Night Watch Open 95 - Game Over before 703

[Haschel Cedricson]

Fair enough.

[afatchic]

unvote

Pretty self explanatory at this point.

Explain anyway.

Er... O.K.

bio = random vote.

my post = unvote random vote.

so you don't have any top suspects, or anyone worthy of a vote after 11 pages?

[afatchic]

UNVOTE

What you were doing THEN merited a vote.. but I like what you have delivered since.
And it's no personality change. I just needed a third. And then the Coug got me all worked up.

@afatchic.. do you have any other suspects .. . other than OP?

TCS- like hascel said, he hasn't done anything overly scummy, but he has done a lot of minor things noteworthy.

Bio- im still not sure about him. he could very well be an over eager townie. he has done well defending himself these past few pages.

theres my top three...

[orangepenguin]

unvote

Pretty self explanatory at this point.

Explain anyway.

Er... O.K.

bio = random vote.

my post = unvote random vote.

so you don't have any top suspects, or anyone worthy of a vote after 11 pages?

See 50 posts before this one (post 226). I'm just not going to throw my vote out there so aimlessly. I want it to be justified and everything. *shrug*

[Haschel Cedricson]

BTW I hid behind orangepanda last night. I will hide behind bionicchop tonight.

[ortolan]

^^ lol

How about instead of "most likely to be lynched," you point out the player that you think should be lynched.

Have you been reading? Haschel asked for a summary- I said I'd give him one from memory. It was intended to be objective rather than personal opinion and I forgot that bionicchop2 had surpassed you in votes. The post was not an attempt to give my "opinion".

This looks like one of those soft, trying-to-appear-in-the-game posts that I really don't like, because if the situation arose you could jump onto my bandwagon and say that this post was tantamount to a FOS, but otherwise you've really made no contribution to the game.

No, it's apparent what the purpose of the post was if you'd been reading- to comply with Haschel's request. I don't accept your criticism as it clearly shouldn't be treated as a "normal post". As I'm currently probably most likely to vote for you, when I do I can assure you I'll give reasons.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Also,

unvote, vote:orangepenguin

as I'm still seeing zero content from him.

[Xtoxm]

Also,

unvote, vote:orangepenguin

as I'm still seeing zero content from him.

What makes you think he is scummy?

[The Central Scrutinizer]

The totality of OP's contribution:

/confirm.

-

I don't see what's wrong with random voting either. I don't see how Crazy knowing that it's a night start is a valid case, because he obviously knew about the set up beforehand, if he voted for it in the set-up thread.

-

I'm more worried about where the first bio is.. Sad

vote:bionocchi2

-

I am not the humorless villian. I am the waddle-talking serious pro-town penguin.

-

I hid behind Xtoxm last night and will hide behind ortolan tonight.

-
I think they're saving you for later, IMO. Getting the idea that you're scummy out there, so they can set up a lynch on you later, assuming you're town and they are scum. If they aren't scum, then I don't think they're doing that, but just my interpretation.

There's a term for that in the wiki some place. Forgot what it's called. But it has something to do with spreading a lie enough that people start to believe that it is true.

That would be it.

-

TCS is at L-3. I don't like his comment that he's sure me or Panda are scum, especially after only 6 pages. He must have a thing against exotic animals. I bet the cougar is next on his list.

EBWOP: Well, make that 7 pages, besides the fact that it was 6 when he made the comment.

-
Care to explain your vibe and suspicions at all?

-

I prefer replacing over lal, especially in cases like Panda, where he obviously just left the site..instead of..active lurking.

-

My one liner about lurkers wasn't even a response to your comment.

10) I only questioned him because his reasonings were stupid and random, and sounded like they were jokes. Not because he said I was scum, even though that caught my attention.

My top three suspects?
You/cammn/TCS. I don't really have a top suspect, but the four of you look kind of suspicious. cammn mainly because I disagree with his insistence to lynch lurkers, TCS because his odd reasonings (which might be omgus, but irregardless..c'mon!), and you. Wink

-

Heh, I guess. I don't think that it's a valid argument against you, moreso that I disagree on that.

And was it a addition fail? Wink Or did I purposely left out my real top suspect? (or more likely, penguins = bad at math )

-

unvote

Pretty self explanatory at this point.

-

Er... O.K.

bio = random vote.

my post = unvote random vote.

-

See 50 posts before this one (post 226). Wink I'm just not going to throw my vote out there so aimlessly. I want it to be justified and everything. *shrug*

In-depth summary of the above:

orangepenguin: hai
orangepenguin: nah
orangepenguin: lol vote:bionicchip2
orangepenguin: sad face
orangepenguin: kk i does stuff
orangepenguin: i can has wiki
orangepenguin: who me?
orangepenguin: leave the lurkers alone
orangepenguin: i don't want to scumhunt, i just want to weakly fos people already under suspicion
orangepenguin: unvotes... ir serious now
orangepenguin: kk i does stuff

[afatchic]

man i think your PBPA is a lil better than mine! but either way its what i was trying to say!

[camn]

a lurker by any other name.......still should hang.

I'd rather see an OP lynch than Bio... on principle.

[afatchic]

a lurker by any other name.......still should hang.

I'd rather see an OP lynch than Bio... on principle.

its not that he is lurking... but rather active lurking. its quite apparent he is here since he comments daily, yet he has added no content and done nothing to help the game along.

[orangepenguin]

So basically all I amount to is a policy lynch? That's going to benefit the town for sure.

Vote: TCS

[afatchic]

So basically all I amount to is a policy lynch? That's going to benefit the town for sure.

Vote: TCS

can you please explain where you get policy lynch from? and also why don't you try and back up your voe with something other than OMGUS. he voted you for the same reason i did, so why haven't i gotten a vote yet?

[Jex]

Vote Count

2 - orangepenguin (afatchic, The Central Scrutinizer)
2 - The Central Scrutinizer (Haschel Cedricson, orangepenguin)
1 - bionicchop2 (icemanE)
1 - Crazy (Xtoxm)
1 - icemanE (bionicchop2)
1 - camn (Crazy)

Not Voting

ortolan, camn, StrangerCoug

It takes 6 votes to lynch

Deadline is Nov 28th

[Jex]

I was just looking at the calendar and will push the deadline to December 5th so that it doesn't happen around Thanksgiving weekend.

[The Central Scrutinizer]

So basically all I amount to is a policy lynch? That's going to benefit the town for sure.

Vote: TCS

I didn't say anything about the "lynch all lurkers" policy. You're not lurking, and we're not screaming "post or perish!" You're posting and pretending to do stuff while quite clearly doing nothing. And as much as I don't like leaning on OMGUS, I've never seen one so blatant as here. So I think you to be worth my continued vote.

[Haschel Cedricson]

So basically all I amount to is a policy lynch? That's going to benefit the town for sure.

Vote: TCS

The only way the case on you is a "policy lynch" is if you agree that you are active lurking. Is this true?

[afatchic]

So basically all I amount to is a policy lynch? That's going to benefit the town for sure.

Vote: TCS

The only way the case on you is a "policy lynch" is if you agree that you are active lurking. Is this true?

im gonna try and make this as simple as possible.
Active Lurking = extremely scummy.
Orangepenguin = Active Lurker
Lynching Active Lurker =/= Policy Lynch
therefore:
Lynching OP =/= Policy lynch.

does that make sense?

im voting you and want a lynch on you because i think you are scum, not because you are lurking. TCS never said lynch the lurker, he said lynch the one pretending to help.

[bionicchop2]

@ haschel - I am satisfied with your follow ups to your summary requests. For now I believe it was genuine scum hunting. I think it is flawed, but all scum hunting is flawed at least a little.


There is a decent case behind this OP wagon. Going to hold my vote on icemanE a little longer, but there doesn't seem to be anybody agreeing with me ATM.

@crazy - really need more participation from you. I don't remember you being this inactive last time we played in the same game. For someone who really liked the setup, you don't seem to be paying attention to it.

[camn]

OP.. do you have ANYTHING to say in your defense?

[StrangerCoug]

Active Lurking = extremely scummy.
Orangepenguin = Active Lurker
Lynching Active Lurker =/= Policy Lynch
therefore:
Lynching OP =/= Policy lynch.

I'm not normally a fan of lynching lurkers since they'll be prodded and replaced if they don't post, but I agree with your logic here. If you think active lurking is scummy, then by all means go after people engaging in it.

I need to reread OP to see if I want to vote him. I think he's as much of a lynch magnet than I am, but he was scum in one game I've played with him where he had been lurking.

[StrangerCoug]

OK, here's my two sense after looking at this OP guy:

I think they're saving you for later, IMO. Getting the idea that you're scummy out there, so they can set up a lynch on you later, assuming you're town and they are scum. If they aren't scum, then I don't think they're doing that, but just my interpretation.

It's hard for me to picture town theorizing about scum motives like this. What I'm getting from this post is that orangepenguin knows ortolan is town and therefore is trying to distance from a mislynch.

So basically all I amount to is a policy lynch? That's going to benefit the town for sure.

Vote: TCS

This is OMGUS.

Vote: orangepenguin

[Xtoxm]

I don't get this OP wagon.

I still quite like my vote...

[icemanE]

Yeah, the OP wagon seems like it's just... there... without any reason to be there...