large normal 243: lindOVER

[MalcolmTucker]

I'm actually surprised flavor died here

Something about this I don't like. Flavor themselves said they'd be at risk of getting killed by scum. It's not a weird elimination from scum's POV, Flavor was wrong on Andante but was making an effort to solve and is a dangerous townie to leave in the game. Feels a bit fillerish this.

[Venmar]

Gimli is really townie. I'll maintain the triage of Andante/Flavor/Gimli was all active town accusing each other to a degree. Scum got lucky when Flavor got off track after his correct townread on Andante.

Did you say this triage sometime earlier in the game? If not, I can't say I like the idea of bragging/justifying a Gimli TR by lumping him in with a couple dead townies like this. Something about the vibes of that don't sit well with me, idk.

[MalcolmTucker]

Gimli is really townie. I'll maintain the triage of Andante/Flavor/Gimli was all active town accusing each other to a degree. Scum got lucky when Flavor got off track after his correct townread on Andante.

Did you say this triage sometime earlier in the game? If not, I can't say I like the idea of bragging/justifying a Gimli TR by lumping him in with a couple dead townies like this. Something about the vibes of that don't sit well with me, idk.

I'm not really sure what you mean here? Flavor/Gimli/Andante were three loud and vocal players who (if I remember correctly) were all pretty firmly on the Kitty wagon toward the end of D1. Presuming Gimli is in fact town (as I reckon they are) I'd argue they've been three influential players who were dictating the direction of the game; only problem was initial townreads on Andante which were correct ended up being doubted.

[MalcolmTucker]

Part of me wonders if I've written off Bub as town too easily so far. Probably still is town given my current scumreads but if I'm headed in the wrong direction there's a good chance Bub could be strong scum.

[Skygazer]

ok so i've thought about it and i'm outting

i'm a traffic analyst and gimli is able to communicate. with the masonry i'd normally hide this but after rereading greeting and gimli i don't really see them as masons together.

so gimli is prob scum (or a neighbor or mailman or something but probably just scum)

VOTE: gimli

[Skygazer]

just played a game with scum bub and i think they'd be more obvious if they were scum here

[Venmar]

CKD's #3380 bothered me for a somewhat similar reason, i'm usually a bit sus of those who gloat about dead townies looking towny before they died, or fluff posting about them like CKD did.

Ninja'd, @Malcolm: I townread Gimli as well, but deciding he's town because Andante/Flavor flipped town and cause Gimli was/is vocal like them feels like an informed way of throwing him in your townpile, is kind of what I'm trying to say.

[MalcolmTucker]

Y'all posting this much on Easter Sunday is an attack on my religious liberty.

I'm willing to jump on the Kitty wagon in a minute but I need to catch on the ten (10!) pages that happened since and do a quick vibe-check iso on Kitty. They didn't ping me at all through the day...but looking back they posted on a lot which kind of suggests something.

Like something about this doesn't sit well with me in retrospect. Bub was willing to jump on the Kitty wagon "in a minute" but also needed to check Kitty at the same time. And what does Kitty posting a lot suggest? I feel like a lot of Bub's posts were much more fully-formed and it's like they wanted to briefly stall in the hope the wagon went away, or even do a quick check of Kitty's ISO to see whether there was any way they could even attempt a townread, before realising there wasn't.

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: gimli

[Enchant]

VOTE: Gimli

Hilariously i wanted to vote here.

... No really.

................

[MalcolmTucker]

CKD's #3380 bothered me for a somewhat similar reason, i'm usually a bit sus of those who gloat about dead townies looking towny before they died, or fluff posting about them like CKD did.

Ninja'd, @Malcolm: I townread Gimli as well, but deciding he's town because Andante/Flavor flipped town and cause Gimli was/is vocal like them feels like an informed way of throwing him in your townpile, is kind of what I'm trying to say.

It's not specifically why I thought Gimli was town, just in general their posting has felt very townie and their relationship in the game to other town players is an important factor in that.

[Save The Dragons]

CKD is still spewed town by kitty

[MalcolmTucker]

ok so i've thought about it and i'm outting

i'm a traffic analyst and gimli is able to communicate. with the masonry i'd normally hide this but after rereading greeting and gimli i don't really see them as masons together.

so gimli is prob scum (or a neighbor or mailman or something but probably just scum)

VOTE: gimli

Believe your claim, but I'm crap at these mechanics, can you explain how Gimli being able to communicate makes them look scummy? Is the argument essentially that they'd have to be mason in this scenario and you don't reckon that's the case?

[Gimli]

lmao im vt

[Gimli]

i dont have any of that stuff

sky im gonna flip your lame ass fakeclaims again

[Skygazer]

aight UNVOTE:

reaction test over

[MalcolmTucker]

i dont have any of that stuff

sky im gonna flip your lame ass fakeclaims again

Why would Sky fakeclaim solely to eliminate you if you turned out to be town?

[MalcolmTucker]

aight UNVOTE:

reaction test over

wat

[Save The Dragons]

wait what

[Skygazer]

i rlly scumread gimli here but dont know how to push it so i was hoping i could get him to fumble panic and claim something stupid

[Skygazer]

felt safe doing so bc he's def not mason

[Gimli]

aight UNVOTE:

reaction test over

is sheep your strongman?

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: bub

[Enchant]

aight UNVOTE:

reaction test over

This is like shittiest reaction test of reaction tests.

[Gimli]

you made me out as vt, sky

you reduced their JKer pool

this was horrible I hope you're scum