mini #585 - A Tempest Has Formed (Over), Thanks Patrick!!

[Xtoxm]

Did I fair enough. Why would you do that as SK? It guarantees you a loss this way...

No, he was being lynched, claiming SK, when there's still 2 other mafia left, is the SK's best chance for victory.

[Porochaz]

The only way you claiming SK could advantage you is if you are actually scum

Or if he's the serial killer and doesn't want to get lynched.

and the next day? Hes gonna be lynched anyway or NK'ed if there are anymore scum...

[Porochaz]

I was blue screened so give me a sec and allow me to triple post to get the old post back up... the SK cannot win with a competent town now. He WILL be lynched. Are you stupid enough to go there's a man running round town killing people with an axe, lets leave him be... no, cause he's killing you!!! Your going to lynch him the first chance you get cause thats how you win the game.

[Xtoxm]

Poro, want to claim?

[populartajo]

Xtoxm how can you win if you claim SK?
And why are you asking Matt what does he think? Do you suspect him?
Poro's response is indeed a bit sad but theres no way he can be scum. No fucking way. The fact that you and Matt did what you did as newbie scum doesnt change the fact that alvinz was dumb enough to claim nurse. I dont expect from him that level of busing. I expect from him the weak attacks against a nonmafia player like EG, the easy target. I cant be wrong.

[Porochaz]

Am I L-1?

[Xtoxm]

No Poro, we've been through this, lynching the SK today makes maf win. I'm just about certain Poro is mafia.

Let's lynch him.

[Xtoxm]

And why are you asking Matt what does he think? Do you suspect him?

If AJ is lying and is scum, he's the one I expect is his buddy.

[Xtoxm]

Xtoxm how can you win if you claim SK?
And why are you asking Matt what does he think? Do you suspect him?
Poro's response is indeed a bit sad but theres no way he can be scum. No fucking way. The fact that you and Matt did what you did as newbie scum doesnt change the fact that alvinz was dumb enough to claim nurse. I dont expect from him that level of busing. I expect from him the weak attacks against a nonmafia player like EG, the easy target. I cant be wrong.

You are a lover. You ahve no extra information. You can be wrong.

[Porochaz]

When you are the SK, (by the way in my view my greatest victory was as SK in Corsican mafia) it stops being a team game, you are out to make every advantage for your self, by claiming SK you have just lost the game, your dead. No way you can win. Why would he do it even at L-1, you still have a small chance of winning.

[Xtoxm]

You are making the same point that I have already defeated, and just wording it differently.

I see no need to explain again.

[Porochaz]

No Poro, we've been through this, lynching the SK today makes maf win. I'm just about certain Poro is mafia.

Let's lynch him.

I know this, why do you feel the need to repeat it. I asked if I was at L-1 today not "Why dont you think we should lynch the claimed SK today?"

[Porochaz]

Thats my point though which you cannot seem to get unless you are his scum partner desperetly trying to find a way out. Or your just incredibly stubborn. AJ has just lost the game for himself WHY would he do that? Hmmm? Ok he survives an extra day, what then, hmmm? Are you just going to give him a free ride? What is in it for him?

[Xtoxm]

Are you stupid enough to go there's a man running round town killing people with an axe, lets leave him be... no, cause he's killing you!!! Your going to lynch him the first chance you get cause thats how you win the game.

This post that you just made is suggesting an SK lynch today.

Mafia should be taken out before SK, nearly always, unelss it's very early in the game.

[Xtoxm]

Thats my point though which you cannot seem to get unless you are his scum partner desperetly trying to find a way out. Or your just incredibly stubborn. AJ has just lost the game for himself WHY would he do that? Hmmm? Ok he survives an extra day, what then, hmmm? Are you just going to give him a free ride? What is in it for him?

I've been in his exact position before, what he's playing for is for mafia to be lynched, and he needs a townie mislynch before the mafia is eradicated.

[Porochaz]

Thats not what Im suggesting at all, stop twisting my posts

[Xtoxm]

How is "man running around with an axe killing people" not a reference to the SK? Now you are backtracking.

[Porochaz]

Thats my point though which you cannot seem to get unless you are his scum partner desperetly trying to find a way out. Or your just incredibly stubborn. AJ has just lost the game for himself WHY would he do that? Hmmm? Ok he survives an extra day, what then, hmmm? Are you just going to give him a free ride? What is in it for him?

I've been in his exact position before, what he's playing for is for mafia to be lynched, and he needs a townie mislynch before the mafia is eradicated.

Sorry I honestly dont know what you mean your going to have to explain this a little more simply because the way I see it is he will either be NK'ed straight off or he will be lynched the next day. Why would the town risk going after a townie after we have a claim from one of the killing parties? Granted just now scum pose more of a threat and you cant kill the SK now but lynch scum now and that threat becomes less. You go for the claimed person rather than search elsewhere because doing something else would be incredibly stupid.

[Matt_S]

Claimed serial killers can still win. I'm busy eating right now so I can't keep up with the pace of the conversation, but I think popular asked about that.

[Porochaz]

How is "man running around with an axe killing people" not a reference to the SK? Now you are backtracking.

Im not, that was a reference to SK Im just saying that if you are town you will lynch him tomorrow if you have any sense what so ever.

[Xtoxm]

Ah, I see your point. So basically, he needs a townie lynched today.

[Porochaz]

Now that he's claimed yes.

[Porochaz]

but even then he's barely got a chance...

[Xtoxm]

Now that he's claimed yes.

Sounds like you know he's telling the truth.

Vote stays.

[Porochaz]

No its common sense, if you go to the front page and look the best he can hope for now if that if a townie mislynch happens, then the best he can get out of ALL the possible scenarios is a draw.