Open 87 - Baby Too Much Scum - Over before 641

[Crazy]

not the fbi agent, but I want to vote Crazy. I heard she had heaps of links with armlx.

Waiting for goat and mence to discuss.

Right... the fact that I'm the FBI AGENT doesn't mean anything to you? Is that even a claim that mafia would fake?

[skitzer]

If you are the FBI agent, then of course I wouldn't vote you...

I'm just saying if you arent.

[Mencellator]

I heard she had heaps of links with armlx.

I don't like this sentence at all. Explain yourself, what do you mean you 'heard' this and what are these 'heaps of links'.

[Goatrevolt]

I am the FBI agent. Crazy is lying scum.

Night 1 I investigated Skitzer, not the SK.

Last night I investigated Mencellator, also not the SK.

With 5 alive, I don't honestly know why Crazy would lie about being the FBI agent. It doesn't seem to make any sense from any scum, but at any rate, I cannot see a town person making that play, and thus Crazy needs to be the lynch.

If Crazy is mafia, we simply win the game. That means that Grimmy has to be the SK, as I'm the FBI agent, and Mencellator/Skitzer are innocent. If Crazy is the SK, then we have 2 days to correctly lynch the mafia member, and I'm confirmed town, giving us a serious leg up.

Vote Crazy

If you're unsure, look back at one of my earlier posts day 2. I make the statement that I'm really sure Skitzer is part of the mafia and not a SK, hinting at my night investigation in case I died. I also was opposed to the FBI agent coming out, because I simply didn't want to have to claim and paint a target on my chest for a NK, when it wasn't completely necessary.

[Goatrevolt]

Also, Crazy was in favor of the FBI agent coming forward and claiming. If he legitimately was the FBI agent, why wouldn't he just claim right there?

-----

Here's the plan:

Crazy is SK: We can deal with this later, since the mafia doesn't have a NK, and we'll all be alive again tomorrow

Crazy is mafia: The SK has to be Grimmy at this point. I'm assuming I'd be night killed simply because I'll be confirmed town. If that is the case, Skizter/Menc have to lynch Grimmy, as I've confirmed both of those players as not the SK.

If Crazy is mafia, Grimmy is SK. If Crazy is SK, then we can discuss further tomorrow (although I have a fairly good idea of who the scum is at that point).

[Mencellator]

Sounds pretty solid.

Crazy, do you have a response?

[Grimmy]

Right... the fact that I'm the FBI AGENT doesn't mean anything to you? Is that even a claim that mafia would fake?

Yes.
Here is why.
Fake claiming FBI agent draws out the real FBI agent, which makes them a target for the SK that night. The real FBI agent knows this and this is why he/she is keeping quiet.

Grimmy
doesnt beleive the claim

[Grimmy]

edit using that bunchof letters...

I didnt see Goat's claim when I posted the above.

Just adds more fuel to the fire, though.

[farside22]

vote count:

Grimmy 1 vote: (Crazy)
Crazy 2 votes: (Grimmy, Goatrevolt)

Not voting

Mencellator
skitzer

[Crazy]

Right... the fact that I'm the FBI AGENT doesn't mean anything to you? Is that even a claim that mafia would fake?

Yes.
Here is why.
Fake claiming FBI agent draws out the real FBI agent, which makes them a target for the SK that night. The real FBI agent knows this and this is why he/she is keeping quiet.

Grimmy
doesnt beleive the claim

One, that's a terrible strategy for mafia. Of course I'm not mafia.

I am, however, the SK. And since there's no hope for me now...

Unvote, Vote Crazy

I swear, this wasn't my original plan. I had a much better plan that couldn't be executed, unfortunately. This was my plan B, which rested on Grimmy being the FBI Agent, since then I might be able to bluff my way into getting him lynched.

It looks like the town won this one, since now you guys have two lynches to find the mafia that's left.

Be prepared for a Crazy-explanation post-game.

[Crazy]

PS I think skitzer is the mafia.

[skitzer]

I'm thinking Grimmy is the mafia.

[/b]Vote: Crazy[/b]

[skitzer]

Vote: Crazy

[farside22]

vote count:

Grimmy 1 vote: (Crazy)
Crazy 4 votes: (Grimmy, Goatrevolt, Crazy, Skitzer)

Not voting

Mencellator

After a long day at the farm. I mean yesterday after a long day something just well Crazy happened.

"I'm FBI and I got guilty on Grimmy." Crazy says
"What are you talking about you nut job." Goat says "I'm the FBI and I found out who wasn't the serial killer, but that claim leads me to believe you are."

Everyone circles Crazy.

"Well what can I say?" Crazy shrugs his shoulders, runs to the kitchen and grabs lighting fluid. "I'm going out my way!"
He poors the lighting fluid on himself and sets himself on fire laughing hysterically.
"I had a plan, but now you are on your own finding scum. HAHAHAHHA."

Crazy - serial killer - burned to death day 3

Night 3 will only be 24 hours from this post
Night 3 deadline is Sept 30th, 4:00pm PST

[farside22]

Welcome to day 4. All is wonderful on are street. The serial killer is dead, however one last mafia scum remains. Who is the scum?
Is it:
Mencellator
Goatrevolt
Grimmy
skitzer

It's up to you to figure it out.
With 4 players it takes 3 to lynch
Deadline is Oct 30th, 4:00pm PST

[Grimmy]

While I was correct about Crazy, it still irked me to see her vote herself off the island.

So...

My evaluations of everyone else will come later this week (hopefully)

Grimmy

[Goatrevolt]

I want to read through everything before making a decision, but I'm currently leaning either Skitzer or Mencellator as scum here. Armlx put Grimmy at L-1 in a situation where a mislynch meant a mafia win. I doubt Armlx is going to push for a scum buddy in that scenario.

Armlx ignored skitzer almost all game, and swapped off of Grimmy and onto Mencellator "to get a response." I could see skitzer being a buddy just as well as that being a distancing technique with Mencellator.

[Goatrevolt]

While I was correct about Crazy, it still irked me to see her vote herself off the island.

Why would that irk you?

[Grimmy]

While I was correct about Crazy, it still irked me to see her vote herself off the island.

Why would that irk you?

I am not a big fan of the whole "suicide" act in mafia games. It is a pet peeve of mine. Not for this game alone, but for mafia in general.

At least this one did have the whole

F**k it. I vote myself. When I turn up town you can look at teh %$^&s who made me so upset that I gave up

Grimmy
has a pet peeve

[skitzer]

Hmmm...I personally think If I were armlx's buddy we would talk...

But you make a convincing point about grimmy. Which leaves Mence.

[Goatrevolt]

Hmmm...I personally think If I were armlx's buddy we would talk...

What do you mean?

[skitzer]

What I mean by that is that if me and armlx were ever scum together, we would be the type that didn't distance.

[Mencellator]

Finally managed to get back online after being temporarily banned by my uni. I need to have a better read.

At the moment I really feel like Skitzer could be the mafia. He was lurking at the right times (I sort of mean, at the times I would expect a mafia might lurk, if that makes sense.)
The fact the armxl was ignoring Skitzer is possibly significant.
I'm also irritated by this sentence, it just seems really scummy:

I heard she had heaps of links with armlx.

On the other hand, for the reasons I had been suspecting Grimmy as SK, I can also picture him being mafia. I suppose Grimmy would be my second choice for now.

[Grimmy]

Out of curiosity, what made you think I was the SK?

Grimmy

[farside22]

Mass prod again (sigh)