Mini 681 - Mish Mash Mafia - THE END!

[ShadowGirl]

Busy weekend, sorry.

I think it's more likely that Emp didn't read the pages instead of tried to get away with that line of voting. But considering if you're unsure about the way mechanics works in a theme game you should ask or see if they've been discussed in the previous pages.

Hn, I don't know if I really like the suggestion of lynching Caboose. It it doesn't go well, it doesn't seem like something that one would have to take a lot of responsibility for.


[quote=Mana_Ku]Does it matter if you're dead day 2 when you've hit scum day 1? You should do anything you can do to get scum down even if it means you're own life as you (if you're town) win when town wins. [/quote]
QFT.

Still,

Vote: sekinj

Who seems pretty level headed.[/quote]

[Empking]

I read the pages. That's why I voted Mana Ku to start with.

I then forgot about it.

[letsbefriends]

If we go by majority vote to decide who will be lynched, will the outcome be any different whoever becomes the executioner?

[ShadowGirl]

If we go by majority vote to decide who will be lynched, will the outcome be any different whoever becomes the executioner?

Well, technically no [if it's a true majority] but people are funny in the way that they don't always due what you expect them to.

---

EBWOP: Tags. ><

Does it matter if you're dead day 2 when you've hit scum day 1? You should do anything you can do to get scum down even if it means you're own life as you (if you're town) win when town wins.

QFT.

[letsbefriends]

If we go by majority vote to decide who will be lynched, will the outcome be any different whoever becomes the executioner?

Well, technically no [if it's a true majority] but people are funny in the way that they don't always due what you expect them to.

How about we just pick who we want to be lynched, a la regular mafia. If we can decide who we want to become executioner by majority vote, why not just cut the middle man and decide who to lynch as a whole, instead of granting one single person unlimited power?

[Empking]

We can't just lynch normally.

We have to vote for an executioner.

[ShadowGirl]

If we go by majority vote to decide who will be lynched, will the outcome be any different whoever becomes the executioner?

Well, technically no [if it's a true majority] but people are funny in the way that they don't always due what you expect them to.

How about we just pick who we want to be lynched, a la regular mafia. If we can decide who we want to become executioner by majority vote, why not just cut the middle man and decide who to lynch as a whole, instead of granting one single person unlimited power?

I'm all for that idea, I'm just saying that things might not quite go that way.

[letsbefriends]

I don't see why we can't if everyone agrees to it. We decide who we want to lynch, elect anyone as executioner and they follow through.

Counter arguments are welcomed.

[ShadowGirl]

What if someone were not to go with whoever we [majority] agreed on?

[letsbefriends]

Automatically lynched the next day or whatever.

I assume if we even get to that point, it means that everyone would've already agreed to following the plan, so I see no reason they would stray at the last minute.

[Empking]

Automatic lynch = bad.

[letsbefriends]

Automatic lynch = bad.

I assume if we even get to that point, it means that everyone would've already agreed to following the plan, so I see no reason they would stray at the last minute.

[MafiaSSK]

I'm gunna trust sekinj as he's the one coming up with the glorius plans.

Unvote, vote sekinj

[letsbefriends]

I'm gunna trust sekinj as he's the one coming up with the glorius plans.

Unvote, vote sekinj

What plans are these?

Sekinj is the person I'd most likely have lynched at the moment.

[Empking]

You might agree with the plan, until you think the town got it wrong.

Also what if all but one person diagrees, what do you do then.

[ShadowGirl]

Automatically lynched the next day or whatever.

I assume if we even get to that point, it means that everyone would've already agreed to following the plan, so I see no reason they would stray at the last minute.

Regardless of the person they killed is scum or town?

[letsbefriends]

You might agree with the plan, until you think the town got it wrong.

That's what we're doing now. Discussing to see if anyone has objections.

Also what if all but one person diagrees, what do you do then.

Regardless of the person they killed is scum or town?

These questions are only of concern if we are going through with this. So until we decide whether we're going to even do it or not, I don't quite see the point in asking this now.

Tell me whether or not you agree with cutting out the executioner and going straight to lynching. I'd like to hear feedback such as you don't like it because it's mathmatically unsound, you see flaws, etc.

[MafiaSSK]

I'm gunna trust sekinj as he's the one coming up with the glorius plans.

Unvote, vote sekinj

What plans are these?

Sekinj is the person I'd most likely have lynched at the moment.

How to decide our lynches and how to decide our executioner of course.

[MafiaSSK]

Automatically lynched the next day or whatever.

I assume if we even get to that point, it means that everyone would've already agreed to following the plan, so I see no reason they would stray at the last minute.

Regardless of the person they killed is scum or town?

If its scum, then it was still an anti-town thing to do.

[letsbefriends]

How to decide our lynches and how to decide our executioner of course.

As Mana has already pointed out, it wasn't her idea. It was Caboose's.

[MafiaSSK]

How to decide our lynches and how to decide our executioner of course.

As Mana has already pointed out, it wasn't her idea. It was Caboose's.

I meant the whole Lynch for who want to lynch the Vote for who we want to be executioner and so on and so forth.

[letsbefriends]

I meant the whole Lynch for who want to lynch the Vote for who we want to be executioner and so on and so forth.

But almost no one is following that format now, including you.

[MafiaSSK]

I meant the whole Lynch for who want to lynch the Vote for who we want to be executioner and so on and so forth.

But almost no one is following that format now, including you.

But I am.

[Empking]

I'm following the format.

[letsbefriends]

Oh yes, I guess you are.

But explain to me why you're voting for the person who basically clarified an idea that was already on the table rather than the person who suggested the idea? I agree that it's a better idea, but I don't see why making something more clear=more town.