Veiled Committee Mafia: List Mods Edition [game over]

[Ircher]

maybe im wrong ive read staggeringly little

but im resonating with what bingle is putting down too

counterargument: who is mafia then

(i personally have 5 slots that are unranked and potential scum but the questions stands)

I don't think this question stands. Even if we suppose AniX is mafia, there's still more mafia to find.

[KatyKimFanClub]

I try to reread the game and post thoughts in chronological order, but idk how much of my analysis is colored by having skimmed everything at least once before.

22: Assuming Ircher is referencing the 2005 playstyle on this site? Or is this something AniX is known to do?

27: Ranger "truthful" miller claim tracks with later push to massclaim, but all this really shows is that she can plan ahead. Still, I like it.

28: Cool tell honestly. Ranger claiming to be "uninspired" literally right after Koba mentions the tell (even as a joke) makes me feel good about Ranger too!

41: Legit curious about the color of everyone's PMs.

55: I know the post says "main" and maybe I'm too optimistic but I see another possibility is just that Ranger wants everyone to massclaim and getting her role out there reduces the activation energy to do so. I get to say this with the benefit of hindsight though.

79: Why?

127: Feels like a weird juncture in the game (timing-wise) for Skygazer to make his entrance in this way if he's scum. I think he's town because of that.

147: Interested if Alisae has a reason for thinking that I am easy to read later in games beyond vibes or my experience. I know other players like UP think I have like super easy towntells so that's why I asked if Alisae has played with me before.

194, 196: Seems sort of antagonistic towards StD? Not sure what to think of it. Pretty sure 196 doesn't happen without StD voting for AniX, which makes me like AniX less?

203: Post pings me as a little too straightforward of a readslist?

209: Why the fuck is DE70 hurt tagging Drew's alt lol. Is there some subliminal distancing here or something? Also why does he say 212 when he and AniX mutually townread Skygazer, Bingle, and (kinda?) Cook. Isn't that like 3/4?

220, 225: I am an idiot but but who mentioned that their roles are controlled by how people post during the day? I didn't get that sense at all so far. Massive paranoia from AniX related to Weird Dreams Mafia gives me like "caveman defrosted from block of ice and has no clue what the fuck is going on in modern society" vibes (no offense intended this is just the comparison my brain came to).

240: Nevermind I understand the paranoia now. Not sure Koba plays their daystart (and claim that their role is negative utility) if they're in a similar role bucket as AniX where they have a day posting objective though?. That being said, I don't see how we can sort people in this role bucket unless we massclaim or flip one of them first?

249: DE70 masspost seems town.

266, 268: lol'ed

271: ??? How is Blood on the Clocktower moderation related here. This feels really tenuous. Why not just paraphrase the relevant part of your role PM if you're so confident there's scum trying to activate abilities with weird posting shenanigans?

290: Assuming Theta playstyle is similar to Rauth I'm pretty confident that Theta mech-posting in this manner is really town.

-- energy depleting --

340: Interested in how these pools of players got made.

363: Idk, I think scum CCS makes a better effort here? Or at least provides some sort of additional commentary on the scumcase.

408: Who is Fenrir?

407: What exactly does towncore mean here? Seems really weird to assume that these people are all town for beefing/voting for/getting voted by AniX.

428: This post and the other earlier massclaim post flipped my opinion of AniX honestly. If we massclaim, I volunteer to be eliminated Day 1. Once I claim my role people will see why anyways.

452: A little confused by this post because isn't the Koba push (as of 452 literally two people one of which you seem to townread)?

I kinda lied about my role being negative utility? I think it's slightly negative in EV. Everyone taking a break from arguing to mechpost ~c. posts 460-470 is a vibe.

510: I agree with Bingle reasoning in 515. I think AniX is town at this point.

[KatyKimFanClub]

I think CCS is scummy but I don't think that is AI.

[Ircher]

ali either randed a good team if mafia or is simply town

*looks at PL*

i say town

The game just started. This is a strange take.

[KatyKimFanClub]

VOTE: DkKoba.

[camelCasedSnivy]

fenrir = save the dragons

[camelCasedSnivy]

also wtf is AI again i legit forgot

[Skygazer]

also wtf is AI again i legit forgot

some weird guy who does song parodies

[Ircher]

anix being scum is an easy take?

I think so.

[camelCasedSnivy]

VOTE: Skygazer

[Doctor Drew]

And I'm not saying "My reads are confirmed right and you all are idiots for not immediately voting as I demand". I get people can doubt these are their roles or doubt my implications about what those role mean in terms of alignment or anything else. it's Day 1, nobody trusts anything and I'm not 100% in on any of them. But that's different from "AniX has no reads and is just talking to talk". I'm been pretty focused on talking about what roles I think people have and how we can get more roles from people this whole time.

I disagree. Roles are not indicative of alignment and therefore are a poor basis for reads.

I agree with Ircher here, I am sure most roles 'could' go either way AI wise. And probably a few that are obv one side or another......but basing all reads on what roles people have, or what you think they have.....is a very slippery slope.

Pre Edit: AI = Alignment Indicative

[Ircher]

VOTE: DkKoba

[camelCasedSnivy]

ohhhh i thought "NAI" was something very different lmao

[Skygazer]

VOTE: Skygazer

i will not be dissuaded from my shitposts sorry

[camelCasedSnivy]

VOTE: Skygazer

i will not be dissuaded from my shitposts sorry

not the purpose of that

[Bingle]

Fenrir is STD.

AI is Alignment indicative.

[KatyKimFanClub]

Flash wagoning RN an hour after they posted they were busy with work seems kind of brutal in a game with no deadlines.

[KatyKimFanClub]

Is this some sort of olive branch between Koba / AniX factions?

[Skygazer]

VOTE: Skygazer

i will not be dissuaded from my shitposts sorry

not the purpose of that

what is the purpose of that

[Skygazer]

kkfc can be town by the way

[Bingle]

what is the purpose of that

Dissuading me from my shitposts, indirectly.

[Cook]

unrelatedly we did it town we managed to have more than 16 pages for the first 24 hours

nice

[Skygazer]

unrelatedly we did it town we managed to have more than 16 pages for the first 24 hours

nice

we did it! we managed to make a short micro's worth of posts in 24 hours with less than double the max player list of a micro

[DkKoba]

its only been 24 hours? coulda sworn we've been here like a week

[DkKoba]

ali either randed a good team if mafia or is simply town

*looks at PL*

i say town

The game just started. This is a strange take.

no it isnt, what does the time of the game having gone on have to do with anything? don't project onto me!