SSW III: Game over

[donkeyz12212]

Nope that was watch.

Several others have already pointed it out. I got mixed between the two on several occasions.

I used "watch" on Cerebus N2.

I still have tracking and roleblock left.

I just sent in my choice for tracking about 15-20 min ago.

Vote count

(10 players alive = 6 to lynch before deadline)
(3) donkeyz12212 –SpyreX, Jebus, Lord Gurgi
(2) Septia – farside22, donkeyz12212
(1) Jebus – Cass
(1) Cass – Porkens

Not voting:

cerebus3, raider8169, Septia

Deadline:

Saturday 9 August 2:00 PM (GMT -5 according to forum clock)

[Jebus]

1st) Why must you keep repeating that you sent in your tracking action?
2nd) What's the difference between watching and tracking?

[cerebus3]

O_o. I coulda sworn that joohono posted a vote count.

Mod note:

I did, but I wasn't fast enough (I want them on top of each page) so I deleted it. This game is truly swift

[donkeyz12212]

uhhh....

1. I just repeated it once?

2. I'm still a bit iffy on this one as this is the first game where I have this ability but I think watching means if someone uses an ability on someone, I can see who visits that person?

While tracking is if I follow someone, I can see who they go to ?

Like Farside - if he investigates Spyrex, I can know he visited Spyrex if I used track on him?

And if I used watch on spyrex, I know that farside visited him?

It's all a bit confusing to me.

[cerebus3]

uhhh....

1. I just repeated it once?

2. I'm still a bit iffy on this one as this is the first game where I have this ability but I think watching means if someone uses an ability on someone, I can see who visits that person?

While tracking is if I follow someone, I can see who they go to ?

Like Farside - if he investigates Spyrex, I can know he visited Spyrex if I used track on him?

And if I used watch on spyrex, I know that farside visited him?

It's all a bit confusing to me.

That is correct.

[Jebus]

He did, about a minute ago.

[Lord Gurgi]

I'm going to take some license here and say that Farside has a vagina, the proper pronoun is she or her.

[Porkens]

If jebus is town, then donkeyz is scum porkens, and visa-versa.

I'd accept this as likely, since otherwise it would be too much power for one side.

Cass flipping town does NOT confirm SpyreX and gurgi. We have gone over this.

Hence the "If you believe the she-wolf claims."

If donkeyz is scum, then he would have to be Jebus's scum buddy, cass's scum buddy, really lucky, or had picked up on a bread crumb.

Yes, you're right. I didn't include that bit but it's what I meant.

[farside22]

If jebus is town, then donkeyz is scum porkens, and visa-versa.

I'd accept this as likely, since otherwise it would be too much power for one side.

Cass flipping town does NOT confirm SpyreX and gurgi. We have gone over this.

Hence the "If you believe the she-wolf claims."

If donkeyz is scum, then he would have to be Jebus's scum buddy, cass's scum buddy, really lucky, or had picked up on a bread crumb.

Yes, you're right. I didn't include that bit but it's what I meant.

This is why I want to do the circle check I talked about. I'm leaning more that Donkey confused and Jebus scum. I'm checking Jebus (i just saying) I want Donkey to track Jebus and if Jebus is telling the truth about JOAT I want her to watch me to see if anyone kills me. If Jebus doesn't confirm or do this I am more convinced of her scum then donkey.

[raider8169]

Though Septia has an odd role and that is one I have been confused about how it fits and that is the one I havent like for a while now I am still not ready to vote Septia yet. I would like to hear from him first.

[raider8169]

EBWOP: If Septia does get lynched did his role say that we lose the next phase or next day phase or what? That seems like a huge risk too. Another reason why I am with holding my vote.

[Porkens]

This is why I want to do the circle check I talked about. I'm leaning more that Donkey confused and Jebus scum. I'm checking Jebus (i just saying) I want Donkey to track Jebus and if Jebus is telling the truth about JOAT I want her to watch me to see if anyone kills me. If Jebus doesn't confirm or do this I am more convinced of her scum then donkey.

It's a good time for power roles to start planing. In combination with that, again, I'd like us to make the most of our lynch.

I also

suspect

Donkey is confused and Jebus is scum.

This is why I want to do the circle check I talked about. I'm leaning more that Donkey confused and Jebus scum. I'm checking Jebus (i just saying) I want Donkey to track Jebus and if Jebus is telling the truth about JOAT I want her to watch me to see if anyone kills me. If Jebus doesn't confirm or do this I am more convinced of her scum then donkey.

It's a good time for power roles to start planing. In combination with that, I'd like us to make the most of our lynch.

I also

suspect

Donkey is confused and Jebus is scum.

So at this point I'd prefer to lynch a non-power role (confirmed or not). This means lynching myself, cerb, or Cass. If we could learn anything by lynching me; I'd be all for it. But from my analysis above; I think we would benefit the most by lynching Cass.

For me, because I believe the she-wolf claims, even if Cass came up town I'd be satisfied that Gurgi is town.

[cerebus3]

Why not septia?

[farside22]

Why not septia?

QFT: I don't see how skipping a day hurts the town. Please explain since there is in a sense no night phase?

[Porkens]

Why not septia?

True, sorry, Sept SHOULD be on the list of non-power roles. Still, we don't learn as much from lynchin Sept.

Not to say that I'm against lynching him; I suspect it's a BS claim, as some of you do, and I ~think~ it would be better for town to force that loss of day rather than leaving the option to scum.

However, we have no opportunity (obvious opportunity anyway) to gain information from lynching Sept.

[raider8169]

Why not septia?

QFT: I don't see how skipping a day hurts the town. Please explain since there is in a sense no night phase?

This is something I was wondering. If it skips the day phase and go right into night? Which by doing so no one should be able to get in night requests so in a sense it does nothing? Im I understanding this right?

[cerebus3]

Though Septia has an odd role and that is one I have been confused about how it fits and that is the one I havent like for a while now I am still not ready to vote Septia yet. I would like to hear from him first.

Here is your connection porkens.

[Jebus]

Why not septia?

Septia's claim wasn't quite a power role, but it's like lynching a power role. If (s)he dies, the maf get two kills, instead of one.

[Lord Gurgi]

What about just from a flavor perspective, all the other roles work or have some flavor rationalization. Where's the rationalization for a Werewolf

Princess

?

[Jebus]

I'm checking Jebus (i just saying) I want Donkey to track Jebus and if Jebus is telling the truth about JOAT I want her to watch me to see if anyone kills me.

I have a track, not a watch, so according to donkeyz, I wouldn't see who killed you, only where you went. None of my abilities can allow me to see who killed you.

Again, I have:
3 vig kills
1 track
1 rolecop
2 nexus

[raider8169]

What about just from a flavor perspective, all the other roles work or have some flavor rationalization. Where's the rationalization for a Werewolf

Princess

?

I said this before but it just doesnt make sense without a king or queen or something to that effect.

[cerebus3]

I'm checking Jebus (i just saying) I want Donkey to track Jebus and if Jebus is telling the truth about JOAT I want her to watch me to see if anyone kills me.

I have a track, not a watch, so according to donkeyz, I wouldn't see who killed you, only where you went. None of my abilities can allow me to see who killed you.

Again, I have:
3 vig kills
1 track
1 rolecop
2 nexus

You had 2 vig kills earlier...

[Porkens]

I've got limited everything, including two vig kills, a roleblock, a rolecop, a tracker, and two nexus. None have been used thus far, thanks to my missing out on the last night phase, and Empking being conservative.

[Porkens]

Sorry for the no-text. Yes, there's a descrepency here. Also, during my re-read, I find it even more unlikely that Jebus and Donkey are both scum. It's unfortunate that Jebus has no actual reports, or that Donkeys was so predictable.

[Lord Gurgi]

Can someone be pro-town this game? Is that too much to ask?