Open 796: Haunted Village Game Over

[MURDERCAT]

To avoid the massclaim.. (oops)

[PlusJOYED]

I am assuming Dunn is fake claiming otherwise we flip me and then plus and win

i'll be suprised if I'm alive
But my guess is murder is scum probably.

[MURDERCAT]

4 pts from dead WHs
2 pts from Plus WH
2 pts from MC WH
2 pts from Isis (likely fake)
1 pt from Dunn commuter
1 pt from Gamma commuter

If Isis is fake we are at total of 10 pts. I forgot 9 pts is possible so if Dunn isn't lying we just flip me and gamma

[PlusJOYED]

I'm at the point where we just need to ask dunn if he was faking then I'm done

[MURDERCAT]

Plus for the 1000th time me claiming there literally makes it impossible to win for the reasons listed above.

There is no reason for me to fake claim when I was being town read by so many people.

[MURDERCAT]

The thing is that if Dunn isn't fake claiming then Gamma fake claim makes no sense to me because I think we always take Dunn over Gamma.

[PlusJOYED]

you aren't gonna convince me murder, and I'll be dead probably. The play was very questionable as scum or town.
try the others maybe

[MURDERCAT]

The play where I claim my real role is questionable as town??????

[PlusJOYED]

gamma was pretty lost/out of it until recently. I can see that claim

[Gamma Emerald]

I think it’s probably 2 of {plus, MCat, Isis}
It could be Dunn but I don’t think it’s him by play

Honestly it feels like Plus is slipping scum perspective a little here

[Gamma Emerald]

If it’s Plus and MCat this game is like the most fucked up sequence of events I’ve ever seen

[MURDERCAT]

I mean Isis is scum, I'm not sure how that could be not true give what is pretty clearly a guilty

[Gamma Emerald]

That’s the thing bothers me the most about your play today MCat
You seems 100% sure about the guilty, but imo there’s still room for doubt? I’m trying to be scholarly about how I approach things (despite clearly not having the brainspan to really do much good with it)

[MURDERCAT]

I've been SRing isis since Noraa flipped. If it's not Isis that means it has to be plus which I don't buy, right?

[MURDERCAT]

Also like how is that post from Cobra not a guilty?

[Gamma Emerald]

Is there a reason it can’t be Isis and Plus?
I’m not saying the post isn’t a guilty, I’m saying it’s not damning, since we don’t know what Cobra specifically did.

[MURDERCAT]

Isis and plus is technically possible but I feel like you are just heading at straws tbh. I don't think plus commits to fake guilty there

[MURDERCAT]

Grasping*

[MURDERCAT]

Assuming Dunn claim is real because I was just confused before I am tracking gamma tonight.

[Infinity 324]

Let’s wait for dunn

[Gamma Emerald]

The way the game has shaped up it appears 2-3 of my D1 teamguess was right
And the loosest of that was MCat because of being part of a set of 3 slots I had the same level of suspicion on, so rn I think the reality of things is that it’s Plus/Isis/ego

[Isis]

PlusJOYED is scum. There is no reason to believe he's not scum except for mech. He scumslipped several times in the way he pretended to think through the mech. I know nothing I say is likely to help with the ridiculous fake guilty thing, but if you flipped Plus you could clear me and get tons more shots finding the partner.

VOTE: PlusJOYED

I kind of have no idea of

MURDERCAT

is 9d chessing as scum with a fakeclaim or 9d chessing as town with a fakeclaim or is actually just a town PR who I have gotten bad vibes from due to something I didn't know, but in that last one, PlusJOYED is just even more scum.

If the people who are town can set aside Kai a lot more than they are doing I can do more to show I'm town, but if it stays at "Isis play doesn't even matter" it's more harmful for the town to spend a longer amount of time in a false headspace for the purposes of solving later. It can get stuck in your head. I've seen it mess up town before. So I'm just going to put my vote on scum and say

MURDERCAT

is still my best guess for next even if I don't know about it. Like this headspace is hard for me too and I can't solve in it.

[Gamma Emerald]

I think this pretty well encapsulates the thought process I’ve had this game

Honestly I feel like my validity for Paragon this year probably hinges on this game

[Gamma Emerald]

Coming back to this I think Isis’ first paragraph is like entirely in line with how I’m thinking
But I’m bothered about how Isis is acting like Plus being limmed and flipping scum is a sure resolution of her and ensures her ability working. She can’t know that for sure, you know? So that kinda firms up my thinking of Isis/Plus

[PlusJOYED]

it feels like gamma and murder are on a race to outscum each other, at least from my pov.
I just don't see how gamma comes to that conclusion as town.