Pokemon Battles 2 - Attack on Giratina [GAME OVER]

[Save The Dragons]

okay but it's the truth if i were scum i probably would have been reminded by my team so i didn't look so suspicious, or I would have remembered.

just because people said "fight tina" doesn't mean I immediately went and did whatever to fight tina

[Chandra Nalaar]

unless you needed to not faint so that you could use your important night action

[Yimmy]

feel like there's a 60% chance someone is like mechanically outed scum and we're too dumb/exhausted to find it

the way d1 went down really took us down a dark timeline. let this be a lesson when the same suspects keep cropping up this early just kill one of them and sort it out later

i will go back to 100% mech-based tinfoil as soon as i have the chance

[Meuh]

just because people said "fight tina" doesn't mean I immediately went and did whatever to fight tina

This is literally what I did tbh

[Meuh]

Also yeah Merlyn's fairly likely to be town

[Meuh]

Should probably check if DGB/Titus is ever S/S

[Meuh]

I mean we're what, 8 people, 3 scum left, I'm town, Chandra and Yimmy town, shoot in the other 5 and we're okay 60% of the time

[Meuh]

I'm feeling STD's just scum here
I liked his more recent posting (day 6/7 I think 5 too?) but it's like... he had really meh content for most of the game that I felt off about, and his recent stuff feels very... safe and palatable? I'd probably need to give it a second glance but I think that progression's iffy

I think this general position + FL's treatment of him makes him flip scum like 80% of the time tbh

[Meuh]

i should just random.org between the other 5 instead of trying that sounds way more fun

Wait who's the other 5 here

[Meuh]

Is your other 5 everyone except you/Yimmy/me? or you/Yimmy/Wheme?

[Chandra Nalaar]

i was running with the idea that merlyn is town

[Meuh]

I'm feeling STD's just scum here
I liked his more recent posting (day 6/7 I think 5 too?) but it's like... he had really meh content for most of the game that I felt off about, and his recent stuff feels very... safe and palatable? I'd probably need to give it a second glance but I think that progression's iffy

I think this general position + FL's treatment of him makes him flip scum like 80% of the time tbh

I meant the weird TItus interactions more but FL's treatment of him was also not great
Pedit: ahhhh gotcha

[Meuh]

I'm fine with not limming Merlyn today

[WhemeStar]

Idk how you think I can be scum meuh

[WhemeStar]

If I’m scum I just kill you no?

[Meuh]

Huh why

[Yimmy]

cause

[Merlyn]

i really want to find squirtle as scum because im very dissatisfied with merlyns performance but i just cant

This must be what it feels like when you get a bad report card- "I'm not angry at you, just very dissatisfied with what you've done'.

[Merlyn]

I would be fine with an StD or NM lim today. If StD was avoiding going after NM it's because they're linked. I do think it's funny that StD is the only one with a vote and it's on NM- I'm wondering what will happen if the votes go up.

[Merlyn]

VOTE: Not Mafia

[$elene]

Quick Links
Current Votecount
Opening Post
Rules
Game Mechanics
Battle Demonstration

V OTECOUNT 8.2
E LIMINATION V OTES
P LAYER N AME	C URRENT V OTES
Not_Mafia (2)	Save The Dragons, Merlyn
NOT VOTING: Everyone Else
With 8 alive, it takes 5 votes to flip! Deadline: (expired on 2023-08-10 21:18:37)
Notes: You may fight the training dummy at any time.

[WhemeStar]

I fought Tina last night when I was at 3 HP, lost 1 HP there, then at night Wheme hit me and gave me a kiss which took 1 HP, I lost 1 more HP at dawn from an unknown source

If I’m scum here and your at 2 hp why do I kiss you and not just battle and kill you?

[Meuh]

I fought Tina last night when I was at 3 HP, lost 1 HP there, then at night Wheme hit me and gave me a kiss which took 1 HP, I lost 1 more HP at dawn from an unknown source

If I’m scum here and your at 2 hp why do I kiss you and not just battle and kill you?

Cause I doubt that if you're scum, you can just go around murdering as many people as you want? I feel like your power would have some restrictions around it if scum and that you wouldn't be able to just kill me like that
For what it's worth, I think you're more likely to flip town than some others, but I don't find this argument super compelling, cause it only makes sense in a world where scum have a factional kill and an unlimited vig (sure you do need to win the battle to kill, but still), in a 17 town 5 maf 1 third party game?

[Meuh]

Oh and Shirou had kill power too

[Meuh]

So on that night I had 3 hp, lost 1 to Tina, lost 1 to Wheme, then lost 1 to an unknown source, which fainted me.
Tbh, Titus and FL's flips point to me both a world where Wheme is town who just happened to attack me on that night, or that it was coordinated:
FL had a power to deal 1 damage to a player, Titus had one to deal 1-3-5 (picked randomly)
So it's likely that either Titus low-rolled, or that Wheme-FL planned to combo to faint me
But I'm not sure why Wheme-FL do that really? I don't think me fainting was worth the bad optics there. Preventing me from attacking Tina is nice I guess but probably not the call to make?