Open 93 - Near Vanilla: Game Over, Mafia Win!

[ChaosOmega]

Would rather not be replaced, will catch up later today.

[Korts]

Would rather not be replaced, will catch up later today.

That's good news, thanks!

[armlx]

I want a claim from gecko in his next post.

[killa seven]

Would rather not be replaced, will catch up later today.

[Doktor Per]

I do not want a claim from GeckoJ. If he's Mafia he'll just lie, if he's a non-power role we take a hit (as in we pro-town folk). Roleclaiming is all bullshit until you have stuff to back it up with.

[armlx]

I do not want a claim from GeckoJ. If he's Mafia he'll just lie, if he's a non-power role we take a hit (as in we pro-town folk). Roleclaiming is all bullshit until you have stuff to back it up with.

I don't get it.

Clearly you don't understand the purpose of the claim here. Lets explain step by step.

Do you agree, that barring extreme circumstances, Gecko is goingto be lynched today?

[killa seven]

I agree with armlx, if hes going to be lynched he might as well claim, so can focus on hopefully lynching scum.

[Doktor Per]

Oh yes, I just don't see him going "I'm a vanilla town" is going to help anyone, or sway most of us. (Or he can lie about the other stuff and then lie about his efficiency making him more protown than Jesus)

If he actually is a power role, we'll potentially have fucked over a Doc or Jailkeeper. But hey, the odds of that happening are only 2 in 13.

[Darox]

Oh yes, I just don't see him going "I'm a vanilla town" is going to help anyone, or sway most of us. (Or he can lie about the other stuff and then lie about his efficiency making him more protown than Jesus)

If he actually is a power role, we'll potentially have fucked over a Doc or Jailkeeper. But hey, the odds of that happening are only 2 in 13.

If he was a doc/JK, then surely we would stand to lose more if we lynched him without a claim, yes?

[Doktor Per]

Possibly, it's a gamble that can cut both ways.

[armlx]

Ok, Doktor.

1. 2/13 > 0.

2. If you realize he is going to be lynched if nothing changes, why not give the chance for something to change if he is indeed a power role.

[Doktor Per]

Because I rarely trust role claims, unless they have something to back it up with. Just because I don't lie, doesn't mean that someone else won't.

[Apothecary]

Woah, sorry I haven't posted in a while.

[armlx]

Doktor, the only reason someone would be lying is if they aren't town.

[killa seven]

Because I rarely trust role claims, unless they have something to back it up with. Just because I don't lie, doesn't mean that someone else won't.

This is true, but i highly doubt scum would pass up the opportunity to NK a power role, if hes lying scum and is here on lets say day 3 do you think he wont be lynched?

[armlx]

Also, usually you don;t straight up trust the claim unless you have a real reason to....

[Doktor Per]

So let's spin this question around. Do you have any reason to believe Gecko?

[armlx]

If he claims jailkeeper or doctor, yes.

[killa seven]

So let's spin this question around. Do you have any reason to believe Gecko?

Seeing as he hasnt claimed yet, this question is irrelavent.

[ZazieR]

I also don't see the point of roleclaiming, however it could be interesting later on.
If he lies, it's just a matter of time before he's found out.

Besides, claiming starts most of the time discussion which is good for town.

Thegeckoj, you've heard it. Claim in your next post. This is an order from armlx.

[MafiaSSK]

I also don't see the point of roleclaiming, however it could be interesting later on.
If he lies, it's just a matter of time before he's found out. .

[killa seven]

I also don't see the point of roleclaiming, however it could be interesting later on.
If he lies, it's just a matter of time before he's found out.

Basically what i was saying, but worded better with better grammar.

[Korts]

SpamWise has been prodded. Vote Count coming up

[Korts]

Fifth Vote Count

(5) thegeckoj -armlx, Darox, SpamWise, MafiaSSK, ZazieR

(3) MafiaSSK -Doktor Per, ChaosOmega, thegeckoj
(1) retrowiz -Apothecary
(1) Doctor Per -Gamma
(1) armlx -killa seven
(1) Gamma -retrowiz

not voting:

Sineish

[SpamWise]

Okay. I'm certain I posted yesterday. At least I remember reading the thread up to post number 168. And saying I was happy with my vote barring a role claim.

But maybe it was merely a dream?