TheSweatpantsNinja wrote:
I don't feel like you did much Page 2 couching.
As cool as the word "couching" is, I looked it up, and I'm still puzzled what you mean. Are you saying that I haven't looked at evidence on page 2 yet?
Its relevant when you spend more time caring about how people react to whether or not you ought to completely explain yourself than about whether or not there should be claims day 2.
It's extremely important there should be claims day 2. I wasn't even considering that people
wouldn't
do that. Bottom of the line, (i just looked at the other scenarios), and no matter what, it helps for any power roles that are still alive to claim.
I would want to explain if people don't believe this, so it's important if anyone needs me to explain myself.
Also, I care about the reactions because I'm
scumhunting
. Scum might want to put doubt in my plan (since it's bad for them) by saying things like it's not an automatic win if they both claim and a scum is dead.
please answer this question with a yes or no response:
Even if I was dancing around sticking my tounge out and saying I have a big secret, would that be scummy?
TSN wrote:
bab wrote: Also, you completely ignored most of my questions.
me wrote:
Explain to me how looking for slip-ups of scum is not scum-hunting.
[. . . ]
What about my reasons for CML or weak? Are there any other better reasons than that at this moment?
See above, where I wrote: "I also doubt CML is any more likely to be scum because he miscalculated what conditions it would take to automatically win. To what end would he be "misleading the town" by warning that its not an automatic win if the cop investigates the bodyguard? What behavior is that likely to shift to the scum's advantage? "
see right after that, where
On post 46, [i]I[/i] wrote:TheSweatpantsNinja wrote: To what end would he be "misleading the town" by warning that its not an automatic win if the cop investigates the bodyguard? What behavior is that likely to shift to the scum's advantage?
If everyone doesn't feel like it'll be an auto-win, then the bodyguard and cop might not claim Day 2. This is the exact thing I was afraid of. In the cases I described it helps if both (or if only one is alive) of them claims on Day 2. I need to make sure that everyone understands or believes this.
The better reason is you manufacturing "controversy" in place of scumhunting.[/quote]
uh, no. Did you read my post on 46?
Also, I need you to
specifically
answer this question.
"Explain to me how looking for slip-ups of scum is not scum-hunting."
Also, are there any other bigger leads other than CML or I right now? Because if there aren't, then you can't criticize me for using weak reasons.