Open 84 - Fire and Ice Mafia - Game Over!

[Eldritch Lord]

*Is Very Wary of Cephrir*

How could you man? I...loved you. /QQ

JK- serious thoughts tomorrow.

---

Eldritch Lord (2): forbiddanlight, orangepenguin
Snix (1): armlx
mik5 (1): Cephrir

Not Voting (5): ChubbsMcLubbs, Eldritch Lord, mik5, Scigatt, Snix

[Cephrir]

Hey, you're the one who was proclaiming it early on. If your argument wasn't awful it might have worked.

Speaking of which, now that the ongoing game in which I actually already knew EL's alignment is over. That he's being logical in this game may or may not be a tell, as he wasn't in the other game. The issue with him following Snix isn't all that unexpected given that they apparently know each other. At least he's not shouting that Snix is town yet.

[armlx]

Speaking of which, now that the ongoing game in which I actually already knew EL's alignment is over. That he's being logical in this game may or may not be a tell, as he wasn't in the other game. The issue with him following Snix isn't all that unexpected given that they apparently know each other. At least he's not shouting that Snix is town yet.

Agree. The game was Strawberry Mafia modded by klebian, BTW, and I'm unsure what kind of conclusions to draw from it.

[Snix]

Hey, you're the one who was proclaiming it early on. If your argument wasn't awful it might have worked.

Speaking of which, now that the ongoing game in which I actually already knew EL's alignment is over. That he's being logical in this game may or may not be a tell, as he wasn't in the other game. The issue with him following Snix isn't all that unexpected given that they apparently know each other. At least he's not shouting that Snix is town yet.

He was right though.

Lets see how long we can derail the game. Shall we?

[armlx]

Lets see how long we can derail the game. Shall we?

How is this discussion derailing the game?

He was right though.

How is that relevant?

[forbiddanlight]

This game is really dying here. I think we need a prod on pretty much everyone who's not armix, snix, EL, orangepenguin (I think?), or Cephrir. Also, I'm ambivalent on meta arguments. In some cases they can prevent a (likely) mislynch like in one of my ongoings, but in other cases they confuse evidence and protect scum. I'm not sure what the aim is here right now.

[armlx]

Meta arguments are best at pointing out explicit scum tells or showing how a normally scummy action is normal for a given player. Beyond that it gets kinda iffy.

[orangepenguin]

Okay, when I said in my one post that we needed to slow down, and take our time, I didn't mean stop posting. Perhaps we need some prods? I admit, I haven't been posting either, but some haven't posted in almost a week (just a guess, I didn't actually go and check)

[forbiddanlight]

Okay, when I said in my one post that we needed to slow down, and take our time, I didn't mean stop posting. Sad Perhaps we need some prods? I admit, I haven't been posting either, but some haven't posted in almost a week (just a guess, I didn't actually go and check)

Yeah, I noticed. Yay for dead games. It's just I didn't want to jump in with nothing to say :S. I already asked for a few prods :S.

[Snix]

The problem is that with two speed lynches we don't have much to go on. The closest we got to a clue is the fact that EL seems to be following me on who to vote for.

[armlx]

Prods would be nice. Still like voting for EL/Snix.

[orangepenguin]

Mod, can you prod the following? Cephir was the last of them to post, and he posted August 2, which was 5 days ago:

01: Scigatt
05: mik5
07: Eldritch Lord
13: Cephrir (Replacing Sun Tzu)
14: ChubbsMcLubbs

[Cephrir]

I'm here. Still not sure whether I want to vote EL (and, if not, what I'm going to do).

[ChubbsMcLubbs]

Im still here as well

[orangepenguin]

Mod, can you prod the following? Cephir was the last of them to post, and he posted August 2, which was 5 days ago:

01: Scigatt
05: mik5
07: Eldritch Lord

13: Cephrir (Replacing Sun Tzu)
14: ChubbsMcLubbs

Updated..

Just to get things going, who does everyone think is the scummiest?

Mod, can we get a vote count too?

[Scigatt]

You know what, I'm going to be asked to be replaced. I probably wouldn't have gotten back around to reviewing this game in a reasonable about of time, due to, among other things, a lack of time.

[armlx]

This is obnoxious. I would have switched my vote to EL a long time ago in order to move things along a bit if we weren't at 5-2-2.

[Eldritch Lord]

Still here, this is obnoxious armlx, I agree but there really isn't anything to talk about tbh.

This game just doesn't have any meaning for me since roflcopter got nk'd. I liked him, his JCS idea was awesome.

I think forbiddanlight is the scummiest so far in my mind because for all his claims otherwise, I'm getting kind of a follower impression from him (takes one to know one, amirite?) despite the fact that he's voting for me for following. Not an OMGUS suspicion, I just think its noteworthy compared to pretty much everything else in this game. I think that whatever the case, I'm willing to act scummy just to keep this game moving for the rest of ya, so:

Unvote

Vote: Forbiddanlight

There y'all go. That should give us something to talk about, answering all questions as they come.

[Snix]

V/LA for the weekend.

Hope I don't miss much.

[forbiddanlight]

I think forbiddanlight is the scummiest so far in my mind because for all his claims otherwise, I'm getting kind of a follower impression from him (takes one to know one, amirite?) despite the fact that he's voting for me for following. Not an OMGUS suspicion, I just think its noteworthy compared to pretty much everything else in this game. I think that whatever the case, I'm willing to act scummy just to keep this game moving for the rest of ya, so:

Well, you've already proven you pay no attention to detail merely in your pronoun usage. Now second, can you actually back this accusation up? And is this the only evidence? Ya see, you have the whole jumping on quick bandwagons against you as well as the BLATENT following. I don't think you can quite liken the cases. If you can come up with better, I'll accept this. For now, you are deflecting.

confirm vote Eldritch Lord

[Cephrir]

Now second, can you actually back this accusation up?

[forbiddanlight]

Is that to me on Eldritch or to Eldritch on me?

[Eldritch Lord]

Forbiddan, don't care if you're a man or a woman.

I will say him, no girls on the internet, etc.

[armlx]

EL, how about instead of responding to the irrelevant points, respond to the ones that matter to the game.

[forbiddanlight]

Forbiddan, don't care if you're a man or a woman.

I will say him, no girls on the internet, etc.

nyeh, irrelevant. Why not respond to the points I brought up? Or maybe you can't? Liking my vote now.