Read Your Role Mafia - Game Over

[petroleumjelly]

Day Two Vote Count #3: End of Day Two

6 MafiaSSK (Seraphim, charter, Yaw, forbiddanlight, SensFan, Caboose)

With

11

alive, it takes

6

to lynch! It will take

4

to lynch at deadline, which is November 10, 9:59 pm CDT.

Not Voting – 5 – Electra, Empking, MafiaSSK, RandomGem, wolframnhart

~

MafiaSSK, Townie, Town

has been lynched!

Townie

You are a vanilla townie. You have no special abilities, although you do have an extraordinary ability for giving a good, bloodcurdling scream upon death. How you are aware of this before you have actually died is for you to ponder.

You win with the town when all Mafiates, Serial Killers, and Cultists are dead and somebody with the exact same win condition as you is alive.

Good luck, and have fun! Be sure to read the rules of the game. Confirm your role by PM.

It is now

Night Two

. Choices are due to me by November 5, 9:59 pm CDT.

RandomGem may be replaced due to request, and I am in the process of determing if that is necessary – night

may

be extended if a replacement is warranted.

[petroleumjelly]

Searching for a replacement for RandomGem.

[petroleumjelly]

Tamuz replaces RandomGem. Deadline for night is extended one real-time day, in accordance with Regular Rule #5.

New deadline: November 6, 9:59 pm CDT.

[petroleumjelly]

charter, Mafia B, has been shot.

Yaw, ???, Town, has been shot.

It is now

Day Three

. With

8

alive, it takes

5

to lynch, and

3

to lynch at deadline. Deadline is November 20, 9:59 pm CDT.

[Electra]

Yay for protown vigilantes, maybe?

I want to ask a question - mainly,

do you think that SensFan is likely to be town?

You can answer in and out of the context that charter is Mafia.

For me, I feel like he reads as town, but in addition to that, I find charter's statement of "I'm pretty sure sensfan is town" to indicate that he would be more likely than not. It's a typical Mafia thing to do to say this about someone you know is town, as a way of buddying up to the townsperson and also in case Sens is lynched, it would be an i-told-you-so.

Anyway,

vote:Seraphim

. I have reason to believe you may be scum, and so I would like a claim from you.

[Caboose]

Going to do a read-through of charter's posts tomorrow. Good night everyone.

[forbiddanlight]

Well, I laid out my reasoning yesterday.

Vote Seraphim

[Tamuz]

hi, post tommorow

[Seraphim]

I'll go point-by-point for you, FL. I have absolutely no problem with parrying your strikes.

1) Besides the name of the game and the fact that even the first post says:

However, I am trying to emphasize that some roles have particular nuances, and instead of playing “hide the ball”, I want you to realize these nuances and take them into account while playing.

Jelly is pretty much saying that some of the roles will be really, really weird. At least, that's my way of looking at it.

2) I agree, this does look rather bad on my part. However, the rest of the post is lost to the voids of computer data, never to be found again. I suppose I wanted to make it look like a mistake because I didn't want to seem indecisive. When I made that edit...well, it was more of a pride thing, I suppose. In hindsight, after I had made that half-of-a-post and had noticed my case leads towards a MafiaSSK lynch as opposed to an Electra lynch. Instead of retyping my post, I instead made it look like that was my intention all along. Which was a major, major gaffe.

3) I'm not I understand quite what you're saying. Do you mind clarifying?

4) I suppose that's a viewpoint I don't share with you, Miss Light.

5) Fair enough, fair enough.

6) Summary post for that coming up. I'm going to reread the entire game and post my new findings and my case against Electra once again. This reread will also put the game into perspective for me, as charter has been revealed to be scum.

Now, for Electra...

I don't know, frankly. I don't think that statement should be used at all for evidence of anyone's scumminess, because it merely leads to WIFOM. We can play this guessing game all we want, but I think that we should play the game based off of what people have said, not what other people have said about them.

Also, that claim...

I don't think I'll claim if you, someone I think is scum, is asking me. I suppose it is a fair question though, because unless things change, I will probably be lynched today, which would be bad at this point. So, if it makes anyone feel better...

I claim vanilla townie. I have no powers. Nothing in the slightest. No special roles. No nothing.

Vote: Electra

Case and reread tomorrow or Monday. Depends on how much time I have tomorrow(our school's musical has two performances tomorrow, but I hope to sneak in some posts in the morning).

[wolframnhart]

Why would you automatically think it is a pro-town vigilante electra? Even if you did say "maybe" it is an odd conclusion to immediately jump to.

[Empking]

Vote; Elektra

Along with everything else that "Yay for pro-town vigilates" when we can be pretty sure that their are two scum groups scummy.

[forbiddanlight]

Jelly is pretty much saying that some of the roles will be really, really weird. At least, that's my way of looking at it.

I'll let this one settle.

2) I agree, this does look rather bad on my part. However, the rest of the post is lost to the voids of computer data, never to be found again. I suppose I wanted to make it look like a mistake because I didn't want to seem indecisive. When I made that edit...well, it was more of a pride thing, I suppose. In hindsight, after I had made that half-of-a-post and had noticed my case leads towards a MafiaSSK lynch as opposed to an Electra lynch. Instead of retyping my post, I instead made it look like that was my intention all along. Which was a major, major gaffe.

Admitting it doesn't make it right. We don't know precisely where your post was going and we won't find out. I don't think my point was invalid.

3) I'm not I understand quite what you're saying. Do you mind clarifying?

You said you didn't say Yaw was scum, but in that earlier post, you said he was. It's somewhat of a contradiction.

4) I suppose that's a viewpoint I don't share with you, Miss Light.

Well, that's not as much the problem as the problem of the motives you were ascribing Yaw for not believing SP's roleclaim. So just because someone claims he's supposed to automatically jump off and go on another wagon? Considering no one really observed SSK claiming survivor, I think point 5 kinda covers this as well..

5) Fair enough, fair enough.

This wasn't a point against you so I'm not sure why I pointed it out, lol.

6) Summary post for that coming up. I'm going to reread the entire game and post my new findings and my case against Electra once again. This reread will also put the game into perspective for me, as charter has been revealed to be scum.

Fine. I'm keeping my vote on you for the time being since everyone else seems to want to lynch Electra.

Why would you automatically think it is a pro-town vigilante electra? Even if you did say "maybe" it is an odd conclusion to immediately jump to.

This.

FoS Electra

[Electra]

Uh... when I see roles that are antitown being killed, I like to hope that there are protown vigs. I know that it's probably actually an SK, but I have wishful thinking.

@Seraphim - Don't bother with a case on me, I have a much better case on you. I need more responses about the SensFan thing though.

[Caboose]

@Seraphim - Don't bother with a case on me, I have a much better case on you. I need more responses about the SensFan thing though.

I hate the dismissiveness towards Seraphim in this sentence.

[forbiddanlight]

Uh... when I see roles that are antitown being killed, I like to hope that there are protown vigs. I know that it's probably actually an SK, but I have wishful thinking.

backtrack.

[Electra]

omg, you guys are so annoying. That's what I actually thought.

Anyway, I will claim since no one wants to respond to me. I'm a cop, I know that Sens and Seraphim are not the same alignment, and I think that Sens is town. Hence I find Seraphim to be scum. His claim of vanilla does nothing for me.

[forbiddanlight]

You were at L-3. Did you REALLY need to claim?

[Electra]

You were at L-3. Did you REALLY need to claim?

I didn't claim because of votes, I claimed because I have a result?

[forbiddanlight]

I didn't claim because of votes, I claimed because I have a result?

Then why didn't you claim earlier when you first posted if it's so important?

[SensFan]

omg, you guys are so annoying. That's what I actually thought.

Anyway, I will claim since no one wants to respond to me. I'm a cop, I know that Sens and Seraphim are not the same alignment, and I think that Sens is town. Hence I find Seraphim to be scum. His claim of vanilla does nothing for me.

Explain exactly how your claimed role works. No one else talk about his result or his role until this is answered.

[forbiddanlight]

Explain exactly how your claimed role works. No one else talk about his result or his role until this is answered.

There was one more thing I wanted to ask (well, right now), but I agree with this, Sens.

Well, except for the fact you failed to read Electra's gender symbol (or the gendered connotations of her name for that matter). But, overall, I agree.

[Electra]

I didn't claim because of votes, I claimed because I have a result?

Then why didn't you claim earlier when you first posted if it's so important?

Because it doesn't say that Seraphim is scum, I am deducing it based off my assumption that Sens is town and I wanted other people's opinions on this issue before I claimed but no one responded besides Seraphim, and there was no point to just sitting here waiting for nothing.

[Caboose]

omg, you guys are so annoying. That's what I actually thought.

Anyway, I will claim since no one wants to respond to me. I'm a cop, I know that Sens and Seraphim are not the same alignment, and I think that Sens is town. Hence I find Seraphim to be scum. His claim of vanilla does nothing for me.

Explain exactly how your claimed role works. No one else talk about his result or his role until this is answered.

[Electra]

Every night I submit a name and I get told if the person I submitted is the same alignment as the last person I submitted. The first night I get told that it's not the same, but since I don't have a submission before that, it's meaningless.

Night 1: Sens
Night 2: Seraphim - not same

[forbiddanlight]

Because it doesn't say that Seraphim is scum, I am deducing it based off my assumption that Sens is town and I wanted other people's opinions on this issue before I claimed but no one responded besides Seraphim, and there was no point to just sitting here waiting for nothing.

Fair enough.

Every night I submit a name and I get told if the person I submitted is the same alignment as the last person I submitted. The first night I get told that it's not the same, but since I don't have a submission before that, it's meaningless.

Night 1: Sens
Night 2: Seraphim - not same

Why didn't you target yourself?