Xyl's Relative Chaos - Game over!

[Xylthixlm]

Vote Count

tubby216 -

4

(SpyreX, farside22, DoomCow, ZazieR)
Crazy -

2

(animorpherv1, tubby216)
Korts -

2

(CoheedCambria09, Crazy)
animorpherv1 -

1

(DrippingGoofball)
Vi -

1

(The Internet)
SpyreX -

1

(Korts)
DrippingGoofball -

1

(Vi)
DoomCow -

1

(hasdgfas)

Not voting: MafiaSSK, Natirasha

With 15 alive, it will take 8 to lynch. The deadline for day 1 will be Saturday, December 6.

Scum/mason daytalk is over.

[Korts]

Post 159 - Korts: No, we can totally talk about it here, since we can't talk about it out of game. Why push this conversation to the side when it could have bearing on the game?

Okay, let's talk about it, then. Unvoting in the early game, especially from a vote you did not make of your own accord and therefore aren't responsible for it, does not promote discussion other than perhaps being called out for it. It doesn't really evoke reactions, because it isn't something that affects someone negatively (as in the case of a vote, where someone gets a vote closer to a lynch). Do you think unvoting without revoting is constructive? If so, how?

[Korts]

EBWOP: meant to paste this at top of last post.

Post 144 - Korts: ALERT! ALERT! PAGE ARGUMENT SIGHTED!

As much as I myself don't like the page number senselessly waved in my face when trying to scumhunt, I think when people are committing to a

lynch

, the state of the game should also be factored in. And the state of the game, as in the amount of information for Day 1, can best be measured by page numbers.

[ZazieR]

zazier seems really quiet to me. I've seen her post more often than this. Why haven't you said much?

You're basing this due to one game, right? Normally, I'm not as vocal in my games as that one. I'm trying to change that. I used to ask questions, and since that game you are referring to, I started to build cases more instead of asking questions. I liked that play of mine so I try to do it in my new games as well as you could see a bit with Tubby.
Then there's homework. It's my final year so school comes first.

But I'll do a reread. Perhaps I'll see something interesting.

[DoomCow]

Post 149 - DoomCow: Wow, what a wonderful noncommital post.

I still need to reread, had some busy days but will eventually get to it though. As for that post, I clearly state my suspicions towards Vi and Animorpherv1.

Post 151 - DoomCow: Why do you think he's the option?

Because of that scummy looking post he made about Crazy.

DoomCow: Hasn't posted any analysis. Just information. I(and tarhalindur) find that scummy. High scumminess.

Wow! no analysis on day 1. Imagine that. It's just, what is there to analyse? Since nobody died as of now, we don't know the possible motives around anything that has happened. So any analysis made at this point would have to be revised later.

[Korts]

It's just, what is there to analyse?

I think there has been plenty of actions that are worthy of a closer look.

Since nobody died as of now, we don't know the possible motives around anything that has happened. So any analysis made at this point would have to be revised later.

And what's wrong with revising the analysis with new information gained? There is no point in an analysis if you're only willing to make it when there's been mod-confirmed information revealed. You might as well just ask the mod to post the setup and role PM distributions.

[DoomCow]

There's nothing wrong with revising an analysis, I just prefer to have a confirmed base behind it, so it's not a complete do over.

And I´m not asking for role-PM distributions, because that takes away the game. I like to know a bit and guess at the rest.

[Korts]

Well, you know your own. Guess the rest.

[The Internet]

This game seems to be slowing down.

[Vi]

This game seems to be slowing down.

And it's partly your fault for not bringing any discussion to the table at all.
But let's not mince words about it.

[animorpherv1]

Post 149 - DoomCow: Wow, what a wonderful noncommital post.

I still need to reread, had some busy days but will eventually get to it though. As for that post, I clearly state my suspicions towards Vi and Animorpherv1.

unvote vote: DoomCow

. Your a great suspect, the fake PR's are what we want to do. We've already talked abou tit. It's ocer. Stop brininging ti up. I ahve a new PR, bulit just for you.

*DoomCow sucks*

Happy?

[Vi]

Post 149 - DoomCow: Wow, what a wonderful noncommital post.

I still need to reread, had some busy days but will eventually get to it though. As for that post, I clearly state my suspicions towards Vi and Animorpherv1.

unvote vote: DoomCow

. Your a great suspect, the fake PR's are what we want to do. We've already talked abou tit. It's ocer. Stop brininging ti up. I ahve a new PR, bulit just for you.

*DoomCow sucks*

Happy?

See Post 184.
Extra negative points for a literal OMGUS.

[hasdgfas]

Post 149 - DoomCow: Wow, what a wonderful noncommital post.

I still need to reread, had some busy days but will eventually get to it though. As for that post, I clearly state my suspicions towards Vi and Animorpherv1.

For what, their fake PRs? Sure, they're anti-town, but you can't lynch someone just based on that, especially when it's completely obvious that they're fake.

That said, I don't like morph's post 185 where he says "the fake PRs are what we want to do. It's over". It seems a wee bit OMGUS to me because the response seems so much stronger than that attack required.

[animorpherv1]

I go overboard. I guess you can tell now. I also don't like it when people go over things that have been gone over 10 times.

But I was annoyed at the fact he wanted to vote us both because of personal preference. If you can't take personal prefernce, then you have a problem.

[hasdgfas]

But I was annoyed at the fact he wanted to vote us both because of personal preference. If you can't take personal prefernce, then you have a problem.

Could you explain this a bit better? I don't understand what you're trying to say here.

[farside22]

Prod received will try and post more today.

[animorpherv1]

But I was annoyed at the fact he wanted to vote us both because of personal preference. If you can't take personal prefernce, then you have a problem.

Could you explain this a bit better? I don't understand what you're trying to say here.

I'll explain.

You know how some people don't post much? They normally have good reasons, like they had school, and such. But then, a half page later, someone else asks, and someone else etc etc, they get annoyed. Then, next page, someone

else

asks, they blow up. I blew up. Thats what happened. I had a bad day at school, to. Someone insulted the place I was born.

[CoheedCambria09]

But I was annoyed at the fact he wanted to vote us both because of personal preference. If you can't take personal prefernce, then you have a problem.

Could you explain this a bit better? I don't understand what you're trying to say here.

Seconded, I dont understand either.

[DoomCow]

Post 149 - DoomCow: Wow, what a wonderful noncommital post.

I still need to reread, had some busy days but will eventually get to it though. As for that post, I clearly state my suspicions towards Vi and Animorpherv1.

For what, their fake PRs? Sure, they're anti-town, but you can't lynch someone just based on that, especially when it's completely obvious that they're fake.

That said, I don't like morph's post 185 where he says "the fake PRs are what we want to do. It's over". It seems a wee bit OMGUS to me because the response seems so much stronger than that attack required.

I don't want to lynch them on the plain fact they're using fake PR's. I voted Vi for it, but when I was shown he actually stated to be using a fake PR I immediatly unvoted. I just find that a deliberate lie (i.e. faking a PR) to town is bad. I'll shut up about this for now though.

[farside22]

I have been prodded. I'm sorry, but I can' contributte because I do not understand the tubby situation. I will hope to contribute more tommorrow.

Well what happened to doing this? I see this as you next post:

This game seems to be slowing down.

Highly questionable coming from someone who has offered nothing this game thus far.

Anyone believe that Korts really

was

making a case against tubby just to gauge reactions? I don't. Saying "Nevermind about all that stuff I was doing; I didn't really mean it" is a scum-tell in my book.

Anyone else have thoughts on this?

Vote: Korts

I would like quotes on Korts saying this. I don't like paraphrasing if that is what this is.

I don't believe faking post restrictions is a null tell. At all.

Anything else game related you wish to share. Maybe someone you find scummy?

There's nothing wrong with revising an analysis, I just prefer to have a confirmed base behind it, so it's not a complete do over.

And I´m not asking for role-PM distributions, because that takes away the game. I like to know a bit and guess at the rest.

That is not helpful at worse it's like asking for a no lynch and waiting for the next day to see what the night brings. Pressure people, add to the conversation. Talk about things that bother your, ect. Not at least adding addressing what you find scummy is anti-town.

unvote:
vote: The Internet

Lurk, lurk, no comment, lurk, lurk, no comment. Something I associate with scum.

[SpyreX]

Even with the lurkers (which I dont like) and the fake PR's (which I see as null) tubby still is my choice.

I'm waiting for any reason for his business to be anything but a bad scum move.

[Vi]

I'm waiting for any reason for his business to be anything but a bad scum move.

What about a bad newb move?

[farside22]

I'm waiting for any reason for his business to be anything but a bad scum move.

What about a bad newb move?

I really don't like the lets give the newb a break, however the lack of conversation from some is very telling in my book.

[MafiaSSK]

/prodded I've put myself in way too many games right now.

[SpyreX]

A bad newb move that the only recourse is negative for the town is a bad newb scum move still.