Xyl's Relative Chaos - Game over!

[animorpherv1]

Very well, I will claim, but just to tell, Korts voted me for the exact same reason I got bandwagonned, he just wants a claim. And I'm sure he's not the only one doing so voting for me.

He wouldn't have done that if you claimed earlier.

I am a so called "Jack of all trades". I have several very different night abilities, all one shot, and one used per night.

As in? I'm not going to fully belive this untill I see more detail.

[dahill1]

DC, you were honest with us in your reasoning but that doesn't justify it not being scummy. voting just for a claim even when you don't suspect the person is scummy.
anyways, i believe the claim enough that we shouldn't lynch DC today, IMO.
also, animorph stop rolefishing it's pretty obv what some of the abilities are

[DoomCow]

Very well, I will claim, but just to tell, Korts voted me for the exact same reason I got bandwagonned, he just wants a claim. And I'm sure he's not the only one doing so voting for me.

He wouldn't have done that if you claimed earlier.

And I wouldn't have claimed before being at minus 1. Hence the term "pressure vote"

I am a so called "Jack of all trades". I have several very different night abilities, all one shot, and one used per night.

As in? I'm not going to fully belive this untill I see more detail.

[/quote] And I won't give more detail. Why would I give scum full access to my role? I have some one shot abilities, which I can use one at night if I choose. I'm not willing to reveal what they are. I do have some willing to survive the night you know...

[Korts]

Very well, I will claim, but just to tell, Korts voted me for the exact same reason I got bandwagonned, he just wants a claim. And I'm sure he's not the only one doing so voting for me.

Wrong. I also was comfortable lynching you, while you stated that you weren't comfortable with a CC lynch. Voting CC to a claim while you don't want him lynched is scummy, and I don't see why you're trying to turn this on me.

Considering your claim, however. It can be confirmed. Do you have a kill? (yes I know this is rolefishing technically.) If you do have a kill, you should shoot tonight, and shoot the person that the town chooses.

also, animorph stop rolefishing it's pretty obv what some of the abilities are

I don't see how that's the case. The abilities of Jacks of All Trades can vary depending on mod/setup/whatever. But I do agree with you; it should not be said what each and every ability is.

Also, I still don't feel animo's contribution levels being adequate. His comments are basically about minor matters almost each and every time, exception is his latest about what exactly DC's abilities are (massive rolefish by the way, kudos to dahill).

unvote, vote: animorpherv

[Korts]

Wait, nevermind the claim of kill or no kill. If you do, shoot. If you don't, there's plenty of chances for you to trip up.

[hasdgfas]

And Hasdfgas, about your last post: If you're convincesd that what you quote is worthy of asking why an unvote, then why not a vote for it? From that post, it seems you want people to keep him a target, so why not put your action where your mouth is?

because I wanted a claim from you first as I still found you scummier. But due to the claim,

unvote, vote: CC09

[farside22]

DC: Some of the votes may move fast do to a deadline where day 2 can be as short as 2 weeks if we dont' agree on someone.

FOS: Animph for role fishing

unvote
vote: CC09

3rd party lynch is good.

[Xylthixlm]

Vote Count

CoheedCambria09 -

6

(dahill1, tubby216, DoomCow, Natirasha, hasdgfas, farside22)
DoomCow -

4

(SpyreX, animorpherv1, Vi, CoheedCambria09)
tubby216 -

1

(ZazieR)
Korts -

1

(Crazy)
animorpherv1 -

1

(Korts)

Not voting: MafiaSSK, DrippingGoofball

With 15 alive, it will take 8 to lynch. The deadline for day 1 will be Saturday, December 13.

[dahill1]

Considering your claim, however. It can be confirmed. Do you have a kill? (yes I know this is rolefishing technically.) If you do have a kill, you should shoot tonight, and shoot the person that the town chooses.

DC shouldn't answer this, and even if he does we most certainly shouldn't guide him.

[Korts]

Considering your claim, however. It can be confirmed. Do you have a kill? (yes I know this is rolefishing technically.) If you do have a kill, you should shoot tonight, and shoot the person that the town chooses.

DC shouldn't answer this, and even if he does we most certainly shouldn't guide him.

I know, I've reconsidered. See my very next post after that comment.

[SpyreX]

Wait a sec. What just happened?

I'm not seeing why I'm guilty for being honest. I did a blatant bandwagon vote, pushing for a claim, I confirmed my reasoning for it (twice), and in less thatn 24 hours after that (with several players not able to post during it), got from 2 votes to 6.

I'm happy with my vote where it is, and I'm not that convinced I should claim, since I was honest about my motivations. One more vote will probably force me to claim, and I probably will, but I find this a bit fast.

Again, I never made it unclear that I wanted the claim, and I wasn't willing to believe it. Also, I haven't seen any real reasoning in the votes against me, besides "he wants a claim". CC was already at 6 votes without mine, that made it cleadr he seemed scum to most of town, and thus that a claim was wanted. I merely responded to that.

And Hasdfgas, about your last post: If you're convincesd that what you quote is worthy of asking why an unvote, then why not a vote for it? From that post, it seems you want people to keep him a target, so why not put your action where your mouth is?

This reads like a scum manifesto.

1.) Says that it was a bandwagon vote for the sole purpose of pushing for a claim. (Not because he thought he was scum)
2.) Alludes to the speed of the wagon on him being because he's town.
3.) Sees no reason nor problem with pushing for a claim on the basis of a claim on not because the target was scummy.
4.) Justifies the bandwagon vote under the premise of "everyone else thinks he is scummy"
5.) Throws some dirt at has.

So, thats bad enough, but:

Very well, I will claim, but just to tell, Korts voted me for the exact same reason I got bandwagonned, he just wants a claim. And I'm sure he's not the only one doing so voting for me.

I am a so called "Jack of all trades". I have several very different night abilities, all one shot, and one used per night.

1.) Korts did what I did defense.
2.) He doesn't give ANY information about his role. Considering my own I would eat my hat if his role is "Jack of all trades". Gives no information on the types of abilities - this is about as vague a claim as you can get.

Then anim gets attackedish for wanting more information.. and this is the reply.

And I won't give more detail. Why would I give scum full access to my role? I have some one shot abilities, which I can use one at night if I choose. I'm not willing to reveal what they are. I do have some willing to survive the night you know...

If this isn't setting up a reason for him to be alive tomorrow even with a PR claim I dont know what is.

On top of it all the OP has the "goddamn batman" which sets a precedent for mult-role abilities and considering the fact its called the "goddam batman" really makes me doubt ANY of this has any truth in it.

Votes staying.

[farside22]

Considering your claim, however. It can be confirmed. Do you have a kill? (yes I know this is rolefishing technically.) If you do have a kill, you should shoot tonight, and shoot the person that the town chooses.

DC shouldn't answer this, and even if he does we most certainly shouldn't guide him.

I know, I've reconsidered. See my very next post after that comment.

Korts do you feel we should keep looking for scum or lynch a 3rd party right now?

Also FOS Korts for rolefishing.

Please stop.

[Korts]

He doesn't give ANY information about his role. Considering my own I would eat my hat if his role is "Jack of all trades".

Consider this a counter-claim?

[animorpherv1]

It's possible to get something else, I'd think, thats why I asked, not to role fish, just to make sure.

unvote, vote: CC09

beacuse he's 3rd p[arty. I'd rather see a scum lynch, but 3rd party is good enough.

[farside22]

He doesn't give ANY information about his role. Considering my own I would eat my hat if his role is "Jack of all trades".

Consider this a counter-claim?

That is pretty vague comment to make if he is. Also I don't want DC to state everything, but if people think it's helps some more info might be needed, but I think info helps scum in this case.

[Korts]

Considering your claim, however. It can be confirmed. Do you have a kill? (yes I know this is rolefishing technically.) If you do have a kill, you should shoot tonight, and shoot the person that the town chooses.

DC shouldn't answer this, and even if he does we most certainly shouldn't guide him.

I know, I've reconsidered. See my very next post after that comment.

Korts do you feel we should keep looking for scum or lynch a 3rd party right now?

Also FOS Korts for rolefishing.

Please stop.

Did I say I reconsidered before DC could reply? Also, I wasn't asking for a full description of the abilities, that wouldn't benefit town as much as it would scum. But a claimed kill could be confirmed or denied in theory.

Also, I feel that we shouldn't end the day just yet. I'm good for lynching CC if we don't have any better options, but a third party lynch is a compromise, basically.

[Korts]

It's possible to get something else, I'd think, thats why I asked, not to role fish, just to make sure.

unvote, vote: CC09

beacuse he's 3rd p[arty. I'd rather see a scum lynch, but 3rd party is good enough.

What'd I tell you, farside? See this post for scum.

[SpyreX]

No its not a counter claim - its saying that it doesn't match any of the flavor we've been given and I think there's a reason for that.

[farside22]

Considering your claim, however. It can be confirmed. Do you have a kill? (yes I know this is rolefishing technically.) If you do have a kill, you should shoot tonight, and shoot the person that the town chooses.

DC shouldn't answer this, and even if he does we most certainly shouldn't guide him.

I know, I've reconsidered. See my very next post after that comment.

Korts do you feel we should keep looking for scum or lynch a 3rd party right now?

Also FOS Korts for rolefishing.

Please stop.

Did I say I reconsidered before DC could reply? Also, I wasn't asking for a full description of the abilities, that wouldn't benefit town as much as it would scum. But a claimed kill could be confirmed or denied in theory.

Also, I feel that we shouldn't end the day just yet. I'm good for lynching CC if we don't have any better options, but a third party lynch is a compromise, basically.

Were at L-1.
How long to you plan on using up this day and making tomorrow shorter for us?

[Korts]

A couple days more of discussion shouldn't hurt, in my irrelevant opinion. Here's my proposition. if the town doesn't find a better wagon in 48 hours, I will hammer.

[farside22]

No its not a counter claim - its saying that it doesn't match any of the flavor we've been given and I think there's a reason for that.

SpreX is correct. Man I need to read more. DC needs to explain more.

[dahill1]

No its not a counter claim - its saying that it doesn't match any of the flavor we've been given and I think there's a reason for that.

and you think squashed banana does??

[farside22]

A couple days more of discussion shouldn't hurt, in my irrelevant opinion. Here's my proposition. if the town doesn't find a better wagon in 48 hours, I will hammer.

Holiday makes me itchy. Also i missed something till SpreX pointed it out I retract my comment.

unvote:
vote: DC
FOS: Animph
Support 3rd lynch.

Yay

[Korts]

No its not a counter claim - its saying that it doesn't match any of the flavor we've been given and I think there's a reason for that.

SpreX is correct. Man I need to read more. DC needs to explain more.

So I went back and reread my own Role PM. If any other player's PM is like mine, and judging from reactions, SpyreX and farside at least do have similar PMs, then DC is bullshitting. See, I was on the verge of hammering CC a moment ago. Now, the DC wagon is getting back on track. How cool is that, that waiting has its benefits, farside?

unvote, vote: DoomCow

[dahill1]

don't support a DC lynch today
do support a CC/animorph lynch today