Mini Theme 2318: Cook's Kitchen Sink [Game Over]

[Doctor Drew]

Also he said his role only worked once there weren’t 3 scum alive. So why would you try or expect anything else?

what would I lose by trying it

But, you tried justifying your night action with what seemed to be a legit reason why you chose Kitty.

If it was for the lulz, why act like it wasn't?

[Flavor Leaf]

Neighbor Semi-Procrastinating Role Cop

my action doesn't succeed (no result) when all 3 mafia are still alive during the night

Actually how the fork do you even know there’s 3 mafia?

Remember how Titus and I kept saying 4 scum last game it's cuz we knew.

[yessiree]

why i know there are 3 scums?

because it's in the setup you absolute doofs

[yessiree]

Also he said his role only worked once there weren’t 3 scum alive. So why would you try or expect anything else?

what would I lose by trying it

But, you tried justifying your night action with what seemed to be a legit reason why you chose Kitty.

If it was for the lulz, why act like it wasn't?

because i asked the mod if i could send an action anyways and she wouldn't answer

so i sent one anyways

[Gamma Emerald]

Yeah in that case it falls back to my prior issue of the being able to act despite the reason given for that ability not being present, but it’s a double whammy now. Mutated role + faction size is known.

[yessiree]

There is only one scumteam, which has 3 members. Consequently, there are 10 townies. No alignment changes are possible.

and the actions regarding the procrastinating modifier can quickly be checked through a 2 minute wiki read

but obviously yall think yourselves so knowledgeable you don't fact check stuff anymore

[Doctor Drew]

why i know there are 3 scums?

because it's in the setup you absolute doofs

I don't see anywhere in the OP or the game announcement about how many scum there are......in fact, specifically said it was a closed setup.

[Doctor Drew]

There is only one scumteam, which has 3 members. Consequently, there are 10 townies. No alignment changes are possible.

and the actions regarding the procrastinating modifier can quickly be checked through a 2 minute wiki read

but obviously yall think yourselves so knowledgeable you don't fact check stuff anymore

Oh haha, didn't look at the second post

[Roden]

Something's fishy.

Why do you know that exact line and why did Yessiree attempt to use it still?

Because I looked up every claimed role and modifier as they were being claimed, and "Procrastination" is very recent in my web history. My Role + Engineer gift puts me in a niche situation where I can confirm certain roles and modifiers when I get targeted, which is why I want Yess to target me.

[Roden]

Neighbor Semi-Procrastinating Role Cop

my action doesn't succeed (no result) when all 3 mafia are still alive during the night

Actually how the fork do you even know there’s 3 mafia?

It's in the set up

[Flavor Leaf]

Also he said his role only worked once there weren’t 3 scum alive. So why would you try or expect anything else?

what would I lose by trying it

But, you tried justifying your night action with what seemed to be a legit reason why you chose Kitty.

If it was for the lulz, why act like it wasn't?

because i asked the mod if i could send an action anyways and she wouldn't answer

so i sent one anyways

why would you be able to 'send an action anyways'

you seemed very aware you wouldn't be able to.

[Roden]

Roden also set up the energy on Naerys.

I also set up the energy on Yess.

[Roden]

Somebody's gonna have to explain why sending an action just to see if you can is scummy

[Gamma Emerald]

…This is usually intended for games with known faction sizes. In a game with unknown faction sizes, a Procrastinating player may attempt to act, but their action will fail if more than one non-town players were alive at the start of that phase.

I call hogus-bogus.

[Roden]

What do you call hogus-bogus on

[Gamma Emerald]

There is only one scumteam, which has 3 members. Consequently, there are 10 townies. No alignment changes are possible.

and the actions regarding the procrastinating modifier can quickly be checked through a 2 minute wiki read

but obviously yall think yourselves so knowledgeable you don't fact check stuff anymore

This post
An actual reading of the wiki gives a very strong reason why Yess shouldn’t have been able to use his role in the way that he claims.

[yessiree]

What r u on about

My action failed

[yessiree]

Also he said his role only worked once there weren’t 3 scum alive. So why would you try or expect anything else?

what would I lose by trying it

[Gamma Emerald]

You shouldn’t have been allowed to act at all

[Roden]

There is only one scumteam, which has 3 members. Consequently, there are 10 townies. No alignment changes are possible.

and the actions regarding the procrastinating modifier can quickly be checked through a 2 minute wiki read

but obviously yall think yourselves so knowledgeable you don't fact check stuff anymore

This post
An actual reading of the wiki gives a very strong reason why Yess shouldn’t have been able to use his role in the way that he claims.

Everything you've quoted substantiates his claim

[yessiree]

Clearly I could, I got no result that means my action failed

This isn't a normal game, the mod doesn't need to follow normal conventions to the letter

[Roden]

You shouldn’t have been allowed to act at all

It does not say that in the wiki

[Doctor Drew]

You shouldn’t have been allowed to act at all

No that isn't how it works.

[Celebloki]

Be nice if we could at least get confirmation from AD or Vander that at least the neighbor part is true.

[Celebloki]

Is it misguided to think there has to be a scum in a neighborhood, or are all town neighborhoods a thing and just as likely? My only exposure to one was a 4 person neighborhood with 1 and a traitor.