Mini 660 - Star Trek: DS9 Mafia (Ruined = Over)

[Ozymandius]

First of all:

Unvote: Timeater

It was just a random vote and at this moment I don't see anything to warrant it. This game is going a lot faster than my newbie game.

Personally I don't think claiming here is a good idea. I think it would give scum too much information right now.

[Jebus]

you have no idea what my playstyle is like.

I could say the exact same. And like you, I'm used to taking votes/etc throughout the game.

Though since your playstyle seems so much like my own, I'd wager I could make a few accurate predictions as to your actions.

First off, you'll probably come up with a reason why the roleclaim is a good idea, and then try to convince everyone else of it. Though I'm not completely in agreement with it, meh, it may be worth it.

My vote was random too, so

unvote

.

[Timeater]

Roleclaims are apart of the game. I'm not suggesting a massclaim d1 or anything (although I think Liam did? Minor FoS on him for that). I'm just STATING that roleclaiming is apart of the game and will be necessary at a point. Yeesh!

Zone where the eyeofnewt are you? -_-

Also poking:

td
firestarter
frelaras

Post people!

[ZONEACE]

I posted 9 and a half hours ago, thats where I am.


Can we get on with this, I think we have enough to go on for a day one lynch or atleast for a forced claim.

I thought jebus why playing like nubtown, he said he's not a mafia nub, so that only leaves scum as a possibility for his behavior.


MORE VOTES PL0X


*insert klingon catchphrase that obviously makes me scummy*

[Jebus]

Well, my opinion of you, Zone, is basically that you are an idiot <_<

[sekinj]

Oh my goodness. I suddenly agree. Let's lynch Jebus, just to get him out of the game. First it's the nub card, now it's personal attacks, next he will be voting for himself.

[Jebus]

Personal attacks are things I rarely do, and what may be noob to you isn't the same to me. As for voting for myself, that's something I never do.

[Light-kun]

Repitition is a huge win Jeebus. (spelled intentionally that way.)

Okay, this is pissing me off, but Fire was prodded, so I am lax there.

FoS: Liam

Okay, I know someone minored it, but since I posted before this how stupid of an idea a D1 role claim is (you know, except for *probably* confirming townies of people who know nothing of the series), I feel obligated to put up the big bad bold meaningless Finger of Suspicion.

*Dramatic music and lighting is requested for the viewing of this post.

[CallMeLiam]

Fos: Tim

for slapping down the claim idea without actually discussing it. I hadn't thought about the fact that some of our players won't know all the characters though L-K, good point. I wasn't gonna push for it or anything, but I'm happier not claiming now.
Jebus: Your play is making it very easy for me to vote for you. Personal attacks have no place in mafia.

[ChannelDelibird]

"Well, I was hoping that our Vote Count would be a long and happy one, but I suppose I'm willing to settle for short and exciting."

Jebus (4): CallMeLiam, frelaras, Timeater, ZONEACE

Timeater (2): Nudude, sekinj
Ozymandius (1): Firestarter
ZONEACE (1): td

Not voting (4): Light-kun, Pie, Ozymandius, Jebus

7 votes to lynch.

[Timeater]

Fos: Tim for slapping down the claim idea without actually discussing it. I hadn't thought about the fact that some of our players won't know all the characters though L-K, good point. I wasn't gonna push for it or anything, but I'm happier not claiming now.

Dude no one was asking you to claim I'm boggled as to how you got that idea. As for not discussing, I dont see what I havent been discussing.

[CallMeLiam]

Top of page six Jebus seemed desperate to claim. It was pinging my scumdar and I waned to get my thoughts out. You did nothing to say why you disagreed with me, but instead just said that you did.

[frelaras]

Sorry for the lack of posts. I've been moving house, and even now I'm 'borrowing' someone else's internet so I can check on my games. Hopefully my connection will be in soon. Anyways...

Wow, Jebus is not responding very well to this wagon at all. I really can't see moving my vote at all.

And while discussing some sort of claim may be useful, I'd really not like it to derail things 'today'. As was already brought up, the potential (quite likely) presence of changelings makes claims a little dubious anyways. Too dubious to derail a behavioural wagon IMO.

[Firestarter]

In case anyone hasn't seen my sig, Im gone for a while, I cannot commit to games, and I require replacing.

Unvote...

[ChannelDelibird]

Searching for a replacement for Firestarter.

[ChannelDelibird]

Mana_Ku replaces Firestarter. Thank and praise him.

[Mana_Ku]

Her and I'm going to read this game ASAP

[Timeater]

-_-

[ZONEACE]

Her and I'm going to read this game ASAP

May you not be a petaQ.

[Jebus]

Fos: Tim

for slapping down the claim idea without actually discussing it.

The idea has to be brought up to discuss it, doesn't it?

Jebus: Your play is making it very easy for me to vote for you. Personal attacks have no place in mafia.

Personal attacks aren't part of my play. They spontaneously occur when someone is pissing me off, and it takes

a lot

to piss me off. I only make such comments on these rare occasions.

Either way, lets get this game going.

Mana_Ku, whaddaya think of this so far?

[sekinj]

Jebus: Your play is making it very easy for me to vote for you. Personal attacks have no place in mafia.

Personal attacks aren't part of my play. They spontaneously occur when someone is pissing me off, and it takes

a lot

to piss me off. I only make such comments on these rare occasions.

You can't defend your personal attack by saying you don't do personal attacks.

[CallMeLiam]

Fos: Tim

for slapping down the claim idea without actually discussing it.

The idea has to be brought up to discuss it, doesn't it?

Jebus: Your play is making it very easy for me to vote for you. Personal attacks have no place in mafia.

Personal attacks aren't part of my play. They spontaneously occur when someone is pissing me off, and it takes

a lot

to piss me off. I only make such comments on these rare occasions.

You brought the idea up, and Tim didn't explain why he thought it was a bad idea.
Secondly I echo what sekinj just said.

[Jebus]

Fos: Tim

for slapping down the claim idea without actually discussing it.

The idea has to be brought up to discuss it, doesn't it?

Jebus: Your play is making it very easy for me to vote for you. Personal attacks have no place in mafia.

Personal attacks aren't part of my play. They spontaneously occur when someone is pissing me off, and it takes

a lot

to piss me off. I only make such comments on these rare occasions.

You brought the idea up, and Tim didn't explain why he thought it was a bad idea.
Secondly I echo what sekinj just said.

I brought up a win-condition claim, not a full roleclaim. That, of course, made no sense, since the win condition was posted by ChannelDeli. I missed that, and then found no point in the roleclaim.

@sekinj - I don't defend it at all. I did it. Leave that part alone now, mmkay?

[Mana_Ku]

I just read this game. I'll have to look into it more as we don't have anyone as suspect except Jebus. I'll wait with my vote against Jebus. As I've seen a pre-game talk of his. Even though he says he isn't newbie, he has newbie thoughts which give others the idea that he's scum.

But I believe that games shouldn't influence other games. I don't think we should roleclaim at all. Most of us (right Light?) know the characters and can perhaps link the claimed with a mafia role, like a doctor or something like that.
Could you explain why you want us to claim? And what is that win-condition claim you talked about?

[frelaras]

And what is that win-condition claim you talked about?

In games where the town WC isn't publically available, we can sometimes catch scum based on them messing up the wording when guessing a town WC. Since many people feel that's poor play, mods will just post the town WC, making claiming it pointless since everyone could just copy and paste the town one. So, as has been pointed out, the idea is dead and gone.