In post 972, Deal With The Devil wrote:
We're three days in, why do we need to consolidate?
I could vote there, but I think I would want to get Drew's input on that.
- Alianna
well it's too late now, now is time for a gimli wagon.
also why won't you consolidate 3 days in, actually?
In post 159, Theta Alpine wrote:
i really should have slept before posting what i have
or more precisely probably should have waited for everyone to claim miller or not miller
i was kinda just going to soft claim part of my role early after i saw my pm because i found it funny but
ehh well it probably is not that bad
if everyone is miller scum probably were informed and if not scum would probably be waiting to claim anyways after seeing all of those miller claims
anyways kind of funny that i rolled desperate twice in a row
different sort of desperate from my last game but still
and with that i go sleep before i make more bad decisions
probably
we will see
In post 979, Elements wrote:
it wasn't so much the content of the posts, more the and this thing, oh and this, this too nature of them.
thought poped into head -> post immediately
oh yeah my discussion with alisae when she demanded to know why i voted her was very +town for her, i agree
In post 972, Deal With The Devil wrote:
We're three days in, why do we need to consolidate?
I could vote there, but I think I would want to get Drew's input on that.
- Alianna
well it's too late now, now is time for a gimli wagon.
also why won't you consolidate 3 days in, actually?
Still haven't gotten around to reading him lol.
I generally interpret "consolidate" as "actually start thinking about executing someone" and I don't think we are ready to actually start thinking about executing someone.
In post 982, Deal With The Devil wrote:
Still haven't gotten around to reading him lol.
I generally interpret "consolidate" as "actually start thinking about executing someone" and I don't think we are ready to actually start thinking about executing someone.
- Alianna
first of all, while i understand what you say, the only way to get out of rvs is to act as if you are out of rvs. the only way to get ready to execute someone is to act ready to execute someone. if you are voting with no intent of killing at all, your vote has less impact, and people won't react properly, so you will have less reads.
second of all, don't read him. read 938 and 947 and click the quoted posts. this should be enough of a scumcase by itself.
I have a gut sense one of these is scum
I think Elements is pretty easy to paint as scum when they are town, as illustrated by their signature. The lack of resistance by Elements doesn’t make it any better either.
if you can't name what specifically bothers you a post like this is just fearmongering -- great job!
This one is willing to concur with Gamma here actually, the sudden deluge of votes was ringing a few alarm bells even if it wasn't anywhere in flashwagon territory considering how many votes we need for a lim.
not a person, just a doll~
this one refers to itself in the third person Get To Know A Doll
there's a difference between town illogical reads and scum illogical reads and vip is definitely in the latter category. i don't think that he actually believes what he's saying. his posts strongly remind me of newbie scum trying to force reads and i don't see how town who is genuinely trying to solve could reasonably arrive at a lot of his conclusions
I am interested in this and I want more from you on this topic, because I think it wouldn't be impossible if I was giving him the benefit of the doubt out of like hope or something. But my impression right now is that I rly don't feel like his actions are coming from a mafia pov. This is a player who hasn't played mafia in a very very long time. I don't get how town is arriving at these conclusions, but I also don't get how what he is doing comes from mafia. If there is one word that comes to my mind to describe them, it would probably just be clueless.
that's the thing though, i think his reads and actions come from clueless scum and not clueless town. even if someone is town is town and hasn't played in years they're still gonna have some kind of solving vibe or at least be asking questions and trying to form reads which i'm not seeing at all from vip
his play very strongly reminds me of scum in newbie games throwing mud at a wall and seeing what sticks. he doesn't seem like newbie town with bad and outlandish reads at all. i also see his type of axiomatic thinking come from newbie scum much more than i do from newbie town
i am giving the pigeon quite a lot of benefit of the doubt with his play to be honest
and i will continue to do so for a while i think so
alter of rautherdir
as town won 5 games | lost 6 games | mislimd 3 times | dayvigged once | nightkilled 3 times | vengekilled once | survived 3 times
as scum won 5 games | lost 1 game | eliminated twice | dayvigged once | vigged once | survived once | perfect scum victory once
and if you count large normal 204 then i won that game after replacing out as scum
In post 982, Deal With The Devil wrote:
Still haven't gotten around to reading him lol.
I generally interpret "consolidate" as "actually start thinking about executing someone" and I don't think we are ready to actually start thinking about executing someone.
- Alianna
first of all, while i understand what you say, the only way to get out of rvs is to act as if you are out of rvs. the only way to get ready to execute someone is to act ready to execute someone. if you are voting with no intent of killing at all, your vote has less impact, and people won't react properly, so you will have less reads.
second of all, don't read him. read 938 and 947 and click the quoted posts. this should be enough of a scumcase by itself.
I don't like this, but I can't quite put my finger on why.
