Newbie 689 - Game Over - Town Wins

[Hoopla]

Interesting kill choice by over9000. Props to idea for making a save on the first night though. As cop I investigated over9000 for this night just to confirm he is the final mafia member, which he is.

vote: over9000

[Arafax]

VOTE COUNT

over9000 (1) - Hoopla

Takes 4 to lynch

[TAX]

vote:over9000

I believe that Hoopla is cop. If we kill over and he is town we can just kill Hoopla day four. Hoopla, you said that over was the final maf member but I don't know who the second is. Did I miss something?

[Hoopla]

I meant MMAM was the first (who I got a guilty on), so over9000 is the final mafia member. It's just a wording thing really.

[TAX]

EBWOP never mind we can just kill him day four part of my post, because if over is town there will be no day four.

Unvote

for now just to have time to sort everything out. The God dam IC need to get here soon.

[Hoopla]

Why wouldn't there be a day four?

[TAX]

If over is is town, we kill him that makes 3 town, 2 maf. Then nk by maf game over for town.

[Hoopla]

You know we've killed MMAM right, who was mafia? There are only two...

[TAX]

Theirs 3 mafia.

[TAX]

EBWOP never mind my mistake.

[TAX]

vote:over9000

[TAX]

Can we get a prod of MSSK and VM.

[Arafax]

VOTE COUNT

over9000 (2) - Hoopla, TAX

Takes 4 to lynch

Will send prods if they don't post within 24 hours of the day beginning.

[_over9000]

Damn

*comes out as mafia*

I'm pretty much screwed either way. I knew there was something up when Hoopla claimed he got guilty on SSK, but I figured he was just a confused townie.

Good game, guys.

vote: _over9000

[Arafax]

VOTE COUNT

over9000 (3) - Hoopla, TAX, over9000

Takes 4 to lynch

[VisMaior]

Why on earth have you counterclaimed then? That makes no sense...

vote over9000

[Hoopla]

Why on earth have you counterclaimed then? That makes no sense...

vote over9000

It wasn't that bad of a play by over9000. The reason I lied about my investigation was to try and catch out MafiaSSK

if

he were scum. If he counterclaimed me, then I'd have caught both of them. If he didn't it would have been a couple of townie points for him.

As far as over9000 goes it wasn't a bad idea to claim cop. There were 8 people left in the game - he knew I was lying about my results (and at this stage both mafia members were unconfirmed). If he claimed cop and said he got an innocent, the smart town play would be to lynch the player we have a guilty on (MafiaSSK). Then when MafiaSSK would have flipped town, I would have been lynched the next day for lying. The mafia get night 2 and 3 to make kills and then win on day 4, with 4 alive. It wasn't a stupid play by over9000.

Good game though everyone, I had fun. Out of curiousity, who did idea save on night 1? Or did mafia just fail to make a kill?

[VisMaior]

Yes it was. He counterclaims he is limiting our choices to you or him. He keeps silent, we lynch SSK and/or you. He wins.

[Hoopla]

If he was thinking I wasn't the cop or was lying as the cop, claiming would add further credibility to him and he could orchestrate a lynch however he wished, particularly the next day. I understand what you're saying though. It would have been a lot safer staying low and hoping I'd be lynched for lying the next day.

Although, if I didn't get a cop counterclaim, I would have come clean before MafiaSSK was lynched and told the town what I was trying to do. But that would have made it a completely different game.

[Arafax]

VOTE COUNT

over9000 (4) - Hoopla, TAX, over9000, VisMaior

That's a lynch.

As he stated,

_over9000

is

Scum - Mafia Roleblocker

The Game is over. Details coming.....

[Arafax]

Player Roles:

idea - Sane Doctor
Hoopla - The Cop
makemeameteor - Mafia Goon
_over9000 - Mafia Role Blocker

The rest of you we Vanilla Townies

Night Choices:

Night 1:

Mafia killed Hoopla. The Doc saved Hoopla. The Cop checked makemeameteor.

Night 2:

Mafia kills idea. The Doc tried to save VisMaior. The Cop checked over9000.

The Cop (Hoopla) was a perfect 2 for 2, while idea made a crucial save as the Doc Night 1. Good job to those special roles. You def won the game for the town.

Good job everyone. Thanks for playing and I hope to see you in another game sometime.

[Hoopla]

Thanks for modding Arafax, I appreciate it a lot! Well done to the town, and especially idea for saving me night 1!

Arafax, how did you think we played as town? I felt like we were kind of going around in circles, the IC's infrequent activity didn't help, but overall no replacements needed - that must be rare. The lynch of Waffles didn't help heaps, but I don't think town or mafia really cared either way on that one.

Idea did a really good job for the town, I barely had anything to suspect you of all game, you were very astute. Lightwolf, I think a lot of your posts were garbled and nonsensicle, I'm glad I didn't waste an investigation on you.

I think the mafia team played well, and probably could have survived if I didn't investigate MMAM on night one. Overall though, good game everyone, I look forward to playing with you all again!

[TAX]

I know I need to learn alot I played a terrible game.

[VisMaior]

would have come clean before MafiaSSK was lynched and told the town what I was trying to do.

You would have probably got lynched for that tough

[Hoopla]

But if no other cop came forward, and I told you what I was doing I think I could have got away with it. It was lying for a purpose, and the town could have understood that.