Silent Star 4: Yin and Yang

[Amy Dunne]

It worries me that no one is defending Chara including it’s buddy, because how can Chara + its buddy endgame in that case?

[Ydrasse]

ahhhh

[Ydrasse]

so the same thing i thought was happening with flea

[Amy Dunne]

why rush to clear someone...?

I’m saying if Chara is scum and it’s buddy is also condemning it, then how does scum win?

[Ydrasse]

i’m fairly convinced by the thing i wrote last night admittedly but i don’t see the case for a town chara?

[Ydrasse]

why rush to clear someone...?

I’m saying if Chara is scum and it’s buddy is also condemning it, then how does scum win?

no this was at you saying why rush to hammer test and to me it’s so we can have a smaller pool + given that chara has started pushing me i wanted to see how it would flip then because it would have to go back onto flea

[Amy Dunne]

Both scum have to be sentenced to win but no one wants Chara sentenced, which means if Chara is scum, then scum can’t win.

[clidd]

No idea what is going on with scum, but that's their problem.

I'm pretty sure Ydrasse is town so /shrug.

[Ydrasse]

scum could have misplayed but that feels like i’m calling them dumb

[Ydrasse]

No idea what is going on with scum, but that's their problem.

I'm pretty sure Ydrasse is town so /shrug.

clidd i know you’re not feeling this game but could you give your cases on everyone even if they’re lightweight

[clidd]

One guess is that they're trying to play independently to give the impression that they're not associated.

pedit: ok, let me take a look.

[Ydrasse]

charas flip on me feels so sharp that i genuinely can’t see the town angle and it felt... irritated in a way that i didn’t expect even if i was suspect of it

[Amy Dunne]

i’m fairly convinced by the thing i wrote last night admittedly but i don’t see the case for a town chara?

If this wasn’t the exact wincon for scum, that both need to be yeeted, that would be fine but if everyone is opposed to Chara being yeeted, then that’s anti-scum wincon if Chara’s scum.

So not having anyone defend it is strange, because one of its accusers is obviously its buddy then.

So is the hypothetical scum gambit, that when X Chara accuser flips red, we will then decide Chara is green, because that has to be scum’s gambit in that case.

[Amy Dunne]

scum could have misplayed but that feels like i’m calling them dumb

And Chara is definitely not dumb.

[Ydrasse]

i think at this point the scum plan is probably to drown us in wifom and pray it works

[Ydrasse]

scum could have misplayed but that feels like i’m calling them dumb

And Chara is definitely not dumb.

chara isn’t dumb and is in fact very smart but it also could have went with a meh plan

[Amy Dunne]

No idea what is going on with scum, but that's their problem.

I'm pretty sure Ydrasse is town so /shrug.

No it’s also town’s problem because no way doesn’t scum have a strategy here.

[Chara]

charas flip on me feels so sharp that i genuinely can’t see the town angle and it felt... irritated in a way that i didn’t expect even if i was suspect of it

why is it surprising that i'm going to wonder that you're scum after you say that i'm scum because i like a certain anime? it doesn't make any sense for me to do that if i was scum and i don't understand how this is your argument.

[Ydrasse]

charas flip on me feels so sharp that i genuinely can’t see the town angle and it felt... irritated in a way that i didn’t expect even if i was suspect of it

why is it surprising that i'm going to wonder that you're scum after you say that i'm scum because i like a certain anime? it doesn't make any sense for me to do that if i was scum and i don't understand how this is your argument.

it does if you didn’t expect someone to actually case you like that?

i had other reasons to think you’re scum but given the similarities in the character feel too much

also knowing that you do like that sort of thing makes it feel like it is you

[Ydrasse]

wait, wasn’t someone literally reminded of chara from one of yins posts

[Amy Dunne]

charas flip on me feels so sharp that i genuinely can’t see the town angle and it felt... irritated in a way that i didn’t expect even if i was suspect of it

Yes, that’s what bothers me a lot too, which is why I think Chara/Flea but then Flea completely shot down my Chara frame tin foil theory. \_0_/

[Chara]

i think at this point the scum plan is probably to drown us in wifom and pray it works

like there's no need for the wifom at all. i didn't even think it's a case of scum framing me, i don't really think there's a way you would have just been able to guess i like detective conan, but given this is your angle it does feel like you hoped that by using a character from something you apparently hate you could push it on to me instead.
like if i was scum and wanted to obfuscate things why don't i google some live action detective drama character. or like. batman.

[Amy Dunne]

charas flip on me feels so sharp that i genuinely can’t see the town angle and it felt... irritated in a way that i didn’t expect even if i was suspect of it

why is it surprising that i'm going to wonder that you're scum after you say that i'm scum because i like a certain anime? it doesn't make any sense for me to do that if i was scum and i don't understand how this is your argument.

Ydra/Flea/Clidd are all on the scum!you wagon, which if you’re scum, then that’s anti-wincon, so I’m wracking my brain on how a you/? team wins here, since both of you need to get yeeted.

[Ydrasse]

well we know scum controlled yin

and scum!yin told me that there's a scumbag within Pooky/Norwee/Chara.

and that would get town!me to maybe 1v1 vs Chara.

Now I don't see why the scum would do that if Chara and I are both town? It'd be kind of a disaster for them if I went all in on Chara no?

Hence Chara is a baddie.

Yes I was very drunk last night

also there’s stuff like this lmao

[Chara]

it does if you didn’t expect someone to actually case you like that?

i had other reasons to think you’re scum but given the similarities in the character feel too much

also knowing that you do like that sort of thing makes it feel like it is you

why wouldn't i expect someone to do that? it was the first thing i thought of to think about, and the first thing you thought of, and Flea.