Raw, Unfiltered, UPICK Game Over !

[MathBlade]

Spicy takes are fun Might be what this game needs

[Jake The Wolfie]

MathBlade is a 3P unjester

[MathBlade]

Got any other comments?

[Jesse Pierce]

Guitarist mafia modded by the baker

That was worded bad but the meaning is clear.

I would say poke Jessee and Grendel.

Seems odd the Jessee slot commented on what Grendel posted saying the wording is bad but the meaning is clear. How is this true and why did Jessee feel the need to say this.

I was referring to my own post. As I've said, my phone is broken.

[Uncrowned]

sorry for not being active my city just got announced as being back into lockdown so work today has been horrid and im drained

mathblade is prob town based on gut. the angle hes taking would be smart as scum but its more likely to come from town imo. seems like actual solving attempts

[MathBlade]

MathBlade is a 3P unjester

Yep! You figured it out! Congrats! /sarcasm

Got anything else to contribute?

[Gypyx]

backup moderation man to the rescue

Votecount 1.?

Jesse Pierce (2): Jake the Wolfie, Mathblade
Kop (2): chkflip, cassowary
Mathblade (2): Jesse Peirce, GreyICE
Uncrowned (1): Flea The Magician
Marky Mark (1): Not Known 15
Flea The Magician (1): Kop
Jake the Wolfie (1): Mistyx
Not Known 15 (1): Marky Mark

Not voting: Uncrowned, Grendel, vaxkiller

Within 14 alive it takes 8 votes to yeet someone into the void.
Day 1 ends in (expired on 2021-02-15 15:10:00), or whenever a yeet has been decided.

Kop replaces Fidget.

edited 2/17/2021 to bring VC format in line with my style -Gamma

[Grendel]

@GAmma and Gypyx

im voring fidget rn

[Gypyx]

can't edit sorry

[Grendel]

voting*

omg, im also drinking so forgive lol

am sinner of a thousand sins

-pre-edit - ahh, ok

[Grendel]

Guitarist mafia modded by the baker

That was worded bad but the meaning is clear.

I would say poke Jessee and Grendel.

Seems odd the Jessee slot commented on what Grendel posted saying the wording is bad but the meaning is clear. How is this true and why did Jessee feel the need to say this.

I;d like to hear about this observation from Jesse too

[Grendel]

As for the game,
Grey town
Math scum
Chkflip town
Grendel null
Marky scum read happened before I finished catching up. His later posting was clear town flail and anyone that doesn't see it isn't paying enough attention or is scum.

Curious why you included a null read for me

Also Chip is town why?

I dislike most of your posts to a very high degree but giving out a scumread will cement that and get me tunneled because I think it's just play style clash.
He seems pretty towny.

yeah, im v fimilar w/ getting SR'd for play stle reasons. Happens most games w/ me haha.

I think this insight might make you town actually. Town don't openly think of reasons of reasons player they wanna SR cant be scum. AT least i try NOT too.

[Grendel]

D1 end in the next few days, we should start consolidating wagins soon.

IM good moving to uncrown rn

I dont have any open reason to SR them, it mores that i have a lot of other players that i think are more net town, or at least net neutral. meanwhile Uncorwned doesn't fit in with those, and I dont see a reason to pull away from there lately. prevous SRs also fit into that bloc.

Could also vote Jakewolf if i had too.

[Grendel]

I must sound like Hoopla's D1 methology of "Hey if they are a leading wagon and aren't a town read just vote them off, its fine" lol

but only less than half the roster has show up as more likely town then not via action thus far. So remiaining no acitvers fall into PoE.

[Grendel]

VOTE: Uncrowned

[MathBlade]

I actually kinda wanna take you up on your Jake offer.

Getting bad vibes my first read was wrong.

VOTE: Jake

[Not Known 15]

I am not really caught up:( Lots to read.

I actually kinda wanna take you up on your Jake offer.

Getting bad vibes my first read was wrong.

VOTE: Jake

Do you have more than bad vibes?

[Flea The Magician]

Using my pre-stoned-yet-still-not-fully-in-pain-brain to make a quick catchup.
Fibromyalgia blows.

Spoiler: 11+12

Given I've got 1 game meta with both of you, you're the one slightly off meta. Mark is just super friend and a town cheerleader type imo

So Mark is like in a majority of his games?

I have 1 game experience with mark, and yes in that game he was town and behaved like this. Had quite a passive yet pokey relaxed attitude.

Given I've got 1 game meta with both of you, you're the one slightly off meta.

I mean, sure. But I'm not talking about meta in a wide sense. That can swing in so many different ways on a game by game basis depending on mood, the playerlist, the setup, roles, etc. etc.

What I'm pointing to (and why I'm partly annoyed at this BS narrative about my initial vote) is the fact that there is no evidence of Scumcrowned ever voting that way, while there's at least 3+ instances (I believe) of Towncrowned doing so.

Does that automatically mean I'm town here? Of course not.

Does that mean I should be given +scum equity? Hell no.

It's pure NAI or at best, slightly +town from a meta perspective and it's getting kinda gross having to keep justifying it with people who say I'm not engaging in good faith and that I'm misrepping when if anything, I'm the one being misrepped and the one being engaged in a way that seems to be in bad faith.

It's creating reactions and stuff to read both of you on though.

Time for a gamestate read.

As much as Mark is acting scummy, the lack of involvement from a majority of slots while we've been dueling is objectively +town for him, I'd say. Assuming this, there's probably scum on each of our wagons. Given Cassowary's weird fence-sitty comment about my one which just looked like someone trying show townie caution, I think we push there.

Honestly, I'm happy townbinning you both for now.

Spoiler: 15+16

Page 2. You haven't lynched Fidget. This is why you fuckers don't deserve democracy. Luckily glorious leader is here.

Vaxkiller and Grendel's avatar are both basically brown blobs. I've decided they're the same person. Also, they're the same person.
P. Sure Torin softclaimed third party. How fucked up is this upick nonsense? My tolerance for reading rules is v. low. I see we could have 9-4, 10-3, or 9-3-1. Mmm. Well, we can circle back.
Vaxkiller noting a need to rolefish is p. funny.
Page 4. Fidget not lynched yet. WTF
Mistyx is feeling newbscummish? Hmmm. Lemme get my noob detector wired up.
Mmm. No wait, noob town. Fidget still isn't lynched. WTF people.
Page 7. NO

Vote: Fidget

Can someone please explain how this thread isn't locked? I should be replacing into a game with a day 1 scumlynch already.

Absolutely no excuse people.

I missed the 3p claim?

I don't really care what your alignment is. We're lynching fidget today. It can be with you or over you.

Oof.

Of course I'm going to be stubborn. Fidget is literally obvious scum. You can roleplay as Titus, or we can do something useful.

Double Oof.
Expand on the foxbat read for me?

Page 2. You haven't lynched Fidget. This is why you fuckers don't deserve democracy. Luckily glorious leader is here.

We aren't executing Fidget until you fall off your high horse and die.

*popcorn monch*

Read the iso. Every post reads as if they are doing a play by play announcer with very little opinion.

I shall have a look when I'm more capable. Though not the answer I was looking for.

Spoiler: 17

I say you are scum
and you tell me I'm scummy and need to explain to you why I'm not scum

that's not how it works.

Yes it quite frankly is because I am obviously town and you right now have done the equivalent of a naked vote.

HAH.
*plants you on scales with GreyICE and see who weighs more*

Ok getting the stoned effect again, that's as far as I'm getting.
The V/LA end date isn't accurate, I just don't when when I'll be fully back.

[MathBlade]

I am not really caught up:( Lots to read.

I actually kinda wanna take you up on your Jake offer.

Getting bad vibes my first read was wrong.

VOTE: Jake

Do you have more than bad vibes?

Yes. I am a d1 cop and have a guilty on Gamma and Gypyx.

(Translation: No this is D1 everything is vibes.)

[Mistyx]

i think the issue with jake is that he just

isn't solving

[Marky Mark]

Phoneposting but will be on later

We need to start thinking about POEs, both to generate some common ground and also to reignite the discussion.

Fidgets getting replaced, so I'll give that slot the benefit of the doubt to see what the replacement does.

My ideal POE would be uncrowned or NK15 here, but I'd happily take a policy elim on Jake if the consensus was more over that way.

Happy to chat through any and all of the above later when I can type easier

[cassowary]

If fidget is replacing out, feels bad to eliminate them today I guess.

Why are we back on uncrowned? Do you guys think uncrowned looks particularly scummy? I think uncrowned looks like another 'town who's convinced they've got it figured out when they don't' to me.

I think if we aren't going to do Fidget my preferred elim for today would be Not Known. The NK/Mark interactions earlier in the thread look pretty bad, I think. Looks like reaching to try to get town to wagon onto someone who had a few votes but might become difficult to vote out later. And the rest of their reads are... pretty ridiculous imo. I guess I'll see where they're at once they finish catching up.

I'm not really SRing jake very hard but I concur with others that if he isn't going to be helpful it would be best to policy-eliminate him early on so he doesn't become an issue later

[Jake The Wolfie]

@GAmma and Gypyx

im voring fidget rn

OwO

voting*

Oh, woah.

[Jake The Wolfie]

I don't become a problem later unless [REDACTED DUE TO ONGOING GAME]

[Gamma Emerald]

Kop replaces Fidget.

quoting since the initial notice got messed up