Mafia 86 - mafia.gif - Game Over!

[farside22]

@Armlx. If you want the link I can try and do that later. I have easier time just using looking for my post and hiting the quote key.

So looking at the past 2 days and what happened and sek's bah post I lean on one more person as part of that faction and I think that person is BA.

If you look back you see sek defending BA and putting pressure on Empking.

vote: blakadder
Fos: Seraphim, ShadowGirl and Sierra

Sera for the above
SG for really hanging back and having no opinion of her own. Active lurkering without saying anything.
Sierra for post 128 and post 161

Also SG is also one of the people I agree with Cow about as well as sierra and seaphim. Fun and good times.

[armlx]

Uhh, yeah, quote is what I meant.

And fair nuff. I just didn't see that for some reason.

[curiouskarmadog]

I am still waiting for the mod to address my last statement directed toward him...this is kind of dictating where I want to go next...I feel it is important that ALL of us know this information (or at least know that the mod will not provide this information) BEFORE a lynch.

going to PM the mod.

[gorckat]

I'll be on this evening. I'd been trying to keep up and review where things were headed, but work has been nuts.

[Jebus]

I can get behind a SG lynch.

I can't. From what I've read up on so far (up to page 15), SG seemed somewhat more pro-town than scum. If this changes after that, and excuse me if I missed this, wanna point this out to me please?

And @sekinj's 'bah' post, it's on page 22.

[Jebus]

BAH!!! GO YAKUZA!!!!!!!! WIN WIN WIN!!!!

[ShadowGirl]

But she could be just messing with us.

[hasdgfas]

PBPA of ShadowGirl(post numbers are number based on her posts):
Post 0-1: A truly random vote. These always feel a bit off to me for some reason. Something about how you're trying to completely absolve yourself of any responsibility of your vote by making sure people know it's random.

NOTE:

SG has not done a dice vote in any other game on MS. I find that very interesting.
Posts 2-5: All of these are completely inane comments that do absolutely nothing at all.
Post 6: Lurker prodding. Not a terrible thing to do, but the mod can take care of this.
Post 7: I find this to be a defense of Stef. Before Stef even answers for himself about his vote, SG jumps in saying that it's probably a joke.
Post 8: What is this supposed to say, exactly?
Post 9: Here ShadowGirl is defending someone else's comment by saying it's just part of the "random vote stage".
Post 10: This post seems quite noncommittal to me. She says that we shouldn't excuse stuff because he is new, but also says that we can take into account that he's new. How exactly would we be taking into account that he's new but not excuse anything?
Post 11: How is this unvote constructive at all? It does nothing to move the game forward. Don't you have any real suspicions? Saying that tajo's claim is a null-tell is probably one of the scummiest things I've seen. I don't understand how anyone could think that. Same with Stef's saying he wanted to be lynched and claiming scum, even in a "joking manner".
That's something I consider to be defending those two. Claiming that scummy actions they make aren't scummy. That's pretty much the exact definition of defending.
Post 12: This is also blatant defending of tajo. The fact that you're saying it's not scummy because it's the "random stage" is even worse. Random stage can be the best time to catch scum doing something scummy because they don't think people are paying attention.
Post 13: An extremely inane comment when I'm sure there was plenty of stuff to comment on.
Post 16: Why point out that it's L-1 here? Also, there's no way he was a doctor. He would've have claimed vanilla so early as an actual doc. The mafia won't take care of him, are you nuts? He was way too easy of a lynch. I feel like SG was trying to derail the wagon on tajo by saying that he might actually be a doctor. Another defense of a scummy player who doesn't deserve it.
Post 17: I hate when people point out it's an awesome night. The only reason to do that is to look town by saying it was a good night because town already knows that.
Post 22: What a useless post. Why even say that?
Post 23: I hate these posts because they look like contribution but aren't.
Post 25: WhyWhy haven't you voted for a scummy person? Because he could be a Jester? Terrible reason, especially because the only thing it does is distract the town.
Post 28: Why does L-2 make so much of a difference? If he's scummy, he should be lynched.
Post 29: I still hate this. Pointing out that it was a good night for the town is not useful because we know it was a good night for the town.
Post 30: What about his play made you think he wasn't scum?
Post 32: Wait a second, you didn't believe Emp was scum? But you voted for him. What gives? Why point out that massive isn't posting much? Is it just to get attention off of you? It seems like it.
Post 33: I love how SG points out that people I think are scummy have been lynched when I made it pretty obvious that I was reading through the game for the first time.

[armlx]

NOTE: SG has not done a dice vote in any other game on MS. I find that very interesting.

This is a winner.

Vote ShadowGirl

[gorckat]

Has she been town in all her other games? Otherwise, as iggy a feeling as I was getting on her, that's not enough to vote on.

vote: massive

His recent posts are all sorts of willingness to vote anyone just blowing in the wind.

[curiouskarmadog]

NOTE: SG has not done a dice vote in any other game on MS. I find that very interesting.

This is a winner.

Vote ShadowGirl

this is a silly reason to be voting anyone on day 3 armlx

[ShadowGirl]

NOTE: SG has not done a dice vote in any other game on MS. I find that very interesting.

This is a winner.

Vote ShadowGirl

Why does this seem akin to the smiley meta that was mentioned earlier in the game? Anyway, this is not a reason to vote someone on day three.

Has, I'll post a reply to your post when I get home from school.

[hasdgfas]

NOTE: SG has not done a dice vote in any other game on MS. I find that very interesting.

This is a winner.

Vote ShadowGirl

Why does this seem akin to the smiley meta that was mentioned earlier in the game? Anyway, this is not a reason to vote someone on day three.

Has, I'll post a reply to your post when I get home from school.

Note how the smiley meta was correct.

[massive]

Of course I'm willing to vote for anyone. I've already expressed that I have suspicions about at least three people, what they are, and this thread needs more lynching and less standing around looking at people.

The front page doesn't indicate who you're replacing, gorckat, so I'm assuming Seraphim. Want to put the OMGUS in front of your vote?

unvote, vote ShadowGirl

Her helpful vote counts pre-both-lynches coupled with her joy of the previous night's events are a desperate attempt to appear townie. I don't believe a townie needs to do that.

[ShadowGirl]

NOTE: SG has not done a dice vote in any other game on MS. I find that very interesting.

This is a winner.

Vote ShadowGirl

Why does this seem akin to the smiley meta that was mentioned earlier in the game? Anyway, this is not a reason to vote someone on day three.

Has, I'll post a reply to your post when I get home from school.

Note how the smiley meta was correct.

Perhaps, but that should not be the deciding factor in a vote.

[farside22]

armlx that is a rediculous reason to place a vote. Other factors that cow brought up where more interesting such as i stated as well her following the votes and backing off of votes.
gorckat: I do not understand what you are talking about post 709.

[armlx]

Why does this seem akin to the smiley meta that was mentioned earlier in the game? Anyway, this is not a reason to vote someone on day three.

Why isn't it?

Other factors that cow brought up where more interesting such as i stated as well her following the votes and backing off of votes.

I agree. I was interested in how SG would react to a vote just based on that. I'm more interested in how she hasn't made any strong commitments to an opinion all game.

[gorckat]

gorckat: I do not understand what you are talking about post 709.

massive gave me the impression of being willing to vote anyone for any reason.

[curiouskarmadog]

vote massive

fos armlx

still waiting for a answer from the mod.

[armlx]

vote massive

fos armlx

still waiting for a answer from the mod.

More plz?

[curiouskarmadog]

massive's eagerness to vote anyone and reasons for doing so. not a fan of people voting anyone due to flavor...still waiting for the mod to answer my question.

you get an fos, because I think your vote today is quite silly...and not sure why are this point (day 3) you are voting because of a lack of a dice roll.

[armlx]

not sure why are this point (day 3) you are voting because of a lack of a dice roll.

Correction: The stated reason was that there was a die roll this game, but never anywhere else.

And read post 717.

[massive]

Please point out where I've indicated I'm willing to vote for anyone. I'm pretty sure I've only voted for people I've found suspicious, and have given reasons in every instance. Hrm.

[farside22]

Always happy to help.

Of course I'm willing to vote for anyone

. I've already expressed that I have suspicions about at least three people, what they are, and this thread needs more lynching and less standing around looking at people.

[ShadowGirl]

Why does this seem akin to the smiley meta that was mentioned earlier in the game? Anyway, this is not a reason to vote someone on day three.

Why isn't it?

It's a weak meta: as well, I've said also that it shouldn't be the deciding reason to vote.

Okay, I'm formulating post in response to has.