Mini Normal 2214 || Game Over!

[Dwlee99]

lol @ posting a game from 4-5 years ago.

Lol @ scum theatre

I like how we are both accusing each other of theatre with DW.

Seems like maybe I'm just town and you're both scum or dumb

[Dwlee99]

Damn, that was a great page top

[Dwlee99]

Okay so here's what I think:

If Rae is evil and Sigmund is good, Rae claims a guilty on Sigmund because Sig is an obvious check and also scummy as fuck. Gg scum win etc. That means if Rae is evil, it has to be with Sigmund imo. Assuming VFP town (so no bussing), Nero is confirmed scum because otherwise two scum (sig + shiki?) could log on and hammer this. Okay, so assuming Rae is evil I think that Nero and Sig have to be evil as well.

If Rae is good, then the team is VFP + two of {Nero, Sig, Shiki}. Now the question is if we discard the Shiki slot from the list. If we do then Nero + Sig are still scum regardless of Rae's alignment. If we don't, then it is possible that one of them isn't and Shiki is evil but I think at this point a lot of us are trusting the game on Shiki not tricking us.

[Dwlee99]

Anyway I think Sig has to flip scum here.

[Sigmund]

I'm conf-town

[Sigmund]

Anyway I think Sig has to flip scum here.

if D-Lee is town here he's 3 for 3 on killing innos

[Dwlee99]

How are you conftown? Only way you are town imo is Rae!town and Shiki has tricked us.

[T3]

Nero is a meta sr. VOTE: vfp

[Dwlee99]

Okay VFP I'm confirmed town now if you're town.

[T3]

Actually UNVOTE: vfp
idk where the vc is at.

[Dwlee99]

You put VFP at E-1

[Dwlee99]

VFP (3) - Rae, VFP, Nero

[T3]

Honestly if VFP is town that's borderline throwing.

[Menalque]

DAY THREE

VOTECOUNT 3.0

[3] VFP:

Rae, VFP, Nero Cain

[5] Not Voting:

JohnnyFarrar, Sigmund, T3, shiki, Dwlee99

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to eliminate.

The deadline is in (expired on 2021-06-19 13:45:16).

MOD NOTES

• JohnnyFarrar is V/LA. He has received a courtesy prod.

• Joined mod ISO

[VFP]

UNVOTE: VFP

[VFP]

So Dwlee is actually confirmed town.
The fact the game didn't end already means Rae and Nero are 100% scum here.

[VFP]

So it's basically a 50/50 on the 3rd right now unless 1 is just a traitor.

[Dwlee99]

VFP the only thing that could convince me you're good is if you can convince me that the novice macho cop would make this game unbalanced. I'm trying to find all the 12p games and look at how they've been balanced but I don't know how to find them.

I'm also trying to figure out if killing outside of the guilty 1v1 could work.

[VFP]

I mean, I'll lim Nero or Rae myself.
But I think the right play for town is to always lim in me or Rae.

I don't think you understand here how powerful 2 masons having macho doc is.
Even if you want to believe there is roleblocker instead of a roelcop then add it to your argument. The Rolestopper gets stronger with each town PR.
Do you honestly think that the game is balanced with that?

The only reason Novice was added to the role is because Rae didn't want to have to give any other results.

[Dwlee99]

Rae could have just said like "Shiki town" or something for the first result.

[VFP]

The more results the muddier it can get on questions.
Scum want to give as little as possible.

Ask yourself, why did Rae not check Nero?

[VFP]

I havent finished reading yet, but is Shiki a scum read to Rae day 1?

[VFP]

I couldn't see it day 1 and just looks like a town read.

Although, I will say the amount of scum comments to Sigmund to only vote once then instantly change vote isn't a good look on Sigmund.

[Dwlee99]

The more results the muddier it can get on questions.
Scum want to give as little as possible.

Ask yourself, why did Rae not check Nero?

Why do you think Rae has to check Nero?

I havent finished reading yet, but is Shiki a scum read to Rae day 1?

I don't remember.

[VFP]

Well going by his ISO, Human/Nero and Sig appear to be his favoured scum.