@xtoxm Who would you be very happy killing today?
At the point you asked this:
Crub
EK
KMD
LF
And poss RF.
But from what i've glanced at this changes.
I'll post an updated one once i've read new stuffs.
I don't understand what you are saying here.
Yeh sorry, sometimes things come out wrong if i'm trying to multitask thinking with typing quickly
What I meant wa sthat the suggested scenario, ie scenario C, is the argument that holds true, irrespective of our alignments.
Like so..!
c) BG
is town and
simply agrees with some points made by xtoxm, and then disagrees with other arguments brought up.
My shall stay where it is for now, for even though the lover claim makes sense in regards to the connection, this point:
I suggest you change that before I start finding it scummy.
makes me still feel that my argument above holds some weight. The fact that BG decided to claim lover with you when only three votes (I think it was three votes) were on her only assists in supporting my reasoning for finding her suspicious on the premiss of her actions being erratic/frantic at times. This factor still makes me feel that BG is hiding something, other than the now-revealed lover situation she had been concealing. It is possible for you to both be town, but it is also possible for one of you to be scum and the other town, as well as both scum, so I am at a loss right now. I feel that my earlier suspicions of you have waned to a certain degree, but I feel your lover partner to still be suspicious.
From the way she has acted, I think she is town. If she is scum, I don't think it will matter much, because I can't see us both making it to the end regardless....
I was annoyed when she claimed so early, escpecially when it was just after my posting a defense rather than after an attack or something, but there's nothing I can do about that. But her reasoning is real - I was in said game when she was cop. She just claimed it out of nowhere day 1. I was scum, there were no doctors. Cop dead N1 nice and easy...
But whatever happens, we aren't lynching claimed lovers on Day 1. More likely we'll find out on Day 2 whether they're telling the truth one way or they other.
Wrong. Scum might not kill us tonight (assuming we are both town) - We are lovers. It's not all that powerful a role. They might try to kill a cop or doc or some such role. The only thing they gain from us is a double kill. We also might be kept alive if they think we are a legitimate lynch target.
STD - I didn't like his silly FOSing of 10 players, but overall I quite liked his entry.
After much deliberation, I have determined that your role screws us over pretty much equally whether we lynch you now or whether you prevent us from being able to sucessfully lynch the scum later on in the game (Thanks, mod). Why Xtoxm would be advocating your lynch over scumhunting is beyond me. However, I am not opposed to thinking about pulling the trigger if we're caught with our pants down and nowhere close to a lynch, and neither should you.
I'm glad another person see's my side of it
I am seriously pretending everything you say is in the voice of Hitsugaia. However, it's been a long time since I've seen Bleach, so I have no idea if that's his name or not, or even how to spell it. It's also hard, because I watched in Japanese, and your posts are in English.
That is WAY cool!
That is his name, english spelling of it is a little different.
You deserve to be immune from my vote for today or something just for that comment
Xtoxm is suspicious for suggesting to lynch LlamaFluff on page 3ish or whatever as opposed to later, though. While I find his ideas to be correct, his timing is suspect.
*Sigh*
Again.
The point is, that his presence moves the day we reach lylo forward by an entire day. So there is absolutley nothing lost in lynching him, and a very high potential gain (scum day one), and I found his claiming the role suspicious, because a voteless shouldn't want to get his role out there, however a scum with that role, or even that fakeclaim, WOULD want to.
I can definately see this action as eager to be helpful without being helpful. Both IG and RF are players that I have not seen go out of their way to hunt scum, or even for that matter, post much in the way of new content.
No, I disagree. I think that IG has been consistent is posting his suspicions and he's looking very town to me atm. I can probably agree with you on RF.
Anyone I did mention I've got my eye on at least (thinktank, kmd) to flat out suspicion (RF, IG, reborn, and BG/Xtoxm pre-claim).
What is the point of keeping your eye here post-claim?
I'm going to Unvote, Vote Reborn for now. I have my reservations about RF and IG, and I'm still not too keen on the lovers claim (as in, I believe it, but I don't think they're in the clear).
I don't like this at all. Gobo looked very townie to me, and Reborn is also looking good. Although on the whole he looks good, there's a couple things about STD i'm not liking.
My answers are in bold. There doesn't seem to be a case here, just an attack on my suspicions of LF followed by a vote on me. I'm looking at you as scum partners now FoS StD
UGGH. Please don't do this. I can't follow it at all when people respond by writing inside the quote they've quoted.
And yeah, you're right, I'm not a very good scumhunter.
I can't help but find it scummy when people try to use this as an excuse. This has come up in another game of mine. Why must people say this...
But I'd like to point out that not only am I fallible, but I also did most of my read from 2:00 am to 5:00 am in the morning, and may not have been fully awake.
Lol, I do this all the time. I think i'm in love with you.
Doesn't mean you should policy lynch players who give scum tells.
This whole scum-tell argument you have is a bit confusing. Is a scumtell not, by defintion, something someone does that makes you think they are scum? In the game you are playing. Not just anywhere on the site, done anywhere. Scumtells aren't constant.
I'm sure a scum would speculate who they're going to kill early in-game IN THE GAME THREAD.
Lol, nice response
Right. my stuff is in bold again.
Screw that idea.
By the way, you still haven't really answered about why you were doing so much power role speculation, IG. How does that help anybody?
He never said he was power role fishing. Why are you putting wrods in his mouth?
Although it can be seen that way, I do not feel that it was intentional.
I'm pretty sure farsidemod is being ruthless about prodding and replacing players. I don't think lurking is an issue in this game. If you disagree, who do you think is guilty of it?
I can vouch for this.
But about your second point - You cannot deny that some are being less active than others - Both in post frequency and content.
As for the o_O, I don't think that you should be ignoring things and hoping they'd blow over.
I think it's ok, i've done it before. Sometimes if there's something you can't think of a good response too, or without one that's liekly to make you look scummy, it can be easier to hope it just goes away.
What is the advantage of breadcrumbing in a theme game, where scum often have safeclaims anyway? Sorry, this is just a strategic question from a newbie.
Main reason I think is because it can prove you later when you claim, it shows atleast that you've had that claim from the start.
Although it's also fun to try and find a good way of breadcrumbing without giving your role away straight off!
this game hasnt been getting enough of my attention, I will should have a larger post up later today
I think you've been a lot more active than most.
On to bigger things - the lovers should find out if its a delayed suicide or not. I have seen instant suicide games and ones where its delayed by either a day or night (ie BG killed N1 xtoxm suicides end of D2). Either way both lovers should be kept off the chopping blocks today.
One step ahead!
I have knowledge. At all: Should I share it now? I think it might be better to keep it to myself, so as to prevent scum finding out.
[Skipped a bit for not having much to say about it]
We don't need an extension, lightweights...
IG - I hear you about TT. His is laying low a bit, but really i'm finding him looking pretty town atm. There's really not anything he's said that i've disliked. I've also played with him once before (well, sort of), and he was much of a talker, and he was town. So I don't see lurking as a scumtell for him.
Ok, so the new list I promised.
Who i'm happy lynching today:
LF (I doubt you're ever going to lose this spot..
)
EK
KMD
Possibles:
RF
STD
So yeh, i'm thinking the other's are town at this time. Although I think Reborn has dropped a bit. But still, I liked Gobo a lot.
Smooth as silk when he's scum, and very much capable of running things from behind the scenes while appearing to be doing minimal effort. - Almost50
Xtoxm is consistently great - Shosin
you were the only wolf i townread at endgame - the worst
