Mini Normal 2200 | Game Over

[Day]

[Something_Smart]

That's pretty disrespectful to skitter.

[Day]

Her positioning?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Luca Blight
NorwegianboyEE
Farkran
LegoLucy
PookyTheMagicalBear
skitter30
Ydrasse
Something_Smart
PenguinPower
Alisae
Chara
Menalque

Is this list in order of likely to be scum or "care about the game"?

[Something_Smart]

Putting her that high above Menalque. Implies that you think there's a decent chance she's town and wrong about him.

[Day]

Luca Blight
NorwegianboyEE
Farkran
LegoLucy
PookyTheMagicalBear
skitter30
Ydrasse
Something_Smart
PenguinPower
Alisae
Chara
Menalque

Is this list in order of likely to be scum or "care about the game"?

They usually correlate, but scum.

[skitter30]

i mean i thought it was weird to have me that high and mena that low at the same time but i'm not sure 'disrespectful' is the word i'd go with here tbh

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

you think not a single person which high scum WIM drew a red role PM?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

you think not a single person with high scum WIM drew a red role PM?

pedit by double post

[Day]

Putting her that high above Menalque. Implies that you think there's a decent chance she's town and wrong about him.

skitter's good, but has known to be wrong. I see her argument about Panic Room, I checked it myself and I can see the difference, Menalque makes more of an effort to fake solving and get townread for it. Still, he ended up being eliminated in that game and lost it as mafia. I don't think a playstyle change on it's own is a good reason to believe he's town, he may just care less this game as either alignment, or may even be going for a different approach knowing he was hydraing with skitter in Panic Room, and that she would like a shift like that.

'm reading him for his stances this game and I haven't liked those.

[Something_Smart]

i mean i thought it was weird to have me that high and mena that low at the same time but i'm not sure 'disrespectful' is the word i'd go with here tbh

Maybe not, but I see it as an undeserved insult to your ability to read Menalque.

[Ydrasse]

i mean i thought it was weird to have me that high and mena that low at the same time but i'm not sure 'disrespectful' is the word i'd go with here tbh

Maybe not, but I see it as an undeserved insult to your ability to read Menalque.

this feels a bit like shit-stirring.

[Day]

The hydra was a different game I shouldn't have mentioned. Disregard that.

[Ydrasse]

"how DARE someone insult your ability skitter... fucked up, isn't it?"

[skitter30]

he got eliminated there because he repped into a dead slot that was always going to die

i think this game would look more like panic room from mena if he were scum; i do appreciate that you actually did go and look at it tho
and i will note that i wasn't in a hydra with him there

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

SS is like the last person i'd expect to be shit stirring in this PL lol

[Luca Blight]

Putting her that high above Menalque. Implies that you think there's a decent chance she's town and wrong about him.

Skitter is human like the rest of us, she could easily be wrong

Although I am leaning towards Menalque being Town atm

[Chara]

I also didn't like 2122 because Chara acknowledged they haven't read most of the game and were playing a 5 page game or whatever, so how could they know when they haven't see what I townread Lucy for and why?

see, i asked you what you townread Lucy for, and i was working off of that. i can't work off of material i haven't gotten to yet, and if there was something besides the meta, you didn't supply it when i asked the question.

but i do see that you took the 5 page thing literally, and not as a joke about my playstyle.

regarding the thing about reconsidering, i thought that because a player who is reasonable could of course be town, it's just often a behavior i see scum do to defuse a situation.

your post about how i'm right and that you

were

treating her as town and so were reading into things with that bias also weirded me out, because it sounds like you're acknowledging i was right to find it strange while also finding it strange that i find you suspect.

[Chara]

Putting her that high above Menalque. Implies that you think there's a decent chance she's town and wrong about him.

are you saying Day should be thinking all of skitter's strong reads are correct?

[PenguinPower]

PP also but he probably won't obvwolf or obvtown d1

This is true. I miss the dr worm-esque persona.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Spoiler: Pooky/Skitter Dance PT

You are town right? Isis is not going to let me hear the end of this if you're actually scum >.>

[Chara]

oh, just Mena specifically. still, i don't think it's insulting.

[Something_Smart]

this feels a bit like shit-stirring.

It was probably needlessly harsh, you're right.

Bottom line was, I think skitter should be no more than a little bit higher than Menalque.

[Something_Smart]

are you saying Day should be thinking all of skitter's strong reads are correct?

Contingent on skitter being town, her reads are pretty likely correct, but especially on Menalque.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

I don't agree that Hectic would think that.