Choose Carefully Mafia: (Game Over)

[CarnCarn]

Why BM? Do you think he is scum?

[armlx]

I don't get it.

It makes me think oEJo is stalling scum tho.

[bird1111]

Vote Count:
oEJo (7): Moses le fou, ZazieR, Empking, hp [leaves], ribwich, Save the Dragons, armlx
Save the Dragons (1): Riceballtail
Battle Mage (1): SocioPath
ribwich (1): CarnCarn

Not voting (6): PutaPuta, oEJo, ZTR, Santos II, Battle Mage

With 15 alive it is 8 to lynch.

Lynch Method Vote Count:
Rope (9): Save the Dragons, Empking, Moses le fou, ZazieR, ZTR, CarnCarn, hp [leaves], ribwich, armlx
Gun (4): oEJo, SocioPath, Riceballtail, Battle Mage


Not voting for a lynch method (2): PutaPuta, Santos II

If a lynch were to happen without any change in lynch method votes, the Rope would be used.

[Moses le fou]

Unvote: Rope

Vote: Gun

If I were scum and jumping on a strong bandwagon, I'd vote for the method that would kill me. If we lynch town, it works either way. If we lynch opposing mafia, the lynch would fail and it'd basically force the town to try the same lynch again the next day.

[Santos]

Idea: Cop investigates oEJo tonight and if he is NOT scum, then we move on. If he is scum, then we lynch him tomorrow?

Thoughts----

[Riceballtail]

1) We have a cop for sure?
2) We want to lose a cop over lynching one scum?

[armlx]

1) We have a cop for sure?
2) We want to lose a cop over lynching one scum?

Hint: The answers start with N.

[Santos]

Yeah, I'm not sure.

[CarnCarn]

1) We have a cop for sure?
2) We want to lose a cop over lynching one scum?

Hint: The answers start with N.

From the signup thread:

Different Mechanics:

• Each Mafia group has to choose whether their kill can affect pro-town people or members of the opposite group
  
• The town, in addition to choosing who to lynch, has to choose which Mafia group can be lynched that day. Either the lynch is by a rope (which the Corsican group is immune to) or by a gun (which the Sicilians are immune to).
  
• Once a majority of people are voting for the same player, then which ever of rope or gun has more votes will be the method used. If they have the same amount of votes, which ever got to the amount first will be used.
  
• If any pro-town people with night-choices are in the setup, they have to choose whether their choice affects Corsican or Sicilian. For example, a Doctor has to choose whether he/she can protect from Corsican kills or whether he/she can protect from Sicillian kills each night, which a Cop has to choose whether they get a guilty on Corsicans or Sicilians each night.

So, yeah, nothing for sure, but odds are there are probably pairs. Also, it seems kind of useless/dangerous to have both cops investigate the same person and both claim their results.

[CarnCarn]

D'oh, not pairs, I read through that too quickly. Only one person has to choose which they want to protect from/investigate on. Still, it sounds like a bad plan.

[Santos]

Not a plan; an idea.

[CarnCarn]

Mod: Can we get a prod on Puta Puta/Thunder/Rich?

Whoever they are they haven't added

anything

to this game...

Confirmed.

What's a SPAG?

Greetings...I see some new faces..and some very familiar ones.. I will read the thread and post more later

Hi

Greetings...I see some new faces..and some very familiar ones.. I will read the thread and post more later

...and u never did....

That's everything. 4 combined posts, one of which was about themselves.

[Santos]

omg fos :p

[bird1111]

PutaPuta prodded.

[Moses le fou]

I think the cop has to investigate somebody and specify whether he wants to see if the target is Corsican or Sicilian. So, the cop could investigate oEJo to see if he's Sicilian and the result could come back negative, but that doesn't dismiss him from being Corsican.

[oEJo]

I think the cop has to investigate somebody and specify whether he wants to see if the target is Corsican or Sicilian. So, the cop could investigate oEJo to see if he's Sicilian and the result could come back negative, but that doesn't dismiss him from being Corsican.

I'm being lynched today.

Anyway, IMO, stop directing the cop, he'll investigate the right person i'm sure

[Empking]

Do people still think that the town can get more from today?

[armlx]

Not unless we want to swing this wagon to someone else.

Which I doubt.

[Battle Mage]

*shrug*

Vote: Santos

jk

Vote: OeJo

BM

[bird1111]

You try to string up oEJo using the rope you set up, but he laughs at your attempts to string him up; when you pull the noose, he doesn't die, instead he looks just fine.

oEJo failed to be lynched by a rope Day 1.

Night 1 begins. Choices due in 72 hours.

Looking for an PutaPuta replacement.

[bird1111]

Still missing some nightchoices. The people responsible for them have been prodded. If I do not get those within 24 hours, they will be forfited.

[bird1111]

Kairyuu replaces PutaPuta.

[bird1111]

You all wake up, expecting to find at least one of you dead. You are not dissapointed, as only 14 of you show up to the town square. You check to see who the missing person is, and realize that it is Riceballtail. You check his house, and find it plain. Looks like he was a Townie.

Riceballtail, Townie, killed Night 1

Day 2 begins, with 14 alive, it is 8 to lynch.

[ribwich]

Vote: OeJo
Vote: Gun

[armlx]

Hold please, I did a full reread and here is what I got.

Post 27: If ZTR is scum, 1 of RBT and STD is definitely scum with him.
Post 33: Moses votes gun, just tracking this as he is a person of interest.
Post 41: Not a random vote ZTR? By known scum?
Post 48: +1 town point for Moses worrying about vote shuffling and hammering.
Post 94: Pretty sure ZTR is just newb scum now.
Post 95: See comment on post 70.
Post 96: Really? See comments on 70 and 95, but where did his suspicion from his last vote go?
Post 107: P sure Emp is not mafia with oEJo. Blatant wagon here.
Post 120: REACH by BM. Not sure if its atypical of him, but notable. Also the Santos reach. I wouldn’t mind a BM wagon.
Post 148: BM = opportunist.
Post 156: More reach by moses.
Post 170: Delay method of choice? Interesting.
Post 179: Excuse for hoping on a future early easy lynch by STD?
Post 182: More worries on ZTR’s part about his image in game.
Post 193: Trying to get more lynches out of the group then necessary (possible this point is just me making his post scummy b/c I think he is scum).
Post 205: REACH.

BM becomes more typical over the next couple pages.

Post 302: Really, higher chance of being NK’ed? Explain Zazier.

BM pushing gun on Santos implies him not being scum with oEJo, as if he was scum that didn’t die to gun he would push rope to get a lynch out of it.

Smiley tell from ZTR in post 410.

I concur with BM’s 430 for the record. Emp is pretty obv town this game. He’s being maximally helpful for him.

I forgot HP was the one of the 2 who claimed. That was pro-town.

Post 479: ZTR’s comment, and he is voting Santos still… gosh. OBV scum.

Needs more explain from Socio.

BM avoided voting oEJo post mod kill. Interesting.

Moses mini-wagons Ribwich on page 30. Noteable

The BM hammer me comment is odd. Probably just WIFOM and should be ignored.

Scummy:
Moses (possible tunnel vision here)
ZTR

Other scum are probably people that lied low and just rode out the Santos issue without taking a prominent stance. I'm leaning PutaPuta + Santos 2, maybe Zazier, off chance of BM or Socio. Then 1 of HP and STD.

Also, 2 questions for STD.

1) Have you ever played with Empking other then this game?

2) Who of the other neighbors do you think is the second scum?

oEJo is obviously the lynch today, but there's no reason to just rush to it without letting everyone make a comment or 2 about stuff.