Meh, I can't seem to stay caught up in this game. Sorry everyone!
First of all: Welcome reborn!
Second of all: To me, I feel as though we have all addressed the gobo claimed/did not claim case ad nauseum. I felt before gobo was replaced that the fact that he had quoted Cleveland twice was mere coincidence, and, correct me if I am wrong, now that he has been replaced there is nothing to prove otherwise. We can debate this as much as we want, but gobo isn't here to answer, and so dwelling on this will continue to get us nowhere.
Thirdly:
RestFermata wrote:Yet of all the scummiest of the scummy here, it still seems that xtoxm takes the cake. Xtoxm's bandwagoning of Llama looks borderline FRANTIC! And his defense of goborage as town was admitedly based solely on a post goborage made saying that xtoxm brought up some pretty good points. And that somehow made goborage town? Just because he agreed with him? I especially didn't like the post when he said that lynching Llama based solely upon his voteless role would be beneficial to the town, and "...we might catch scum!" Might? Aren't we supposed to be maximizing our chances of catching scum by...I don't know...LOOKING for scum? Maybe Llama looked scummy to Xtoxm, but he didn't seem to care one way or another, nor did he contribute any evidence. It seemed to me he was actively protesting any scumhunting activities. How can that be good? He was the second scummiest on my list next to goborage, and now that goborage's replacement has cleared some things up for me, I'm afraid that the vote falls upon xtoxm.
I will agree with you when it comes to the fact that xtoxm's persistance in a LF lynch is very suspicious. His continuous posts in which the only reason he gives for lynching LF is his PR still is suspicious to me, for as stated in the post above, pushing for a lynch without any viable reason other than speculation based off this PR detracts from true scum hunting.
At the same time, however, I must disagree with you, for I don't believe that xtoxm's recent posts portray him as actively protesting any scum hunting. His vote is not on LF, it is on dalt/Elvis, and I believe his reasoning does justify the vote. Dalt made a ping on my scumdar as well with his vote, for he provided no reasoning for doing so, and then when others took notice of it and he was asked about it his activity level plummeted until he was replaced. I do not get the same suspicious reads from Elvis, but the fact that he replaced dalt still looms in the back of my mind.
I'd also like to state my suspicions on dalt
FoS dalt
. However, things obviously might change once he starts chiming in again.
It might be hard for dalt to chime in any time soon. . .seeing as how he was replaced and all.
reborn537 wrote:LlamaFluff wrote:I tend to vote a lot in the early game, seriously go meta. Its a fairly logical path too but that doesnt seem something you are concerned about pointing out here.
This basically amounts to "I always act scummy in early game, seriously, go meta."
The only reason (aside from just doing something that is incorrect, I should point out for fairness' sale) to do something scummy consistently is so that you can point out the meta when you are in fact scum or when people call you out on it. Therefore it's consistently bad for everyone except yourself (and your mafia members if you're mafia). Wishy-washiness is a scum-tell. You can't get around it by saying that you always do it. That doesn't make it ok, or right.
QFT.
reborn537 wrote:Everything you've done so far has led to distraction of the town, for many pages. The goborage thing wasted the town's time for so long and was made up out of thin air.
As I have stated above, I found xtoxm to be suspicious because of the intense pushing for an LF lynch solely based off the fact that LF has a PR. I am not following the GW deal that you sited in your earlier post, and I too found gobo's avoidance of responding to the questions/comments of others to be suspicious as well. Because of this, while I agree that LF has contributed to distracting the town, I cannot agree that everything that he has done so far has been a distraction to scum hunting.
Fourthly:
GhostWriter wrote:Oh, and one more thing: Kloud, I do believe that Elvis is hating on how we both just so happen to like badass silver-haired Square characters.
No doubt about it.