Veiled Committee Mafia: List Mods Edition [game over]

[camelCasedSnivy]

VOTE: Skygazer

i will not be dissuaded from my shitposts sorry

not the purpose of that

what is the purpose of that

i dayvig anyone i vote as long as i don't explain why

in reality I'm just bored and don't feel like voting anyone i scumread temporarily

[AniX]

And I'm not saying "My reads are confirmed right and you all are idiots for not immediately voting as I demand". I get people can doubt these are their roles or doubt my implications about what those role mean in terms of alignment or anything else. it's Day 1, nobody trusts anything and I'm not 100% in on any of them. But that's different from "AniX has no reads and is just talking to talk". I'm been pretty focused on talking about what roles I think people have and how we can get more roles from people this whole time.

I disagree. Roles are not indicative of alignment and therefore are a poor basis for reads.

Roles can be analyzed for likelihood of alignment and the intersection of what that means though: Like if someone has a role that interferes with voting, obviously there is no CERTAINTY (but there is rarely any certainty even with other kind of reads so that's no flaw of the read specifically) but as people have been saying, it certainly makes it LESS likely to be a scum role.

[Cook]

tbh the only other person i would want to wagon is ircher bc they were also in my ?? slot and i would like them to elaborate better


i hate being back in the spot of "idk fam" but also im still kinda shocked that it only has been 24 hours, i play mafia at the speed of light like a dummy

note to self if i ever get to be on a veiled committee mafia design board i'm going to make all of my roles have geriatric post restrictions in the hopes you rand one

that'd be funny as hell

[DkKoba]

i would like to thank random nurse for having posted in a thread for a votecounter that works with the new site

now i might actually start running games on this site again

[DkKoba]

my lightning fast meta dive establishes a baseline that maintains a scum vibe on random nurse and finds the vote appropriate now.

your move, nurse.

[Random Nurse]

isnt nurse vla

scum tend to lean into being busy to avoid needing to fake content, town tend to feel obligated to show up to keep up

1) Activity is not indicative of alignment.

2) I'm starting to read the thread so be patient.

[DkKoba]

isnt nurse vla

scum tend to lean into being busy to avoid needing to fake content, town tend to feel obligated to show up to keep up

1) Activity is not indicative of alignment.

2) I'm starting to read the thread so be patient.

the way you contribute during periods of low activity is indicative! as many here know, false promises of content are a >rand scum trait after all.

I do find it weird you are reading without contributing as you go, a bit odd for you, would you say?

[DkKoba]

lol i think nurse may have a bit of a volume tell - within both post count and post density.


we will see tho once nurse returns from the bowels of the thread while doing supposed reading and analyzing

[Cook]

what if he comes back with something good

[DkKoba]

what if he comes back with something good

then mission accomplished, player is reliably readable

[xyzzy]

votecount 1.04

happy baldur's gate 3 eve to all who celebrate

4 players voting for Random Nurse (Cook, Alisae, Doctor Drew, DkKoba)
3 players voting for DkKoba (AniX, KatyKimFanClub, Ircher)
1 player voting for AniX (Save The Dragons)
1 player voting for Doctor Drew (Ranger)
1 player voting for Alisae (Aureal)
1 player voting for Aureal (Skygazer)
1 player voting for Save The Dragons (Bingle)
1 player voting for Skygazer (camelCasedSnivy)

4 players not voting (Random Nurse, JasonWazza, Theta Alpine, DragonEater70)

with 17 votes, it takes 9 to eliminate.

mod notes: as noted in rule 19, some PMs may differ in formatting from the sample role PM in the rules. Ranger is V/LA. I interpreted 402 as a vote for Bingle and then an immediate vote for AniX, which means Bingle momentarily had two votes. re:416, doing that as soon as I post this votecount! I made the swap in the list of players but not the list of living players. that being said I generally treat pre-game replacements as though the player was always in the slot.

[DkKoba]

votecount 1.04

happy baldur's gate 3 eve to all who celebrate

3 players voting for Random Nurse (Cook, Alisae, Doctor Drew)
3 players voting for DkKoba (AniX, KatyKimFanClub, Ircher)
2 players voting for AniX (DkKoba, Save The Dragons)
1 player voting for Doctor Drew (Ranger)
1 player voting for Alisae (Aureal)
1 player voting for Aureal (Skygazer)
1 player voting for Save The Dragons (Bingle)
1 player voting for Skygazer (camelCasedSnivy)

4 players not voting (Random Nurse, JasonWazza, Theta Alpine, DragonEater70)

with 17 votes, it takes 9 to eliminate.

mod notes: as noted in rule 19, some PMs may differ in formatting from the sample role PM in the rules. Ranger is V/LA. I interpreted 402 as a vote for Bingle and then an immediate vote for AniX, which means Bingle momentarily had two votes. re:416, doing that as soon as I post this votecount! I made the swap in the list of players but not the list of living players. that being said I generally treat pre-game replacements as though the player was always in the slot.

VOTE: nurse

flashwagon, im convinced for now bc of the commitment from anix but im still keeping a very close eye on the slot and it hasnt really moved a bit + i hated nurse's entrance post right there tbh tbh

hello i am asking if the vote appearing in the votecount is correct, attached is my most recent vote

[xyzzy]

that was an error -- I pasted your name on the wrong line. fixing now!

[Skygazer]

VOTE: doctor drew

like him for scum better than any others w more votes tbh

[Skygazer]

sorry my friend

[Deal With The Devil]

VOTE: doctor drew

like him for scum better than any others w more votes tbh

Let's rock and roll

[Doctor Drew]

VOTE: doctor drew

like him for scum better than any others w more votes tbh

Let's rock and roll

This is why I can't be trusted in a hydra bah

[Theta Alpine]

lets just hope that alianna does not start hydra slipping as well or this is going to get very confusing

[Doctor Drew]

lets just hope that alianna does not start hydra slipping as well or this is going to get very confusing

Would be extra weird considering she isn't in this game lol.

[DkKoba]

this is the part where theta reveals the shadow-hydra neighborhood with aliana

[DkKoba]

VOTE: doctor drew

like him for scum better than any others w more votes tbh

went back to refresh my memory on drew baseline play bc i remember the guy is super mislim bait despite feeling p readable for me, vote feels fine, i think nurse is a good vote too, moreso so shrug.

feasible that the drew vote on nurse can be a bus one

if i had to gth solve rn - nurse/ircher/drew/wazza ? jury on anix is still out tho - hoping to see a development past trying to only purely talk mechs and discuss stances too.

[Theta Alpine]

lets just hope that alianna does not start hydra slipping as well or this is going to get very confusing

Would be extra weird considering she isn't in this game lol.

i have confused alianna with alisae

[Doctor Drew]

this is the part where theta reveals the shadow-hydra neighborhood with aliana

I had a feeling, I knew this hydra was a setup

Pre Edit: Koba have we enjoyed each others presence before?

[Theta Alpine]

anyways i am either about to have a lot more free time or little at all because i seem to have come down with something

not sure just how much that will leave me able to do tomorrow

[DkKoba]

this is the part where theta reveals the shadow-hydra neighborhood with aliana

I had a feeling, I knew this hydra was a setup

Pre Edit: Koba have we enjoyed each others presence before?

a few years back yes,
cultd3 immediately comes to mind as 1 example