that, what exactly I can't put my finger on it though

Black I just recently commented on. However the trajectory on me/Light is awful.

You're in a position to opportunistically vote on Lap, I don't TR you, you fit a rule of 3 if Ranger is scum.

Imagine if you are the Cop, and someone else who is close to being limmed claims a Cop variant, and someone else(PC) defends the claim......how would you react?

Also, by your logic I am scum if you flip scum as well?

[Political Clout]

I'm perfectly happy not saying anything lmao. How do you even come up with this stuff.

[Political Clout]

I'm here for the rest of the night


ITT: what would a cop for sure do: The anime.

[Titus]

Enchant might be scum. It's unlikely and tabling.

Light Drew Ranger Black is my scumpool with Ranger being the least likely.

Can you elaborate on Black and I?

Also is funny that both of you kinda scum read each other(talking about you and Ranger), and you both have me as a solid scum read.....I feel like there is something to that, what exactly I can't put my finger on it though

Black I just recently commented on. However the trajectory on me/Light is awful.

You're in a position to opportunistically vote on Lap, I don't TR you, you fit a rule of 3 if Ranger is scum.

Imagine if you are the Cop, and someone else who is close to being limmed claims a Cop variant, and someone else(PC) defends the claim......how would you react?

Also, by your logic I am scum if you flip scum as well?

Did PC "defend the claim" or merely show reluctance? Why does that matter regarding your vote?

[Doctor Drew]

Enchant might be scum. It's unlikely and tabling.

Light Drew Ranger Black is my scumpool with Ranger being the least likely.

Can you elaborate on Black and I?

Also is funny that both of you kinda scum read each other(talking about you and Ranger), and you both have me as a solid scum read.....I feel like there is something to that, what exactly I can't put my finger on it though

Black I just recently commented on. However the trajectory on me/Light is awful.

You're in a position to opportunistically vote on Lap, I don't TR you, you fit a rule of 3 if Ranger is scum.

Imagine if you are the Cop, and someone else who is close to being limmed claims a Cop variant, and someone else(PC) defends the claim......how would you react?

Also, by your logic I am scum if you flip scum as well?

Did PC "defend the claim" or merely show reluctance? Why does that matter regarding your vote?

PC showed no sign of doubt the way someone who has the same(or extremely similar) role would, they defended it even by mentioning how it is in the normal roles thread.....if they did show reluctance as town it would make sense they WERE NOT a cop.....which apparently only Enchant is that...Koba, JV, and yes myself all acted in ways a cop would react to a seemingly fake claim

[Doctor Drew]

Enchant might be scum. It's unlikely and tabling.

Light Drew Ranger Black is my scumpool with Ranger being the least likely.

Can you elaborate on Black and I?

Also is funny that both of you kinda scum read each other(talking about you and Ranger), and you both have me as a solid scum read.....I feel like there is something to that, what exactly I can't put my finger on it though

Black I just recently commented on. However the trajectory on me/Light is awful.

You're in a position to opportunistically vote on Lap, I don't TR you, you fit a rule of 3 if Ranger is scum.

Imagine if you are the Cop, and someone else who is close to being limmed claims a Cop variant, and someone else(PC) defends the claim......how would you react?

Also, by your logic I am scum if you flip scum as well?

Did PC "defend the claim" or merely show reluctance? Why does that matter regarding your vote?

PC showed no sign of doubt the way someone who has the same(or extremely similar) role would, they defended it even by mentioning how it is in the normal roles thread.....if they did show reluctance as town it would make sense they WERE NOT a cop.....which apparently only Enchant is that...Koba, JV, and yes myself all acted in ways a cop would react to a seemingly fake claim

On laptop now, so can be a bit more clear lol

The claim by Lap made me think it was caught scum, and the way PC was so iffy about the claim at the time made me think PC was protecting Lap. Now in hindsight it feels like PC not wanting to be part of the mis lim.....just like in hindisght I understood how Koba and JV were acting around the claim.

Also again Titus, how would you act if you come into the thread at night, you see someone is about to be limmed, you are the town Cop, and said player on the chopping block claims an extremely simliar role to yours?

[Political Clout]

That wasn't more clear at all...

[Doctor Drew]

That wasn't more clear at all...

What do you need clarification about?

[Political Clout]

That wasn't more clear at all...

What do you need clarification about?

Wellll I don't want to impose but if I am scum how do you explain my revote of lap? you are only looking at this one dimensionally i.e. my unvote of lap. if you make a good argument I'll vote myself.

[Doctor Drew]

That wasn't more clear at all...

What do you need clarification about?

Wellll I don't want to impose but if I am scum how do you explain my revote of lap? you are only looking at this one dimensionally i.e. my unvote of lap. if you make a good argument I'll vote myself.

Funnilly enough(not a word i know lol), this is less about you and more about Titus' read on how the end of D1 went. I don't get how my play is scummier than your play.

Hence why I keep wanting her to answer how she would act if she was the town cop in that scenario.

[Political Clout]

That wasn't more clear at all...

What do you need clarification about?

Wellll I don't want to impose but if I am scum how do you explain my revote of lap? you are only looking at this one dimensionally i.e. my unvote of lap. if you make a good argument I'll vote myself.

Funnilly enough(not a word i know lol), this is less about you and more about Titus' read on how the end of D1 went. I don't get how my play is scummier than your play.

Hence why I keep wanting her to answer how she would act if she was the town cop in that scenario.

On balance the question is pointless as titus would either make something up or just tell the truth. How you would or wouldn't act as a cop in my opinion cannot be attributed to alignment. I think you actually make an insightful question how you are scummier than me both valid and needs answering. If I was scum I would be jumping for joy at the fact that lap was blasted off day 1, so what would be my next move if I were scum? I think I would want to blend in, or reveal information that I think would get me town equity. I think someone asked who it was that decided we were all cops that was a pretty good question imo.

Further you might be talking past each other you and titus. I think a more productive question is when did they start scum reading you and why?

[Doctor Drew]

That wasn't more clear at all...

What do you need clarification about?

Wellll I don't want to impose but if I am scum how do you explain my revote of lap? you are only looking at this one dimensionally i.e. my unvote of lap. if you make a good argument I'll vote myself.

Funnilly enough(not a word i know lol), this is less about you and more about Titus' read on how the end of D1 went. I don't get how my play is scummier than your play.

Hence why I keep wanting her to answer how she would act if she was the town cop in that scenario.

On balance the question is pointless as titus would either make something up or just tell the truth. How you would or wouldn't act as a cop in my opinion cannot be attributed to alignment. I think you actually make an insightful question how you are scummier than me both valid and needs answering. If I was scum I would be jumping for joy at the fact that lap was blasted off day 1, so what would be my next move if I were scum? I think I would want to blend in, or reveal information that I think would get me town equity. I think someone asked who it was that decided we were all cops that was a pretty good question imo.

Further you might be talking past each other you and titus. I think a more productive question is when did they start scum reading you and why?

Valid last point, I pointed it out earlier and didn't say explicitly......but found it odd that Titus and Ranger both scum read each other......yet both have me in their solve.

And my question to Titus about how would they act as town cop......well, I still would prefer a reponse from her, then we can examine her response

[Enchant]

I don't like Drew, his argumentation is pure nonsense, and not in sense i use.

[Political Clout]

I'm sitting on that for a moment

How sure are you

70/30

UNVOTE: PC

who do you want dead rn?

I doubt it's truly a Ganski/Ranger/PC solve but it sure feels like it

I doubt it's truly a Ganski/Ranger/PC solve but it sure feels like it

Sometimes it really is that easy

VOTE: PC

the jacksonvirgo pocket spews as informed scum.

[Doctor Drew]

I don't like Drew, his argumentation is pure nonsense, and not in sense i use.

Explain Zebra

[Enchant]

There's like 2 common approaches people take when double claims.

1. They aggressively pressure. Mostly unrealistic but happens.
2. They try out of their way to show that "no i am not this role" yet still gonna vote. More realistic.

It's kinda hard to fake.

[Enchant]

I don't like Drew, his argumentation is pure nonsense, and not in sense i use.

Explain Zebra

As i said, your argumentations are pretty eh and more fit demagogue, not town member.

[Doctor Drew]

There's like 2 common approaches people take when double claims.

1. They aggressively pressure. Mostly unrealistic but happens.
2. They try out of their way to show that "no i am not this role" yet still gonna vote. More realistic.

It's kinda hard to fake.

As I said before, I didn't like how stark my shift was on lap after I saw his claim, in retrospect......read my notes PT and you will see I thought I was a goner

Just thought it was an obvious fake claim, I mean just look at my interactions with PC lol

Pre Edit: Do you know how to expose Titus?

Ranger did give a hint earlier

[Enchant]

I am strongly convinced at minimum 1 mafia claimed inno on me.

Need to figure who exactly.

[usesPython]

I'm sitting on that for a moment

How sure are you

70/30

UNVOTE: PC

who do you want dead rn?

I doubt it's truly a Ganski/Ranger/PC solve but it sure feels like it

I doubt it's truly a Ganski/Ranger/PC solve but it sure feels like it

Sometimes it really is that easy

VOTE: PC

the jacksonvirgo pocket spews as informed scum.

JV is obvtown

[Political Clout]

I'm sitting on that for a moment

How sure are you

70/30

UNVOTE: PC

who do you want dead rn?

I doubt it's truly a Ganski/Ranger/PC solve but it sure feels like it

I doubt it's truly a Ganski/Ranger/PC solve but it sure feels like it

Sometimes it really is that easy

VOTE: PC

the jacksonvirgo pocket spews as informed scum.

JV is obvtown

doesn't explain why you are letting jv dictate your actions.