Titus v Nancy Drew (Game Over)

[Gamma Emerald]

Pagetop

[Dunnstral]

Does that make any sense?

No, I'm responding to things as I read, and arguing that I'm "trying to go unnoticed" is a stretch

you're missing the point. the point is that I think you're asking too many questions and trying to blend in too much. Theres no good way to reply to this and I feel like your attempt to reply is also quite scummy.

That's... not a tell that I have, and me responding to you isn't scummy

[Batsunami]

IM CAUGHT UP YAYYYYYY
Ok bye I'm off cuz I hate being ninja'ed

pedit: DAMNIT GAMMA
Pedit2: fuck you

[Pyro]

Italiano is posting in a way which is designed to look bad and scummy, not by accident, but intentionally.

Interesting defense. What makes you say this?

I think Italiano is self-aware enough to recognize posting a few GIFs and then responding with "Hello" looks stilted and cautious. The post about him not bring a mason also looks incredibly bad. I think he's less likely to make these posts as scum.

[Fey]

A dunnstral SR is forming because of this post:

How much 'patience' do you really need to google deja vu and get the accents?

Last time I played with town you, you were so serious and your vibe was "lets get down to business I have no time for your bullshit baby talk, Noraa"
This time ... you're shitposting?

How is that a shitpost?? I think it's totally serious in response to the read... I don't get this SR.

Ok I'll admit that I didn't read that post carefully enough but it caught my attention because the tone was off. After almost finishing catching up, I'm 90% sure Dunn is scum here. The reason is quite simple. It's a tell that I picked up a while back - Dunn is doing a lot of short replies and many that are pretty mellow and a lot that are in the form of questions. This type of thing could be subconscious or on purpose but it helps you go unnoticed because your opinions and your voice is softer. Does that make any sense?

VOTE: Dunnstral

I mean, maybe? I'm reading this and I don't really like how you're walking back what I call you out on for and then you still double down on it regardless, and you didn't include it in the first place when you made the read? Like, it feels incoherent I guess with what you originally posted. I don't think that he's trying to go unnoticed, really!! ^^; He just seems to be poking and prodding but not in a way where he's keeping to himself. I don't think this read is very good. In general, your solve confuses me. I don't agree with much in it.

Why are you not on the War and Peace wagon if you think Ircher is scum? Isn't that more productive than voting Dunnstral?

Do you have any other reads right now?

Batsunami is likely town based on their enthusiasm here. They don't particularly like scum, and it feels pretty genuine enthusiasm. Aside from that, not really.

I think Sherlock and Watson are a bit quiet, but it could just be that they both aren't very active.

That's about it on reads for now.
~Ircher

Can you quote bits that you think are genuine for me? I just want to have a grasp on it. And I don't think they were too quiet, I mean. I guess I remember them because we had that same-brain thing going on... ^^;

i'd be happy to townblock with Fey, Charlie and Snoopy and Batsunami.

Can we include Pyro? He's leading the charge on War and Peace so I think he's earned his place with us for now, and that's even without him being apart of our little moment! I feel good about him.

sorry but definitely not

Seriously? What's put you off of him?

I think he had the least credible take on Toogeloo out of players who have commented.

I mean, I guess I disagree, he's pushing on things with whatever he can. I think it's super funny that he went for accent marks, that's so outrageous to me that I actually laughed and I liked it. Even if you don't want him in the townblock, I'm treating him like he is right now.

[Charlie and Snoopy]

I feel really good right now about Battle Mage and the Shadowslug hydra just because we all had the same take at the exact same time. It felt like all went 'huh' naturally together, and it made me giggle.

i'm not quite as enthusastic as this mostly because it felt like low hanging fruit and any decent scum would identify problems with ircher's posts, but i like you trying to form a lil gang early on

-ss

Are you saying scum would bus ircher, or that ircher could be town getting pushed by scum?

just that i don't necessarily townread BM/fey for having an issue with ircher's post, since I think his post is very easy to critique

-ss

[Rogue Squadron]

VOTE: Starcrossed

Let's get out of RVS.

This is always Town.
-Rogue 3

[Rogue Squadron]

Hi everyone. Jsyk, @Titus, I picked my masons based on who I think you picked and I’m going to be keeping a very close eye on those slots I didn’t get.

Can’t wait to wipe out your team, I’m practically salivating at the thought,

Ooh a game of wifom in wifom in wifom.

Based off who I think you drafted who I didn’t get, I may have already solved the game but I also know you couldn’t get everyone you wanted and fortunately I’m pretty decent at reading most of those slots, so I’ll know soon enough.

Over confidence. Wanna bet on it?

I bet she doesn't realize that you drafted me!!
-Rogue 3 (Lunar)

[Batsunami]

Why are you not on the War and Peace wagon if you think Ircher is scum?

I didn't connect the dots and realize war and peace was ircher. Like I knew ... kind of but then forgot. Yeah just dont ask. But no I'm not joining the wagon. As for reasons, go figure it out urself

[Gamma Emerald]

Italiano is posting in a way which is designed to look bad and scummy, not by accident, but intentionally.

Interesting defense. What makes you say this?

I think Italiano is self-aware enough to recognize posting a few GIFs and then responding with "Hello" looks stilted and cautious. The post about him not bring a mason also looks incredibly bad. I think he's less likely to make these posts as scum.

I dunno why he’d post that as town rn though

[Nancy Drew 39]

Nancy, can you do me a solid and listen to Pooky? unless he's scum.

VOTE: war and peace

ok wagon-o-clock

Yes, if he’s town here, I would definitely take his reads into account since he caught like two scum last game. However, I think it’s too early to have a read on him yet. I already have quite a few trs that I’m taking my cues from.

hey, here's hoping i'm one of them!

Slots I’m currently tl seem to like you so unless I have reasons to disagree, I’m not currently concerned with you.

[Pyro]

Really, Batsunami? 90% confidence in Dunnstral being scum?

[Fey]

I don't agree with the Italiano scumreads, for what it's worth! I think that dropping the self-vote and then peacing out is like... you're inviting scrutiny, honestly. And if Italiano is a bit like... nervous, as scum, which I think he is? He doesn't want to invite that onto himself and have to reply to people and explain on the off-chance he's prodded about it.

[Rogue Squadron]

So Nancy is the good guy and Titus is the bad guy? So if I’m not a mason, how do I help Nancy?

How do you spell Lah-mist?
-Rogue 3

[Dunnstral]

I think Italiano is being defended too hard for the content he's actually posted

Not saying that's scummy, just misguided

[Rogue Squadron]

I don't think Italiano is a likely draft, but I'm also fairly confident that I'll be able to sort Italiano.

-Rogue 3

[Fey]

Why are you not on the War and Peace wagon if you think Ircher is scum?

I didn't connect the dots and realize war and peace was ircher. Like I knew ... kind of but then forgot. Yeah just dont ask. But no I'm not joining the wagon. As for reasons, go figure it out urself

Uh... no, sorry! ^^ That isn't how it works... I'm going to ask, it seems weird for you to have just forgotten. Why are you stubborn about your vote on Dunnstral?

[Dunnstral]

I don't think Italiano is a likely draft, but I'm also fairly confident that I'll be able to sort Italiano.

-Rogue 3

Fair point

[Fey]

I don't think Italiano is towny really because that'd be silly, but I just think he's an easy place to post fake-misgivings/stick him into a solve.

[Batsunami]

Really, Batsunami? 90% confidence in Dunnstral being scum?

ye

[Battle Mage]

VOTE: dunnstral

i'll sheep noraa for a bit

[Batsunami]

Why are you stubborn about your vote on Dunnstral?

Because I want to be. Whats up with your obsession with me? I know I'm charming and all but uh no thank you.

[Batsunami]

XD im flavor leaf's apprentice nice to meet you guys

[Gamma Emerald]

I think Italiano is being defended too hard for the content he's actually posted

Not saying that's scummy, just misguided

What do you make of Pyro, then?

[Batsunami]

VOTE: dunnstral

i'll sheep noraa for a bit

yay!