It should be noted that this (and possibly Infinity being evil twin) are the only two pieces of information that would not be impacted by Vortox.
Yeah, this is pretty relevant and I should have distinguished.
And I checked this, vortox says "townsfolk abilities yield false info," but me learning that infinity was evil twin was part of a minion ability, not a townsfolk ability.
Does anyone know what Hu Tao's "everyone read their role PM correctly" info could mean? Since we've established that there's a Vortox, someone must have read theirs incorrectly.
I think if no one admits to having read their role PM incorrectly, I guess we can conclude that either a scum read it incorrectly or Hu Tao is scum.
In post 507, atsi wrote:
Does anyone know what Hu Tao's "everyone read their role PM correctly" info could mean? Since we've established that there's a Vortox, someone must have read theirs incorrectly.
I think if no one admits to having read their role PM incorrectly, I guess we can conclude that either a scum read it incorrectly or Hu Tao is scum.
Or someone read their PM wrong and still doesn't realize they read it wrong?
Official Gimmick List:
INVENTOR OF UPICK!
LORD OF THE 11TH HOUR!
ASEXUAL!
KING SCAR APOLOGIST!
DREAMER OF THE NE0N DREAM (SUPP 2021 LAST PLACE WINNER)!
In post 507, atsi wrote:
Does anyone know what Hu Tao's "everyone read their role PM correctly" info could mean? Since we've established that there's a Vortox, someone must have read theirs incorrectly.
I think if no one admits to having read their role PM incorrectly, I guess we can conclude that either a scum read it incorrectly or Hu Tao is scum.
Or someone read their PM wrong and still doesn't realize they read it wrong?
Then they should probably realize it after reading Hu Tao's claim and checking their role PM again.
Do you think this info could refer to you, since you thought Snake Charmer's ability was optional? That feels like a bit of a stretch, but I could kinda see it.
How Mathematician and Vortox would interact. If a Mathematician gets a 0 on the first night and there is a Vortox, does this mean that some other role besides the Mathematician must have had their ability work abnormally?
How Mathematician and Vortox would interact. If a Mathematician gets a 0 on the first night and there is a Vortox, does this mean that some other role besides the Mathematician must have had their ability work abnormally?
No. Mathematician can receive 0 in game with Vortox, without any other role being abnormal at night, but it's more because of recursion than actual common sense.
Spoiler: Why
On given example, because no other role is being Abnormal, truth answer would be 0, which is not possible answer due ability of Vortox, therefore answer must be changed, but then it means that Mathematician worked abnormally and truth answer must be 1 instead, which again can't be given due ability of Vortox. Therefore 0 result is plausable even if it would mean that Mathematician didn't work abnormal at first place due recursion resolution because answer was changed at all and 1 are not possible as it's truth in all instances regardless on how you look at recursion.
Therefore any result expect for 1 are reasonable for Mathematician to receive in this situation.
Wizard-Mercenary
You need replacement/players ASAP? PM me! I almost always accept.
In post 477, Hu Tao wrote:
Day 1
1. AniX is poisoned
2. There is a Mutant in the play.
Day 2
1. Everyone read their Role PM correctly
2. Demon are Vigormortis
@Random Nurse do you know what this could mean? We know there's a Vortox so unless Hu Tao is lying all this info must be false. Would the mod have a reason to think you read your role PM wrong?
I'm probably gonna vote PiggyGal here anyway, but if we can confirm that someone did read their role PM wrong it would give me a lot more confidence in that vote.