Alright, I've gone back and re-read the thread and read a few more games to try to get another perspective.
First off: mastin. Don't think for a second I like your playstyle. You offer a lot of text with very little content. But I think you're more of a village idiot than a scum. I've seen bad players get good over the span of one game, and maybe you can be one. Shape up. For starters, I want to know your thoughts on Schehera and Panamon/mark. Also, do you have any other suspects right now?
Secondly: schehera. The more I look at this thread, the scummier you seem.
Scheherazade wrote:Town, I think we should hold off lynching Mastin, even if his posts have condemned him enough in your eyes, until after more players have posted.
It might be a red flag that he's encouraging us to lynch him, whatever his motive. And I think he's wrong when he states "you might regret hesitating": if we hastily lynch him as scum, we may lose some insight into who his partner may be.
Having written the above, his partner might lurk, but I think that any lurking is suspect anyway.
This is a nice sentiment, but you're really not offering town any incentive to NOT lynch mastin. I think that's what you were going for. If mastin is lynched, and turns up town, your protest is seen and helps your cred, keeping the pressure off you. If mastin isn't lynched, then there's a player that you've seen as weak and less of a threat who is still in play. Either way, if you're scum, you win.
Also, as I've stated, I don't like you referencing the cop in this game. I don't care if we have one or not, I don't want him to get any funny ideas and pop his head up in a way that scum (or you perhaps) can pick up on. We do not, and I repeat, DO NOT need to know who cop is if we have one. It is counter beneficial for cop's presence or name to be known.
Also, going back to the mastin issue again, in post 132, you try to extract material out of him that has already been extracted. It seems like you're not really paying attention to the game, or want him to remain suspicious. The less obvi-town players there are, the better chance scum has of surviving.
Regardless, I don't like your play at all.
Unvote mastin (again)
Vote: Scheherazade
Spring Lullaby: what exactly DID you mean by investigation? Also, do you have any other suspects besides schehera? And is there any good reason that you have yet to cast a vote?
Orange: where do you stand as far as scumdar goes? Any reason for the nonvoting?
Vollkan: is there any chance that when you votal, you can include a history? In another game I play, it's customary to include unvotes in the format (name). It makes it easier to run votals and easier to see history.
