SSW III: Game over

[Porkens]

Someone must have 7 votes against them to hang before the deadline. In the situation you described, the person with the most votes (but not a majority) would be hung at the deadline.

Vote count

(12 players alive = 7 to lynch before deadline)
(3) CoheedCambria09 – farside22, Grimmy, Septia
(3) Porkens – Lord Gurgi, raider8169, donkeyz12212
(2) Lord Gurgi – Jebus, cerebus3
(2) raider8169 – Porkens, SpyreX
(1) donkeyz12212 – Cass

Not voting:

CoheedCambria09

Deadline:

Tuesday 5 August 2:00 PM (GMT -5 according to forum clock)

[Jebus]

Thanks porky

[cerebus3]

Do you guys want everyone to come out and say their win condition?

Yes, nothing is really lost by doing so (it wont hint at power roles as I have postulated) and then once it has been shown that SpreX has a different win condition then the rest of the town, we can move on.

[SpyreX]

I have no idea why I have a different win condition, but yea, there you have it.

[Septia]

So, is this going to become a no lynch or do we have a descent suspect to lynch?

[Lord Gurgi]

So, is this going to become a no lynch or do we have a descent suspect to lynch?

No it's not, the way it's going, it's Coheed that's going to die at deadline.

[cerebus3]

unvote, vote: CoheedCambria

Because I might not be back before lynch, and I like him as scum better than porkens right now, though I don't think either case is enough to support a legitimate lynch right now.

I still think gurgi is scum, and I will push this without hesitation tomorrow, but I need sleep now.

[cerebus3]

unvote, vote: CoheedCambria

Because I might not be back before

deadline

, and I like him as scum better than porkens right now, though I don't think either case is enough to support a legitimate lynch right now.

I still think gurgi is scum, and I will push this without hesitation tomorrow, but I need sleep now.

fixed.

[Cass]

My win condition has no wolf pack in it, so while reading that I thought Spyrex washonest and Cerebus lying. But it seems there are two differently phrased town win conditions around. (That, or all the scum just outed themselves :p ) So, it actually confirms Cerebus as town, and Spyrex too.

I still have a bad feeling about Farside, too much lurking. But the Coheed lynch is good, I think. I reread all his posts (doesn't take long), and it really looks bad.

Unvote
Vote: CoheedCambria

[raider8169]

So, is this going to become a no lynch or do we have a descent suspect to lynch?

Do you have a desent suspect? Out of all the cases out there you have no opinion?

[Lord Gurgi]

So, is this going to become a no lynch or do we have a descent suspect to lynch?

Do you have a desent suspect? Out of all the cases out there you have no opinion?

Septia appears to be voting for Coheed.

[raider8169]

So, is this going to become a no lynch or do we have a descent suspect to lynch?

Do you have a desent suspect? Out of all the cases out there you have no opinion?

Septia appears to be voting for Coheed.

Guess so, it just doesnt make sense then why he would be asking.

[CoheedCambria09]

ok guys, I've explained my behaviour in this game and I know I'm town, so I can claim now if you wish.

[Cass]

If you think it benefits town, now would be the time.

[Cass]

Also your explanation seems to be:
- I don't read carefully and because of that I do scummy things (...yea)
- this game moves to fast for me (please read the name of this game)

[CoheedCambria09]

first point- that was at the beginning, I'm reaing more carefully now and don't think ive done anything scummy

second point- its not that its moving to fast for me, its that i get called scum because of when i place a vote even though thats the first time ive checked the game since a wagon took off.

[Cass]

I don't call you scum for your votes, it's the way you (don't) explain your votes.

"I agree with all the reasons" or "I believe (all) the claim(s)" hold no weight unless you explain

why

you agree or believe. I could say the above anythime, no need to even read the game. So that's my point - nowhere in your posts do I see

evidence

that you are paying attention to the game.

For example: please give your opinion on the current controversy about the town win condition. Do you have a theory on why Battle Mage was NK'ed last night? What exactly convinced you last day that Wall-E should be lynched?

If you claim something confirmable, I might unvote you. Best hurry though, the deadline is nearing.

[Cass]

Btw I would really like to hear more from Grimmy, feels like he's been gone from the game for a long time now...

[Grimmy]

Btw I would really like to hear more from Grimmy, feels like he's been gone from the game for a long time now...

Actually, I have. Rl issues have taken precedence, but I am leaving my vote on Coheed until I have a good reason NOT to.

My thoughts on the BM lynch.
BM probably scared that mafia, but I think it was stupid of them to NK him. His style of play was causing enough doubt that they could have called for his lynch and not seemed suspicious about it. I was on the fence about whether he was scum or not, because he was all over the place day one, and then fizzled out.

Coheed, make your case before the deadline hits. Ill check in before then to see if I should lift my vote.

I also still have suspicions of a few others, but that can wait for another time.

grimmy
back to Rl he goes ( but I have a special place in my heart for this SSW game.)

[CoheedCambria09]

Town Win Conditions Controvesity

- It seems to me that people are really arguing over something that cant be confirmed. Meaning everyone will paraphrase words differently than everyone else. I think the town probly a) has all the same win conditions and the paraphrasing is throwing people off or b)someone is lying. Neither can be confirmed without explicetly stating the win condition which would result in a modkill.

Battle Mage NK

- I think he was killed for a number of different reasons. The first is that he claimed as townie, so the scum would know there killing a town role for sure. The second is his exchange with Wall-E and the oh I investigated you/ your town/ I am town. It seemed like they could possibly have been a connected role (lovers/the other one, i forget what its called but there connected), or thats how it seemed to me. It looked like Wall-E was going to be killed so why wouldnt the scum want to kill BM.

Wall-E

What convinced me of lynching Wall-E was the exchange with BM. If you investigate someone and get innocent, why the hell would you vote them? It seemed like bussing and combined with scummy behaviour by Wall-E (the roleclaim for example) convinced me that he was the best lynch for the day.

[CoheedCambria09]

since I'm probly gonna die anyways,

vote:porkins

[Cass]

You decided not to claim then?

[raider8169]

You decided not to claim then?

I agree I was waiting for a claim before I was going to decide to jump on the bandwagon or not.

[CoheedCambria09]

Im a werewolf, a plain werewolf.

[farside22]

since I'm probly gonna die anyways,

vote:porkins

Why do you think porkins is scum.

unvote:

Your last post before the claim gives me some hope that you may not be scum. My thought on the Wall-E was that he made a mistake. There should have been the whole lets see if anyone counter claims, but the problem and reason I didn't bring that up is last game there were 2 trackers.