Mini Normal 2303 [Postgame!!!!]

[Black]

I mean she's obviously softing some sort of powerful role

I didn't pick this up? And I think it's really scummy of you to point a crumb out if it really is one

[Ausuka]

k

[fireisredsir]

i don't think it's scummy to point it out and she actually did hint at it early tbh

i thought both were like. laying it on a little thick and was unsure how to take them

imitial reaction was i didn't like the first one at all and thought it was overly obvious to the point where a real PR wouldn't do it and it was probably just scum. and that was part of why i voted

after seeing how she behaved a bit more i wasn't as sure. kinda think it might be something she would actually do

[Black]

Maybe it's not inherently scummy. I mean correct me if I'm wrong but I just feel like the best play would be to let Cook claim some kind of PR once she got closer to being limmed. She only has 3 votes rn I think. It's ok that you don't want to vote her but I just don't see why town!you would say that right here to defend yourself against not voting Cook

On the other hand if we leave her for D2 we possibly get utility out of the role and it's possible for us to confirm if she does happen to be town. I won't tell you what to do but my instinct is to be against killing her today

I'm wondering why this doesn't apply to T3? I'm guessing you think T3 is more likely to flip red than Cook but I don't really understand that either. We definitely don't get more information from a T3 lim

[fireisredsir]

i think i tend to find softs like that to be way more obvious than they are so idk maybe it wasn't overly obvious

but i also think that if anyone noticed then scum already knew about it bc they're actively looking for that and are more likely to see it

this is why softing (for the purpose of hoping that somehow only town notices and backs off) is kinda dumb

[Black]

Fire what are your thoughts on Cook/T3

[Ausuka]

SS can lurk his way to D2 I guess

I think we should go here

VOTE: Cook

i disagree, i'm sure i'll be much more interesting tomorrow

Personally I'm fine taking this at face value even though it is ++scum for her to say it, and we can lim her D2 if we don't like it

I don't think town win rate goes up much from limming scum day 1 anyway

No one asked me why I wasn't voting cook before I said this, so I think it pretty clearly wasn't to defend myself

I'm saying that right here because it seems like the right thing to do given that I don't trust the claim at all but also don't want to kill her today. I am pretty sure there's no way all the mafia don't see that but also like, if cook is town and gets killed by mafia, great, I don't see that as a bad outcome

[Ausuka]

It doesn't apply to T3 because to my knowledge T3 has not done like... Any of the things I am talking about in regards to cook

[Ausuka]

I went through cook's iso again and I don't see the soft

My only thought is the "mafia know something about me" thing, but I assumed that was referring to what she said later about flailing in response to pressure because I don't know how mafia would know her role so soon on d1

[iamveryhappy]

i think i tend to find softs like that to be way more obvious than they are so idk maybe it wasn't overly obvious

have you found any softs that you don't think are obvious this game?

[fireisredsir]

Fire what are your thoughts on Cook/T3

i don't especially want to lim either of them rn

[fireisredsir]

I went through cook's iso again and I don't see the soft

My only thought is the "mafia know something about me" thing, but I assumed that was referring to what she said later about flailing in response to pressure because I don't know how mafia would know her role so soon on d1

that + "they'd be taking about it in their scum pt" was what i was referring to yeah

i thought that was what that was meant to imply even if it doesn't really make any sense (it not making any sense + being too early was what made me think it was more likely to not be a real town reaction to the pressure)

[fireisredsir]

talking

[Black]

Fire what are your thoughts on Cook/T3

i don't especially want to lim either of them rn

You've posted elaborate thoughts on a few people this game. Do you have any regarding these two?

[fireisredsir]

i was feeling lazy zzz but ok fine

[Black]

You don't have to do it right now

[Black]

But I would like that

[fireisredsir]

cook like ive been saying i thought she was kinda scummy early and then i think once i got a better understanding of who she is as a player, some of the reactions vibed more as real to me. especially the bits where it felt like i could see her thought process developing over a series of posts

there were still a couple places that i didn't like tho, where it feels like she's posting thoughts that aren't real. i really didn't like the bit where she said she was too busy defending herself to think about SS, bc that just.... doesn't make any sense. the SS thoughts were after she had been defending herself, there's no point where she should have been thinking about SS but she couldnt bc she had to defend herself instead. it feeling slightly pre-emptively defensive + fake pinged me a bit. i think there were a couple more of these moments but thats the one that stands out to me

also didn't like how she sat on asri for so long and didn't seem to even remotely care about hunting for scum

i did kinda like her latest long reread post tho so eh

still don't really want to lim bc she probably resolves later but idk could be scum

[fireisredsir]

imo t3 is the scummiest of the low posters

that said im not sure if its just that my main experience with t3 is playing scum with him when he didn't really do anything

I don’t remember being scum with you but it is 12:30 AM

I’m usually a very low poster. Tbh I just find it very hard to generate good content as either alignment. I often spend 20 minutes reading through 5 pages, analyzing them, trying to best understand them, and then I walk away with nothing

for t3 i think we already kinda talked about him, the only new post i think that stood out to me was this one, just bc i don't really know how accurate this is

i haven't seen him play town lately but i had the impression of him being more on the hyperposter side of things if anything. and i felt like he was pretty self-conscious of his posting when he was scum (it was in warrior cats btw) and i think he made some excuses like this at times. thats entirely from memory i could be wrong lol

but i also don't really know why he'd lie about that lol so idk, i will look at meta later

overall i think a little less town than before but not really among my top choices for a lim

i don't quite get the insincere vibes that ausuka mentioned

[KatyKimFanClub]

Sorry, I've been a little busy with work. I know someone asked me to give my reads on Ausuka so I will do that in a bit.

[Asri Teroka]

i was feeling lazy zzz but ok fine

Whenever you have time in the coming days can you share some thoughts about Italiano and invisibility?

[fireisredsir]

italiano still feel about the same, but he's VLA and been gone for like 3 days so not really productive to push him at the moment. interested to see what he does when/if he comes back

invisibility i was actually gonna bring up recently but then got distracted. for context i was a little wary of him in rvs but then a bit later i felt like he was having good takes on things and started to feel like he was townier, like he was kinda digging into things in a way that felt like he was trying to solve

but then lately i was thinking that he's fallen off a bit and has felt more passive and reactive. the continued push on cook doesn't really feel that much like he's continuously trying to sort her based on new information, feels like he's kinda already decided

[Asri Teroka]

Thank you!

[HighPrincessErinys]

This one's gut is saying that sure whatever T3 is a fine elim?

[iamveryhappy]

interestion
I think that's like the first time anyone has to say anoything about voting T3
that or I'm blind