hi, i'm large normal 242. and i'm over with.

[marcistar]

malcolm scum malcolm scum malcolm scum

[MathBlade]

Do we tell NM who to shot

Marci.

You gonna finish your claim?

[Lukewarm]

Luke seems town so far on their play. Didn't like BCG but suppose it's possible they largely just got disengaged given the replace out.

You called my play town until I voted you, and you called my vote on you inconsistent based on nothing

[Lukewarm]

Do we tell NM who to shot

Marci.

You gonna finish your claim?

It seems like since he is scum reading BCG, that is probably where he is gonna shoot.

[MathBlade]

Do we tell NM who to shot

Marci.

You gonna finish your claim?

It seems like since he is scum reading BCG, that is probably where he is gonna shoot.

Enchant already said not a vig?

Was previously discussed Marci?

If NM goes BCG I need to know so I change and we are on the same target

[marcistar]

why do u need to confgirm nm again?

[Lukewarm]

why do u need to confgirm nm again?

I think the point is to know : did they live because of the disloyal mod or because a scum doc was on them

Tests the target, not NM

[Lukewarm]

Do we tell NM who to shot

Marci.

You gonna finish your claim?

It seems like since he is scum reading BCG, that is probably where he is gonna shoot.

Enchant already said not a vig?

Was previously discussed Marci?

If NM goes BCG I need to know so I change and we are on the same target

Never said enchant was a vig, I was talking about who NM was gonna target.

NM wanted bcg dead today, it didn't happen. Seems like he would want to target bcg tonight.


But it's really up to him I guess

[MathBlade]

why do u need to confgirm nm again?

I think the point is to know : did they live because of the disloyal mod or because a scum doc was on them

Tests the target, not NM

This

It’s why I would prefer to test you over BGC

Because if you’re town and live to tomorrow and NM lives to tomorrow then you visit NM meaning we likely get a check on N4 and survives to N5.

[MathBlade]

I want to have all protective slots checked and taken care of.

[Cape90]

VOTE: MalcolmTucker

I think Malcolm just has a suspect playstyle in general, but his responses to Lukewarm, who I am thinking is just getting more and more towny is just not it

I don't see what makes Luke so inconsistent to you Malcolm

[Cape90]

I don't think any of the speculation stuff is AI though since I suppose that's the mass-claiming stuff that's been going on

[Cape90]

would u want to vote malcolm pooky

im asking

would there be any world where u would vote malcolm

you still think pookys scum froggy..? why?

does pooky usually fake claim a pr as scum thats so easy to disprove?

i think i believe pookys, maybe mathblades idk

the rest idk

There's very little interaction between Marci/Pooky early on and these exchanges look like players who could potentially be partnered. Marci felt very hedgy on Pooky - not completely unwilling to vote there but never particularly pushing Pooky all that strongly either. Their read on the slot feels a little bit inconsistent, like they wanted to create some distance but didn't want to push there in case it picked up momentum.

In terms of Malcolm, I like posts like this which do provide a fair point in terms of how marci has been treating the pooky slot

VOTE: Titus

If you don’t want to cooperate with the town block you can die. No need for mass claim.

Do you actually properly think Titus is scum here or not? The wording of your post indicates you're largely voting Titus for disagreeing with you and I dislike that, it can be frustration but disagreement isn't always bad for town provided players aren't overly stubborn.

I don't really find this post towny in fact, it just seems odd and also ignores literally everything else that MathBlade has done in suspecting Titus and goes off assumption without reading beyond the base level.

Ah okay derp.

Yeah NM is lock town. Forgot about that thanks.

Mainly I want to find the scum that kills Frogger over me.

Because while I am alive scum are pretty much stuck doing what town decides.

I have to go now but yeah. That’s kinda where I am at.

That and I can’t figure out Titus.

Why is this true? You're active, sure,

but it's not guaranteed town will follow your reads and it's not even guaranteed all town will trust you

, as we're seeing with Titus. Scum could also be perfectly content leaving you alive if you're on the right track as well, or may simply have killed Frogster because they believed he had an important role and one of them had managed to identify it.

I don't like how Malcolm talks like town is some separate entity from himself here.

I'd be perfectly content with a Furtive elimination at this point as well from a brief catch-up. Their jokey/playful tone doesn't feel natural and sounds more like scum to me trying to dodge suspicion by looking like they don't care, without having to particularly commit to reads.

Vote for me then, get your hands dirty.

How many votes are you at? I'm wary because it seems you've accumulated a good few and we have some notorious quickhammer players in the game. If it's settled to eliminate you though I'm more than happy to hammer.

This post directed at furtiveglance feels so slimy almost in like a teabagging way. I do not see Malcolm "wanting" to solve for the furtive slot in this post at all.

Even if Pooky's ISO here isn't particularly identical to early-game Lost, I've definitely seen a few games where Pooky is fairly quiet in terms of fully-formed reads despite having a higher post count. I'm not seeing them as scum and feel like when a read depends too heavily on meta comparisons to work, it's not a great or massively strong scumread.

I mean you could point out marci's treatment of Pooky but man IDK about your own complaining that too many people were relying on meta reading pooky or whatever.

Pooky's responses seem okay, I'm not particularly wanting to go there at the moment. Back to null on the slot, certainly not sold on them as scum.

This too.
I am aware that my slot isn't the greatest when it comes to the Pooky slot, I mean I just defended him because i thought the juxtaposition between his day 1 versus day 2 posts were "a towny shift" when I assumed Pooky would literally do the thing they have been doing day 1 all game if mafia.

but I feel like you actually put more focus into Pooky which makes me a tad concerned

What's the Pooky cased based on? I find Pooky hard to read in general and had them null so far.

They're playing to their scum meta and their D1 votes were poor in hindsight

What specifically is Pooky's scum meta? I find them hard to parse in most games but can't recall having actually played with scum Pooky now I think of it.

Lurk early game, power through late game

Hmmm, maybe notable that Pooky's been quieter this turn than they were D1. Been a few slots that could apply to. My view is you and Math has been TvT and therefore it's likely some scum have been lurking in the background to let that play out since it's useful for them.

In conclusion: Sayanara I have no trouble pocketing who I think town is

[Cape90]

you also said furtives role makes sense for scum to have but look where that wound u up

It absolutely did. It was still the right play to elim furtive because of that and lying. It’s not like I was alone in saying it either. Given the same facts I’d do it again too.

and you dont pause to think

furtives role makes sense as scum yet hes town
so maybe the same thing applies to others?

geez for someone who keeps trying to take mechanical lead you sure are shit at it

I can believe in a town!marci world

I will be honest, I haven't read 1435 but I think it's a decent scumcase on Malcolm and I do like the sort of read on Maria, I felt like Malcolm was suspecting Maria whenever it felt convenient if that makes sense. Like if someone else were scumreading Maria, Malcolm would hop in

[Cape90]

Posts like some of the ones Malcolm pulled up here also just seemed fine to me

when i said this, it was also a lazy read via thinking Malcolm quoted all those things because towny self-confidence and w!Malcolm wouldn't want attention on any of his prior posts if he were wolf.
I know, look at me having ulterior motives behind my posts

[Titus]

Is Lukewarm dead yet?

[MathBlade]

I don’t scumread Luke.

[Enchant]

I want to kill Math for reasons, but fuck me i guess.

[Titus]

why do u need to confgirm nm again?

I think the point is to know : did they live because of the disloyal mod or because a scum doc was on them

Tests the target, not NM

This

It’s why I would prefer to test you over BGC

Because if you’re town and live to tomorrow and NM lives to tomorrow then you visit NM meaning we likely get a check on N4 and survives to N5.

If we confirm Lukewarm as the check, I am ok with a MalcolmTucker lim.

[schadd_]

JohnnyFarrar replaces Big Chungus Gaming at long last

[schadd_]

Spoiler:

vote count 3.5 !

MalcolmTucker (4):

MariaR, Lukewarm, Not_Mafia, Cape90

Lukewarm (2):

MalcolmTucker, Titus

Enchant (1):

JohnnyFarrar

MariaR (1):

Toogeloo

not voting (3):

Enchant, marcistar, MathBlade

with 11 alive, it takes 6 to blow someone up. day 3 ends in (expired on 2022-11-03 20:38:11)

modorator notes

• i'll go ahead and add a day to the deadline

[schadd_]

prodding MariaR

[JohnnyFarrar]

Hello! Who wants to catch me up on gamestate?

[Enchant]

Hello! Who wants to catch me up on gamestate?

I am Cop with guilty on you.

[JohnnyFarrar]

Hello! Who wants to catch me up on gamestate?

I am Cop with guilty on you.

I found scum already! Hot shit