Mini 681 - Mish Mash Mafia - THE END!

[Caboose]

Unvote

Enough foolishness from me.

Here's what I suggest.

We each pick a person that we would kill if elected executioner. Once we have everyone covered (everyone's got somebody that would kill them), then we play like a regular mafia game. Instead of voting for the person we want to lynch, we vote for the executioner who would kill that person.

Is that OK, or is that stupid?

[ShadowGirl]

But then it's basically a random lynch? We don't have really any reason to validly kill anyone at this point. :/

Unless we can change our choice of who we want to kill as time goes on?

[Caboose]

But then it's basically a random lynch?

I did not suggest a random lynch at all. I suggested that we play it like a normal mafia game, with a slight change in mechanics.

We don't have really any reason to validly kill anyone at this point.

No, we don't at this exact moment, but we will by the end of D1.

[ShadowGirl]

But then it's basically a random lynch?

I did not suggest a random lynch at all. I suggested that we play it like a normal mafia game, with a slight change in mechanics.

We don't have really any reason to validly kill anyone at this point.

No, we don't at this exact moment, but we will by the end of D1.

Sorry, I didn't understand what you meant, as you can see by the question mark.

So if we can change our 'kill target' during the course of the day, then I think this system makes sense.

[letsbefriends]

Hullo friends!

Does the game we play rotate from the list in the beginning or is it going to be Elect the Executioner the entire game?

[MafiaSSK]

Its gunna be ETE for the day.

[Tovarish]

Exactly, caboose has it nailed.

[sekinj]

I'm not sure that I agree with trying to defeat the "theme" part of the game...

[Caboose]

I'm not sure that I agree with trying to defeat the "theme" part of the game...

What do you suggest, then?

[letsbefriends]

I'm not sure that I agree with trying to defeat the "theme" part of the game...

What do you suggest, then?

Group hug!

[ShadowGirl]

I'm not sure that I agree with trying to defeat the "theme" part of the game...

What do you suggest, then?

Group hug!

Much better solution.

[sekinj]

I'm not sure that I agree with trying to defeat the "theme" part of the game...

What do you suggest, then?

Well, the logical would be to just pick the person who seems the most town...

[Caboose]

I'm not sure that I agree with trying to defeat the "theme" part of the game...

What do you suggest, then?

Well, the logical would be to just pick the person who seems the most town...

The person who is most town =/= the person who has the most in-tune scumdar

[Caboose]

Question to Max: How many votes does someone need to be executioner?

[Tovarish]

If elected, I will kill sekinj.

[letsbefriends]

Don't elect me because I don't want to kill. ;_;

[lord_hur]

Unvote

Here's what I suggest.

We each pick a person that we would kill if elected executioner. Once we have everyone covered (everyone's got somebody that would kill them), then we play like a regular mafia game. Instead of voting for the person we want to lynch, we vote for the executioner who would kill that person.

Is that OK, or is that stupid?

This seems like a good idea. Except that I think we should discuss as normal *then* ask for kill choices and elect the executioner.

[Knight of Cydonia]

I refuse to state who I would kill, because as soon as the scum know who each of us would kill, they can and more than likely will attempt to steer lynches onto town players who would kill town.

Vote Caboose

for suggesting it.

[Max]

Question to Max: How many votes does someone need to be executioner?

Standard Majority, 7

[lord_hur]

I refuse to state who I would kill, because as soon as the scum know who each of us would kill, they can and more than likely will attempt to steer lynches onto town players who would kill town.

Vote Caboose

for suggesting it.

You're supposed to vote for people you find pro-town, in this game. Why voting for someone you think suggesting something you think is pro-scum?

Your remark does make sense though.

[Max]

Vote Count "But I do nothing upon my self, and yet I am mine own executioner":

Caboose (1) Knights Of Cydonia
ShadowGirl (1) MafiaSSK
letsbefriends (1): ShadowGirl
Empking (1): Tovarish
Mana_Ku
Tovarish
orangepenguin
sekinj
lord_hur
Knight of Cydonia
MafiaSSK
RestFermata

Not Voting (8): Caboose, letsbefriends, orangepenguin, Mana_Ku, sekinj, Empking, lord_hur, RestFermata

[Mana_Ku]

I'd actually want to here from the other players as I really don't know who I should vote for.

I won't vote Caboose, that's a given. By suggesting that idea, it seems as if he's pro-town. I saw a game at the marathon day, where someone who also suggested an idea was the bad guy. This is a clear case of WIFOM.

Where's everybody?

[Max]

Everybody, except orangepenguin has not picked up PM

[Caboose]

I refuse to state who I would kill, because as soon as the scum know who each of us would kill, they can and more than likely will attempt to steer lynches onto town players who would kill town.

Vote Caboose

for suggesting it.

Huh? I make the suggestion that we basically turn this into a regular game of mafia. The scum are going to try to get elected executioner anyway, so I don't see why my suggestion is scummy.

FoS: Knight

for voting for me for something that's

not

a scumtell.

[Knight of Cydonia]

Scum won't want to be elected executioner, necessarily - it'd be wiser to push a lynch on a pro-town player who would kill another pro-town. That is why saying who you'd kill if selected is a bad idea - scum can push for a lynch that will give them a double kill of town. My vote stays.