TM 2023 | Super Mario Bros Mafia | Game Over!

[wgeurts]

also I agree the peta reads are sudden

but not so much a 'where is this all of a sudden'

more like tis been simmering since peta's been not active and it would be VERY INTERESTING to see wgeurts flip, cuz if theyre scum Ill take peta as conftown

Got 7 more pages to go, but do I need to lure you off my wagon with more tasty temptations?

[Fate]

im down to wagon anyone thats not obviosuly town

i mean thats how the game is won bois

[Adorable]

I'm lost in this game and my teammates are mia.

[wgeurts]

im down to wagon anyone thats not obviosuly town

i mean thats how the game is won bois

Counterpoint:

Sichuanese boiled beef

[wgeurts]

Okay I somehow fucked up that spoiler formatting

[wgeurts]

{CSF}
{Radical Rat, Petapan, Jingle}
{Adorable, Fate}
{Cerb}
{Porkens}
{HPE}

Page 13 rn, these are my current reads. Will be giving in-depth thoughts once done.

[Fate]

I can read this spoiler tags on my phone goddamnt

[Fate]

I also refuse to share a tier with adorable, I've been way scummier

[wgeurts]

I also refuse to share a tier with adorable, I've been way scummier

I have a few things I'll get into that make it slightly more likely for you to fall town than scum, likewise with adorable. Honest to god I don't know how to properly handle either of your playstyles though.

[wgeurts]

Not caught up my list is

HPE
Adorbs
Rat

CSF
Cerb
Porkens

Fate

Wgeurts
Peta

Not done yet, but straight up what on earth have Cerb/Porkens/HPE done to earn those positions? Your readslist makes it feel like I'm reading a completely different game to you.

[wgeurts]

Like, Cerb has quite demonstrably given little to nothing of value and a lot of it is wordy but not at all substantive. I cannot for the life of me follow HPE's progression, but can think of a relatively clear scum motivated one. It's reactively forming a lot of opinions. You rank Fate low and then say you think he's abrasive town and that Koba is worried they're going to get mislynched?

And then finally just karma check Porkens for town when he's done nothing whatsoever?

[wgeurts]

Oh wait I misread, those are Koba's reads. I want whatever koba is on man.

[HighPrincessErinys]

Rat {polarized slot showing off towny bits, genuine curiosity, team engagement}
HPE {proactive, lots of references when discussing reads, evidence behind thoughts, natural progression}

CSF {passion, vibe read, mindmeld}
Cerb {initial bad vibes but good since, solvey, fluid, willing to be shown he's wrong}
Adorbs {No idea how to read but logic is solid behind what's been shared, overall towny vibes} (I'm not entirely sure what this means, but I think Koba thinks that Adorable's perspective is a reasonable one to exist, not that Koba thinks Adorable is explicitly right given the context)

Fate {kinda cringey at points, but just generically abrasive towny who don't give no fucks.} Koba thinks HPE is conflating bad push with scum here and thinks Fate should ISO. Contextually I think that means Fate should ISO HPE? I can check if you want clarification
Porkens {engaged and towny energy, pass for D1}

Peta {BoP about scummy, calls him flaccid , nothing to townread in his posts. Overall low substance and small scope given the team and the small size of the game.}
Wgeurts {fell off in activity from not a great start. Buncha Nothingburger}

These are Koba's reads.

Not caught up my list is

HPE
Adorbs
Rat

CSF
Cerb
Porkens

Fate

Wgeurts
Peta

I'm only really townreading the top three on my list. Meanwhile I'm actively scumreading the bottom two and leaning scum on Fate. I'm back, btw.

These are Jingle's reads.

[wgeurts]

-snip-

Nevermind I need whatever your whole team is taking.

[HighPrincessErinys]

Like, Cerb has quite demonstrably given little to nothing of value and a lot of it is wordy but not at all substantive. I cannot for the life of me follow HPE's progression, but can think of a relatively clear scum motivated one. It's reactively forming a lot of opinions. You rank Fate low and then say you think he's abrasive town and that Koba is worried they're going to get mislynched?

And then finally just karma check Porkens for town when he's done nothing whatsoever?

This one would ask what you think about their peta read since it's also opposite yours but you're going to give your full thoughts in a bit anywho.

[wgeurts]

I've had brewing suspicions on him for a while now, mostly because early game he seemed to be actively avoiding doing content, so I'll bite there. I don't necessarily think you're right, but peta being actually scummy to me and doubling as a sanity check on the very stylish hat sounds good.

VOTE: petapan

Okay I disagree with this and want to talk this over with you, more later.

[Fate]

I'm satisfied enough

VOTE: petapan

[wgeurts]

I'm satisfied enough

VOTE: petapan

what

[wgeurts]

I do not understand the peta scum reads can anyone lay it out for me? I've read the whole thread, and Jingle seems to be like death-tunnelled on the slot, whilst others seem to just be seeing something completely contrary to what I'm seeing.


Meanwhile HPE has LITERALLY just positioned themselves AGAIN to bounce if they need be. They town read Petapan in both 261 and 162, have completely unannounced said they now scum read them, asking others to do the explaining. Previously they also softened their scum read of me as it didn't like it was going anywhere, until people picked it up again, and also magically positions to dislike Porkens when others start mentioning the slot but doesn't do anything with it.

How is this town behaviour.

Am I delirious?

I can't believe it's page 17 and I'm going to have to post my first ISO

deathtunnel

case

[wgeurts]

Like this is why I have a spreadsheet tracking literally everything people say on anybody and get mad at people with null reads. Null reads for no reason are a lame excuse for laziness or malice.

Peta went from "most" liked to scum literally only because others are doing the same. This slot is just looking for something to stick: they've angled on me, Porkens, Fate, and Peta now and have no indication that they're considering that something must be wrong in their line of thought to end up there.

[HighPrincessErinys]

I do not understand the peta scum reads can anyone lay it out for me? I've read the whole thread, and Jingle seems to be like death-tunnelled on the slot, whilst others seem to just be seeing something completely contrary to what I'm seeing.

Meanwhile HPE has LITERALLY just positioned themselves AGAIN to bounce if they need be. They town read Petapan in both 261 and 162, have completely unannounced said they now scum read them, asking others to do the explaining. Previously they also softened their scum read of me as it didn't like it was going anywhere, until people picked it up again, and also magically positions to dislike Porkens when others start mentioning the slot but doesn't do anything with it.

How is this town behaviour.

Am I delirious?

I can't believe it's page 17 and I'm going to have to post my first ISO

deathtunnel

case

Where did this one start scumreading petapan? It asked others to explain their cases. This one also pivoted to Fate to try and wring posts out of them, not because of (presumably) "it not going anywhere". Stop putting words into my mouth.

[HighPrincessErinys]

This isn't your first time misconstruing my posts this game and it's VERY hard to see the town in you when you do it again and so blatantly.

[wgeurts]

{CSF}
{Radical Rat,

Petapan

, Jingle}
{Adorable, Fate}
{Cerb}
{Porkens}
{HPE}

Page 13 rn, these are my current reads. Will be giving in-depth thoughts once done.

This one would ask what you think about their peta read

since it's also opposite yours

but you're going to give your full thoughts in a bit anywho.

Bullshit, you are such a liar

You literally just said your read is "opposite" to mine. My read on Peta has been town the entire game. You scum read me when it was convenient, then started walking it back by saying my recent posting looked town, just to go back when it was convenient. This is all you have done with all your reads the entire damn game, and now you're outright lying.

VOTE: HPE
VOTE: HPE
VOTE: HPE

[wgeurts]

Like, I don't want to see a single other post from anyone unless they can either:

A - Point out that I'm losing my mind
B - Vote this shit

[Fate]

Again, I'll kill anyone not town

Null reads are worthy for death