Hmm. Well, might as well get my thoughts on the claim cleared up now that I've seen other peoples posts about it and checked the MD discussion thread. So, here are my thoughts:
As Miller:
Claiming Day One is probably the best play, as a claim right after a guilty result is revealed comes off as really contrived. Claiming day one, page one even, seems like the proper play as miller. Not only does it get the idea out there early, but it also provides a good basis for discussion early which is fairly protown.
As Scum:
Claiming Day One is probably the best play, as a claim right after a guilty result is revealed comes off as really contrived. So, if the scum wishes to claim miller, day one is definately the best time to do it as well. The claim, however, attracts a lot of attention to the scum. Many players as scum wouldnt be ballsy enough to pull the claim due to the increased scrutiny.
So the question to me is whether User is skilled enough, and ballsy enough, to pull this as scum. He only has two completed games as mafia, but theyre both wins. Definately worth checking out. So as of now, I'm undecided. I will say that the flavor makes a lot of sense, however.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Other random commentary/questions:
1)
Darox - In post 9, you subtley changed your vote to Username but provided no specific reasons for doing so. Was this on the basis of his claim? If so, why was the claim voteworthy? Oh, same goes for Rashiminos, though your post had less subtlety involved.
2)
fhqwhgads and crywolf - you both posted after usernames claim without making any mention of it, even though it was the only relevant issue to come up at that point. Why did you choose not to even mention the claim? This goes for Lowell as well, however he only initially ignored it and then chimed in after ythills post.
3)
bionicchop - in post 19, you mention that investigating username is useless. Couldnt the investigation be used to prove sanity of a cop, if there is one?
4)
Tony - You call lowells attack vague and unsubstantiated. Could you elaborate on why this is? It seemed like he had a decent point to me so I'd like to see where youre coming from.
I play the games rul gud.