Open 87 - Baby Too Much Scum - Over before 641

[Goatrevolt]

Grimmy, you claim first.

Popcorn after that. Grimmy picks the next person to claim, who then picks the following person, etc.

[armlx]

Agree with popcorning.

[Crazy]

Agreed.

[Grimmy]

Ok then, I investigated Goat and got an Innocent result. Crazy , you are up next, but remember that Armlx is out for a while, so everyone should leave his claim for last so we dont stall the game waiting for a claim.

Grimmy
passing the baton to crazy

[farside22]

Mmmm popcorn. Might as well get some at the rate things are going.

vote count:

crazy 1 vote (Grimmy)

not voting:

Mencellator
Goatrevolt
Crazy
armlx
skitzer

Day 2 deadline September 20th, 9:00am PST

[Crazy]

Investigated Username.

Mencellator, you're next.

[Mencellator]

I checked Grimmy, and he's not SK.

Goat, you claim next.

[Goatrevolt]

I checked Sktizer and he's not the SK.

He can go next, though.

[skitzer]

I checked goat and he's pretty innocent.

armlx, I choose you!

[armlx]

I also say Goat is not the SK.

[Grimmy]

so the tally

4 people say Goat is not the Sk
1 says Grimmy is not the SK
1 says Iam is not the Sk.

At least we know Crazy is right....

So where do we take this info from here?

Grimmy

[Goatrevolt]

3 people say Goat is not the Sk
1 says Grimmy is not the SK
1 says Iam is not the Sk.
1 says Skitzer is not the SK.

Fixed that for you.

I'm not sure how meaningful that information is. I'd like to be able to say that since 3 players said I'm not the SK that there's a 50% chance one of them is the FBI agent, thus clearing me, but that's not a very strong argument.

I'd like to just reread and see what I can pick up from that.

[armlx]

I really don't think we can read much into those results.

[Mencellator]

Yer, not much can be done with them. Though I would feel more comfortable lynching someone other than Goat.
And if you wanted to be super-strict on odds, I suppose you'd lynch someone who isn't checked at all. But actually that wouldn't work because the fact that these people were 'checked' means we suspected them as SK, right? Looking too heavily into the results is going to lead us astray.

[armlx]

Looking too heavily into the results is going to lead us astray

I think looking at all into them has a large potential to do so. For example, you said Goat was least likely, but lets say all 3 of the people who said he wasn't SK aren't the FBI Agent. They all thought he was a logical checking target for some reason...

Basically, its all WIFOM.

[Crazy]

Since only one of those six results actually mean anything, I don't think it's a good idea to look into it. This really is just for reference in case the FBI Agent is killed tonight.

[Grimmy]

posting this in all games

Jury Duty starts Sep. 11th. Ill likely be out until monday at the earliest.

Grimmy
at the pace this game has been at, I dont think my absence would have been noticed anyway...

[farside22]

Mass prod

[armlx]

Yeah, I'm here. I haven't had time for a reread yet though. Possibly tonight.

[Crazy]

Here.

Vote: Grimmy

. Out of the votes on the Oman wagon, his looked the most suspicious to me.

[armlx]

Seems fair.

Vote Grimmy

Gogo wagon Rangers!

[Mencellator]

Vote: Grimmy

Not just because Crazy and Arm are voting but I was planning on voting Grimmy anyway.

[armlx]

Not just because Crazy and Arm are voting but I was planning on voting Grimmy anyway.

Reasons?

[Goatrevolt]

I'm not sure about the speed of this wagon here. The fact that Grimmy is already at L-1 scares me.

I would strongly suggest no hammer.

[Crazy]

I'm not sure about the speed of this wagon here. The fact that Grimmy is already at L-1 scares me.

I would strongly suggest no hammer.

I agree with this.

I'd like to hear Mencellator's response to armlx's question before I decide what to do.