Cosmos Mafia (Postgame)

[MMR]

@MMR why would you call the player who’s suggesting you botched your fakeclaim “a beacon of light?

And why bother mentioning the Mastina/Fire thing unless you have an actual opinion about it?

The first thing is that T-Bone is displaying a Town mindset. He is making observations and working from there.
The second thing was because Math wanted a summary and I decided that he needed to know mastina's request.
-Rubella

[MegAzumarill]

VC 2.0.7



Past Present Future (5) Scarfmanship, MMR, Toogeloo, Dingle Dangle Scarecrow, Firebringer [E-3]
MMR (5) Radical Rat, Yume, Past Present Future, Mathblade, furtiveglance [E-3]

Unwnd (1) Mastina

Not Voting (4) Ydrasse, Enchant, T-bone, Unwnd,

Deadline: 1 day*
With 15 alive it takes 8 to eliminate.

Deadline frozen for replacements.

[Scarfmanship]

Nice votecount. Everything is going according to plan.

[Enchant]

Compounding on that
There’s no evidence of a rolestopper/blocker of any kind so by that logic MMR/PPF contains a scum.
Ergo if everyone should be voting in Mastina/MMR
And everyone should be voting in MMR/PPF

Everyone should be voting MMR no?

no

What is the flaw in the logic?

I know one (

very

unlikely both) of them is evil, but keeping them both alive is preferable for time being for info.

I thought that originally too when it was just Mastina.

But leaving them both alive means I have to decide it alone tomorrow.

This is a fate I don’t want.

Wait i think safe option is voting PPF.


I wouldn't touch claims yet.

[Dingle Dangle Scarecrow]

We checked the wagons to see if moving our vote would make the day end/feel happier and we decided that actually there were two scum reads (well, I kinda tr FB but they did replace frozen angel), on each wagon, so that didn't give us much help.

We have a poe of eight: maybe fire, enchant, RR, radical rat, toog, furtive, one of MMR/PPF. We're a bit flip floppy on mastina.
We think math, scarf and t bone are lock town (possibly ydrasse).

[Past Present Future]

We checked the wagons to see if moving our vote would make the day end/feel happier and we decided that actually there were two scum reads (well, I kinda tr FB but they did replace frozen angel), on each wagon, so that didn't give us much help.

We have a poe of eight: maybe fire, enchant, RR, radical rat, toog, furtive, one of MMR/PPF. We're a bit flip floppy on mastina.
We think math, scarf and t bone are lock town (possibly ydrasse).

I don’t think scum!Mastina flips out like that. If anyone can find a game that debunks that, I’d be seriously shocked.

[MathBlade]

Compounding on that
There’s no evidence of a rolestopper/blocker of any kind so by that logic MMR/PPF contains a scum.
Ergo if everyone should be voting in Mastina/MMR
And everyone should be voting in MMR/PPF

Everyone should be voting MMR no?

no

What is the flaw in the logic?

I know one (

very

unlikely both) of them is evil, but keeping them both alive is preferable for time being for info.

I thought that originally too when it was just Mastina.

But leaving them both alive means I have to decide it alone tomorrow.

This is a fate I don’t want.

Wait i think safe option is voting PPF.


I wouldn't touch claims yet.

Elimming PPF was acceptable earlier.

We really need to elim MMR.

Only reason I don’t turbo push is Mastina replacement and Yume replacement needs to happen

[T-Bone]

I'm willing to wait for replacements to at least acknowledge them before we end the day.

[Dingle Dangle Scarecrow]

Elimming PPF was acceptable earlier.

We really need to elim MMR.

I saw your logic for this earlier and I don't think this is accurate

You said 'we need to eliminate in {MMR, mastina} and {MMR, PPF} therefore we need to eliminate MMR'

when really what has happened is the elimination set has just become {MMR, mastina/PPF}

It hasn't suddenly made MMR the mechanically correct choice

[MMR]

Elimming PPF was acceptable earlier.

We really need to elim MMR.

May you enlighten me?
I don't get your logic.
-Rubella

[Enchant]

Honestly considering how you played, i respect Math choice, even if i disagree with it and think you could REALLY fuck up.

[Radical Rat]

Mostly just prodging while waiting on replacements, but nothing I've said has changed. Either/both of MMR/PPF could flip scum, MMR claim shenanigans is worse than PPF's potential associatives with mastina, so still prefer MMR.

[Toogeloo]

Enchant, T-Bone...

Come back to PPF.

[MegAzumarill]

Prodding Ydrasse and Unwnd

[unwnd]

I don't have much to contribute presently,

It really is just a waiting game. I have tabbed into this thread on multiple occasions with my brain being shut off

[Enchant]

VOTE: PPF

[Past Present Future]

This game has been murdered due to replacements. Tbh, I was debating subbing out but I wouldn't put that through to the mod.

The structure of this is levels of unfun. I tell myself I'll read but it's pages of the same thing. Stagnant game. Reads are stale.

~Titus

[Past Present Future]

We're looking at 7 replacements Day 1, which is utterly ridiculous and it could go to 9.

~Titus

[furtiveglance]

MMR is the better vote I think

[Ydrasse]

just for that

VOTE: ppf

[Firebringer]

are we there yet mom

[furtiveglance]

just for that

VOTE: ppf

we know yer bad

[furtiveglance]

PPF, I'm probably gonna hammer just to beat this level if you know what I mean. Any final thoughts?

[MathBlade]

Elimming PPF was acceptable earlier.

We really need to elim MMR.

May you enlighten me?
I don't get your logic.
-Rubella

Mainly I think you’re scum.

There’s worlds (I don’t agree with) that PPF can be town and Nancy is trying to cooperate

I think you’re all three scum and PPF elim is you don’t elim cops before guilties

So either is good.

[MathBlade]

Much as I also hate the replacements I think that it’s protown to wait for Mastina and Yume replacements.

Both said they’d be doing particular things.

They should be able to do those before we go to night.