Mini 683 - Intentionally Vague Mafia, Over

[JDodge]

To be specific about the grim situation at the moment:

I have been looking for replacements for both Scattered and Drake. I have found none yet. IF I do not find

at least one

in the next 72 hours, I will simply resort to a modkill of both of them.

[CF Riot]

Sounds fair to me.

[CF Riot]

Should've thought longer before I posted. Will the Mod-deaths send us to night or reset the current day?

[JDodge]

Should've thought longer before I posted. Will the Mod-deaths send us to night or reset the current day?

A dual modkill will be treated as a full day-night cycle. We would officially be in day four.

[CF Riot]

Okay, I like that ruling.

[Lawrencelot]

In that case, I'll wait for a replacement or modkill.

Unvote

[RestFermata]

Unvote

I guess that those modkills are set to happen any minute now :/

[JDodge]

And so, from somewhere you cannot fathom, something happens to a couple of people. And so your trials and tribulations are over; you are free to live your little vague somethings in your little vague town of little vague people in your little vaguely depressing style.

Game over, something wins.

[JDodge]

THE SCUM:

MafiaMann - Mafia Witch (Role Action: Curse, gives target's night actions 50% chance of failing, permanent, target told something happened)

Scattered - Mafia Goon (Role Action: Kill, kills target)

Sun Tzu - Oddly-worded Mafia Allied Ascetic (Role Action: Immunity, immune to all night actions except for Kill, passive; role PM was worded to imply that he was a survivor)

THE TOWN:

Lord Gurgi - Vigilante (Role Action: Kill, kills target)

RestFermata - Census Taker (Role Action: Census, is not told any important info when he uses his ability, designed to be misleading)

Lawrencelot - Delayed Day Cop (Role Action: Day-investigate, is given useful results, but results are delayed as to be misleading. Activated by posting "Something: ____" in thread.)

CF Riot - Frankenstein (Role Action: Auto-mutate, turns Frankenstein's Monster into another role already in setup each day)

DraketheFake - Frankenstein's Monster (Role Action: N1 - none (townie), N2 - kill (vigilante), N3 - kill (mafia goon))

Forbiddanlight - Townie (Role Action: None)

Firestarter - Ascetic (Role Action: Immunity, see above)

Rich, kmd4390 - Lovers (Role Action: Unending Affection, commits suicide if other dies, passive)

Thoughts? Comments? This entire game was mostly an experiment in what would happen if you were to take all relevant information out of the setup. I'd like as much information out of it as I can get.

[forbiddanlight]

I think it ended up putting people off since no one had any idea what was going on, and there wasn't enough information to even try to piece it together. People like a puzzle, but not when it is missing half the pieces. I was actually quite happy when I was killed, to be honest. I'm sure there are people who would enjoy this, but I'm not one of them.

I'd like to see what the others thought though.

[CF Riot]

Yeah, not to be harsh or anything but not for me. Not knowing whether you were right or wrong took the fun out of arguing with people and lynching people. I actually thought I might be an SK or Vig D2 because I targeted Forbid on N1. Now that I know my real role, I still don't really understand it. If MM and Sun Tzu hadn't been obvscum, I think a game like this is heavily favored for the scum. I could be wrong though.

Go town?

[Lawrencelot]

It was interesting. Not knowing your action wasn't the problem, and not knowing the roles of dead players wasn't either. But apparently I did a day action (only by luck) yet still nothing happened, while it would have been equally likely that I didn't post Something: x.
So Sun Tzu was mafia but didn't know his teammates? It does make it more balanced, but I don't know.

Interesting game, glad I played in it, but not sure if I'd do it again.

[Vi]

Watching from the sidelines, I'll vouch that the concept at least was hilarious. But I think this game would only have worked out if nobody (save the Mafia obv) had used their actions, just to keep the game remotely explicable.

[Kmd4390]

Wait, so Scattered was modkilled for a town win, correct?

And I have to say, we did pretty damn good on those lynches.

I'm shocked I was a lover. Didn't expect that.

[RestFermata]

I think it's funny that FS, Lawrencelot and I were arguing up a storm but it was useless because the scum had gone AWOL.

[RestFermata]

Oh and by the way, I'd be interested to see everyone's day/night actions and stuff.

[forbiddanlight]

My only night action was targetting Lord Gurgi. We thought we killed each other, lol.

[Firestarter]

This is not for me.. thanks.

[MeMe]

last post