Mini 709 - Musical Mafia - (Game Over!)

[WhereIsTony]

vote Wall-E

I know this puts him at L-2

1. I never stopped suspecting him and only dropped to pressure Nek (who is no longer here)
2. He has had time to post, but no time to respond to cases against him.

The context of this post seems to infer that you dropped voting for your #1 suspect in favor of pressuring someone you did not think was as scummy as me. Am I correct in this?

There is still plenty of time for you believe me when i say you are my #1 suspect still.

Vote Count:
Atlas - (0)
Budja - (1) Wall-E
corporate - (1) WhereIsTony
Gamma - (0)
jerseygoomba - (4) Atlas, Gamma, RestFermata, zachattack
JordanA24 - (0)
My Milked Eek - (0)
RestFermata - (1) Tolmides
Tolmides - (0)
Wall-E - (5) My Milked Eek, corporate, jerseygoomba, Budja, JordanA24
WhereIsTony - (0)
zachattack - (0)

With 12 alive, 7 votes will end the day.

[Budja]

So, why did you vote corporate then if Wall-E is your top suspect?

[WhereIsTony]

A vote can be used as a tool to announce displeasure, or to put pressure on a player to explain an action which corporate more or less did, II did not bother unvoting because it was one vote.

he is not near a lynch

Wall-E while my top suspect has not yet warranted being put to L-1

[Wall-E]

Just so we're clear; you are not currently voting for your #1 suspect. Is that correct?

[WhereIsTony]

yes that is correct

[corporate]

hell, if you think wall e is scum why not put him at L 1? you do what scum to die, right?
heres your

FoS Tony

[RestFermata]

Wall-E, that's a good observation, but you aren't voting for your #1 suspect, either. That is, assuming that your #1 suspect is me, which I don't think you'd argue with. Unfortunately I don't think you bother to read my posts, so if someone else could relay this to Wall-E, I would appreciate it.

[WhereIsTony]

If I put Wall-E at L-1 I strongly suspect someone else would unvote, thus serving nothing.


But I am happy to put it to the test

unvote, vote Wall-E

[My Milked Eek]

The point is not about you putting Wall-E at L-1. The thing I, and others, don't like is that you voted for a person when you felt there was someone more scummy around (after unvoting your top suspect). You say to have done it to apply pressure yet you don't quite apply any pressure and crack to "pressure" yourself by putting your vote back.

[Wall-E]

RF you are not my #1 anymore. I essentially haven't picked my badger yet.

[corporate]

convienent time to change your mind

[WhereIsTony]

RF you are not my #1 anymore. I essentially haven't picked my badger yet.

you seem to confuse #1 suspect with certainty.

[WhereIsTony]

The point is not about you putting Wall-E at L-1. The thing I, and others, don't like is that you voted for a person when you felt there was someone more scummy around (after unvoting your top suspect). You say to have done it to apply pressure yet you don't quite apply any pressure and crack to "pressure" yourself by putting your vote back.

A good point, but voting for a person despite someone else seeming more scummy has many utitlites,.

For example here it got corp to reread my earlier post.

[Gamma]

If we lynch wall-e today, and he turns up town, I can only say "I told you so."

And then I will promptly rail against the bandwagon- I'm pretty sure at least one of the Wall-E lynching party is just really oppotunistic scum.

[WhereIsTony]

In the Event, Wall-E is lynched and I am night killed before I post again

my suspect list from scummiest to cleanest

Wall-E
corporate
jerseygoomba
Tolmides
Budja
Atlas
Gamma
RestFermata Nekka-Lucifer
zachattack
JordanA24
My Milked Eek
WhereIsTony

[jerseygoomba]

Tony, out of curiosity, what makes me more scummy in your eyes than Tolmides, Budja, or Atlas even?

[corporate]

im also curious how your list would be useful to anyone other than scum, tony.

[WhereIsTony]

Tony, out of curiosity, what makes me more scummy in your eyes than Tolmides, Budja, or Atlas even?

brief post with a lot of silence in between, like you are doing as little as possible to be noticed

[WhereIsTony]

im also curious how your list would be useful to anyone other than scum, tony.

So if I am night killed other townies can have a glimpse at my thoughts pre-death

How would it be useful to scum?

[corporate]

im also curious how your list would be useful to anyone other than scum, tony.

So if I am night killed other townies can have a glimpse at my thoughts pre-death

How would it be useful to scum?

if your not killed scum knows where they stand in your eyes

[jerseygoomba]

Tony, out of curiosity, what makes me more scummy in your eyes than Tolmides, Budja, or Atlas even?

brief post with a lot of silence in between, like you are doing as little as possible to be noticed

That's pretty weak rationale all things considered, but then again, this IS only day 1, so until we see some movement, its almost slightly better than random voting I guess.

[Wall-E]

It's pathetic that nobody can come up with a reason why I'm being wagoned.

[My Milked Eek]

It's pathetic you still haven't answered to Jordan's (most recent) posts.

[JordanA24]

i support a no kill from gamma because its day 1 and i dont think we have enough information to make 2 kills today and i would hate to have him kill a townie on accident.

One problem I have with this is that we force him to no-kill is that, how can we be sure he no-kills anyway? If he is an SK, and two kills are made, he can simply claim he is still a Vig, and that there is another player who is an SK that made that second kill. And also, if force him to kill someone, we may be able to find out if he is an SK or Vig via his kill method (Shot=most likely Vig, Stabbed or something like that=Most likely SK). I realise this is Playing the Mod, and he might not even post kill methods at all, but it's still something to bear in mind.

I say let him choose,

If he kills we may be able to see the nature of his role.

I am always a big advocate of a vig kill on night one because it is the

equivlant of a lynch with 100% scum free voting

.

how does this make any sense at all? the scum get to vote too.

This post makes no sense at all, Tony's post quite clearly states that he's talking about a Vig Kill.


Tony makes very little sense at the top of the page regarding his vote. If you want to announce displeasure, an FOS is an equally valid method of doing that.

RF you are not my #1 anymore. I essentially haven't picked my badger yet.

You've crossed the line into complete ridiculousnes. As corporate said, convenient time to change your mind, why did you change your mind so suddenly? You went from "NEKKA IS SCUM!!!" to "I'm completely unsure who to lynch" in, what, 2 pages?

It's pathetic that nobody can come up with a reason why I'm being wagoned.

EPIC HEADDESK

[Gamma]

I AM SUPERIOR ROAR THEREFORE I WILL REFUSE TO BOW DOWN TO SUCH MORTAL INQUIRIES ROAR ONLY A SUPERIOR CASE MADE AGAINST ME WITH A PRO SUPERIOR CASE WITH QUALITIES OF SUPERIORITY (SUCH AS MYSELF) AND NOW I WILL GO AND SIMPLY REFUSE TO ANSWER QUESTIONS DESPITE BEING AT L-1 ROAR

getting tired of this ^

WALL-E YOUR EVASION TO EVEN ANSWER QUESTION MAKES ME WANT TO LYNCH YOU OUT OF PURE SPITE, TOWN OR NOT

only bold text can express my opinion of this rationale

unvote jerseygoomba, ragewatch Wall-E