Mini Normal 2191 | Endgame

[samantha97]

no idea why you guys aren't suspecting that that was a gambit

I mean... it even worked lol

[samantha97]

obviously it's possible that she's just town but she pounced on that as soon as it started, and there's no way town would want town to go into the next day knowing they had only 1 attempt to get it right

[clidd]

Do you see something scummy on Maduisha by ISO, Sam?

[samantha97]

what just happened was a manifestation of what I found suspicious before, so yeah?

[Cabd]

Literally my tinfoil is that it's somehow Maxwell-Fuzzy and this is all a giant game of charades.

[clidd]

Ok, just that?

[samantha97]

pretty much

the note I had about being apologetic might be something but yeah that's about it

[clidd]

UNVOTE: samantha97

Let me check something then.

[Cabd]

{Clidd}
{Maduisha, Umlaut}
{Fuzzy, Samantha}
{Maxwell}

Adjusted...

I'm re-reading and a certain set of posts REALLY sticks out as fucking bonkers...

But eh. That's reads and zero setup spec involved in them. (Obviously, a clear on clidd is a clear on clidd)

[Cabd]

i think it is likely scum is claiming vanilla. Giving my role and Cabd role it is likely one is claiming VT to make the balance seem more town heavy then it is. As i believe Cabd role.

TBF it is weird that Cabd investigated Clidd instead of me since i was the number 1 suspect yesterday. Part of me thinks that it was that she was paranoid and wanted to make sure Clidd was town since he was TR by almost everyone. The other is i might be wrong and for some reason and Cabd is fake claiming.

Fuzzy, can you please, please give some consideration to the people here who have an understanding of setup balance who are telling you it is basically impossible that your role, a cop, and a doctor exist inside the same setup. I'm saying it, Cabd is saying it, Umlaut has actually modded normal games, we can't all be scum.

Nah, you're deliberately being evasive in your stances. You're refusing to commit to a read on multiple players or analyze the likelihood of possible scumteams, because if you try to actually look for a scumbuddy for fuzzy, it falls apart pretty quickly. Last I communicate with you on the matter. Fairly sure you're scum now so I'm not going to bother debating you anymore. My words are for those I need to convince.

Gods above and below, Arceus Damn, these posts give me the biggest hive-rash ever.

[maxwell]

no idea why you guys aren't suspecting that that was a gambit

I mean... it even worked lol

There's always the possibility, but I didn't think she seemed the type, I guess it's something Cabd could have come up with.

UNVOTE:

[maxwell]

Rereading Maduisha's ast post I don't like it as much. This is harder than it has any right to be.

[clidd]

Ok, let's go back to: VOTE: Maduisha

If she's scum, good. If she's town, ok, we learn something. I kind of just want to end the day.

Sam is scummy, but Nep had some peculiarities that sound like a towny dissonance or something like that, so yeah, I'll just ignore that for now.

[Cabd]

If I had to GTH i'd yoloshoot Maxwell-Samantha, but I don't, and I'll defer to you all I guess.

[clidd]

Also none of you are cohort players lol. That's not an insult but an actuality.

what's a cohort player?

And if Nep was scum (speculation), I don't think she would interfere after being replaced (assuming she had a scum PT to look etc)

Ohhhh lol

Something similar to Zulfy commenting after he was dead, considering he had no PT to look at.

[clidd]

Other reason is that if Maduisha flips town, I can blame Max regardless of the alignment he is (since the idea of ​​scumread on Maduisha came from him)

[Umlaut]

Since I didn't say this explicitly: if we're eliminating Maduisha, Fuzzy should be checking Sam. I think that's actually the only useful target since clidd was neighborized, though I'm not 100% sure how that works.

@mod: how would a player who started as VT but later got neighborized investigate to a Neapolitan?

What is VC now? At this point I agree with clidd, just eliminate one of the two.

pedit

That's actually a good point about Nep.

[Umlaut]

UNVOTE: Sam

Willing to vote Maduisha at this point but I'd like to get the answer to that question.

[clidd]

He's the kind of mod who prods a dead player, so..

Send a PM.

[Umlaut]

Already did.

[Cabd]

Why would you check clidd anyways given I have a clear? Unless you think the team is exactly Cabd clidd.

[clidd]

He said on the hood (that was a long time ago) that one of the paranoia scenarios could be Cabd + Clidd, but idk if he truly considers that as possible.

[Umlaut]

Why would you check clidd anyways given I have a clear? Unless you think the team is exactly Cabd clidd.

I mean, as clidd said it's not out of the realm of possibility, but I was originally going to just write

check Sam because I'm confident enough clidd is town

and only realized as I was writing it that clidd might not even be meaningfully checkable by a neap.

[Cabd]

No offense but if it was Cabd clidd we'd already be done with the game and talking about how fun it was to win.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

sorry guys long day today..... I am going to crash. I wanted to catch up today but it just didn't happen. I Will dig in tomorrow. Just wanted you to know I am not trying to avoid commenting.