SSW III: Game over

[Johoohno]

Vote count

(16 players alive = 9 to lynch before deadline)
(5) SleepyPanda – Wall-E, CoheedCambria09, Empking, Cass, M4yhem
(3) Wall-E – donkeyz12212, cerebus3, SleepyPanda
(2) Porkens – SpyreX, Lord Gurgi
(1) cerebus3 – Porkens
(1) donkeyz12212 – Battle Mage
(1) M4yhem – farside22

Not voting:

ace1217, Grimmy, Septia

Deadline:

Thursday 31 July 2:00 PM (GMT -5 according to forum clock)

[Battle Mage]

actually

Unvote, Vote: Cerebus

God Bless You Porkens!

BM

[cerebus3]

Incorrect. We have the random chance that the player we choose is scum. We gain info if they are town based on reactions. And we gain lots of information depending on what happens at night. It's how this game works. But the fact you KNOW that Panda and possibly Wall-E are town says alot! Very Happy

I think Panda is town. I really don't see scum acting the way he did, but that is hardly definitive. Thus, if I think he is town then *quick*-lynching him gains nothing, because we cant really scrutinize why people got on the wagon because everyone would just be "To avoid teh Nk!". At least, that is why everyone jumped on the panda wagon.

Where did I say I thought Wall-E was town? Now you are just misrepresenting me.

You said 'we have no real chance of catching scum', which by definition, implies that both Panda and Wall-E are town. Not that they 'are probably town'. That they ARE town.

I was talking about the panda wagon specifically. I think he is town, and if I think he is town, then OBVIOUSLY I don't think he will flip scum. Come on BM...

And I APPROVED of the WALL-E wagon, obviously I think there is a chance he can flip scum.

We will have a pretty good idea that those who joined the wagon late are not scum, because they would have submitted the kill. Duh... Rolling Eyes

That actually makes sense.

Sorry, i meant Wall-E. Embarassed
Same question, names transposed. Razz

Because he was using crap logic to vote for panda. That was certainly more than the case against Panda now aint it?

I think the case on Donkey is better. What about you?

BM

I don't really get the case at all.

[SleepyPanda]

This game moves quickly. I've never been suspicious of Mayhem really. SleepyPanda is off the cards. Wall E is most likely town too. Cerebus and Donkey are the two scumbags we must choose from today. What do you mean by 'more high profiled'?

You're assuming that both Wall-E and I are both town, but weren't you saying Cerberus doing the same thing was considered scummy? You seem pretty sure that Wall-E is now town, how are you so positive? It looks like all you're going off of is by association.

I still find Wall-E scummier than Cerebus or Donkey.

[SleepyPanda]

ROFL. I just read Wall-E's posts. Is he really being bandwagonned for making a random vote?

BM

Read it again.

It was a random vote when he had said nothing at all. When asked, he gave the reason that he voted me, which was for changing my vote on the first page. When asked why he chose me over the other two who had done the same thing (Mayhem, Cerberus) he added defensiveness and erratic posting. But those two factors should not even be considered when choosing as they happened AFTER he first voted.

[SleepyPanda]

Edit: Was suppose to add that when he gave a reason, it shows that it wasn't a random vote to begin with, if that wasn't already implied.

Also, my vote is currently on Wall-E.

Mod note:

Sorry about that, I've back tracked the vote counts and fixed it.

[Grimmy]

grrr.....

I had a well thought out post talkign about how BM and Panda seemed townie to me, and I got some sort of CPU OVRLOAD error that wouldnt let me back on the site for a few minutes....

BAH

anywho.

BM's quick lynch idea seems scummy, but he was consistent about it, and did not jump on the Wall_E wagon. IM on the fence about this.
He may be scum WITH Wall-E, or he may be honest about what he wanted to do.

Panda. The self vote seems to be selfless. I need to see how close he got to a lynch. He may also be partnered with BM, and BM may have given up on the wagon in time for him to be safe. I need to check on this, but im on the fence about this too. This may have been a plan of their to make both look townie from the beginning, so they would have this to fall back on.


Or maybe Mafia games haveme paranoid...

Grimmy
PS
Im back
The Grizzled Veteran of SSW games.

[cerebus3]

I'm still for lynching Wall-E but I don't think it's very realistic to get 7 people to switch votes quick enough and have this tactic work. I'll hang around and vote myself if people still decide to go that way.

Unvote;Vote: Wall-E

If everyone who is voting you votes Wall-E, then we have a quick lynch. And If people backtrack on voteing wall-e when their reasoning to vote you was such, then we have scum.

Oh, i guess i'm scum then! EVERYONE BANDWAGON BM!!!!!
I dont like this enforcement of the bandwagon.

HoS: Cerebus

I'm happy to bandwagon this guy if the majority prefers.

BM

You misunderstand me. I meant it would be scummy for someone to jump on the panda wagon for your reasoning and yet be apprehensive about voting the Wall-e wagon.

Which is what i have done. Which means i am scummy. So you can either vote for me, or be proven to be a complete hypocrite.

Your call.

BM

Meh, I think it

is

inconsistant that you were willing to lynch Panda for no reason at all, but not Wall-E, but the fact that you are presenting cases on other players mitigates that somewhat.

Yeh i think you are squirming right now because you dont want to be drawn against me.
The reason im less keen to lynch Wall-E is obvious. People have actually started acting scummy, and it's probably far too late to learn much from a quicklynch with so many people participating.

BM

Ya, and I think you are trying to rile me up into OMGUS-ing you. and ya it IS obvious, notice I didn't FOS you or anything?

[CoheedCambria09]

I think the best bet for a quick lynch today is the Wall-E wagon, we need the quick lynch.

so

unvote, vote Wall-E

[SleepyPanda]

I think the best bet for a quick lynch today is the Wall-E wagon, we need the quick lynch.

so

unvote, vote Wall-E

What do you mean the best bet would be voting Wall-E? Wouldn't I still be the best bet as I have most votes?

[SpyreX]

Good gravy I go to sleep and wake up to this? I hope that not all game its this mega-nocturnal.

If SP is scum, he's got balls of steel - As it sits, with that reaction I've got a town vibe.

Now, the whole Wall-E thing. That vote looks like serious business and, if so, its almost as awesome as the whole "policy lynch" that started the day off last game.

Unvote
Vote Wall-E

@BM (sup)
Why Cerebus over Donkey?

I think the best bet for a quick lynch today is the Wall-E wagon, we need the quick lynch.

so unvote, vote Wall-E

HoS: CoheedCambria - the quicklynch isn't what we're aiming for anymore. Even if it was, you're voting for someone who would need a turn around in order to get the votes needed which, of course, would take time.

My vote is on Wall-E for some serious what the hell logic explaining his random vote.

[M4yhem]

unvote, Vote:Wall-E

I'm still waiting for an explanation of why 'also' is a scumtell.

Also, this seems to be what eveyone else is doing.

Fos:Grimmy

for saying not a lot with many words.

[SpyreX]

...WHAT?

Also, this seems to be what eveyone else is doing.

Also, this seems to be what eveyone else is doing.

I quoted it twice, because, WHAT?

[Grimmy]

Fos:Grimmy

for saying not a lot with many words.

Let me sim-pli-fy it for you.

Im on the fence a-bout both Bat-tle Mage and Sleep-y-Pan-da.

Grimm-Y
Brea-king it up for may-hem
/sar-cas-m

[cerebus3]

This game moves quickly. I've never been suspicious of Mayhem really. SleepyPanda is off the cards. Wall E is most likely town too. Cerebus and Donkey are the two scumbags we must choose from today. What do you mean by 'more high profiled'?

The hipocracy of such a statement makes me LOL

[M4yhem]

What's the problem, Spyre-x? If we want to quicklynch, we need to all vote for the same person.

Grimmy- I got it the first time, I just don't see the point of you telling us that and find your lack of opinion scummy.

[SleepyPanda]

What's the problem, Spyre-x? If we want to quicklynch, we need to all vote for the same person.

Grimmy- I got it the first time, I just don't see the point of you telling us that and find your lack of opinion scummy.

Quicklynching is pretty much a bad idea at this point. From my count, 11 people have come into this thread after the idea of quicklynching was brought up. That's almost 3/4's of the entire game.

[SpyreX]

^ See above. And, seriously, because everyone else is doing it? Really?

[Cass]

I'd guess SP is town. Battlemage probably as well. At least that's the feeling their actions up to now give me. I don't see the case on Wall-E, doesn't seem to me that he actually posted content.

On the other hand, the scum is most likely among those lying low, so he could be one.

Unvote Sleepy Panda

We need wagons, but I dislike voting someone just because everyone does, so I'll vote who's I think is scummiest:

Vote: M4yhem

[Wall-E]

People, people. I am an important role. Someone give me a lynch count and if I'm at L1 I will roleclaim.

[Grimmy]

I think the best bet for a quick lynch today is the Wall-E wagon, we need the quick lynch.

so

unvote, vote Wall-E

the call for the quick lynch has been dropped a while ago.

FOS: CoHeed

Grimmy

[Wall-E]

Also

, Jesus what a bunch of touchy buttwipes. I was just pointing out a linguistic tendancy. It would be like if someone said "It's very, very important that you-" The second very kinda tips you off that it's important to THEM and not important in GENERAL. Things that are important are self-evidentiarilly so.

[Wall-E]

By buttwipes I MEAN NICE PEOPLE WHO I LIKE VERY VERY MUCH!

[Grimmy]

People, people. I am an important role. Someone give me a lynch count and if I'm at L1 I will roleclaim.

FOS: Wall-E

This seems like a panic reaction to the voting, and he has ye to answer the question about his vote.

Grimmy
the suspect list grows. (Grows means gets big-ger Mayhem)

[SleepyPanda]

People, people. I am an important role. Someone give me a lynch count and if I'm at L1 I will roleclaim.

I think you're only at like 6 votes, didn't double check though.

Quicklynch seemed to have already been out of the question, so you weren't really in danger of being lynched. Claiming a power role without saying what it is is just dangerous as roleclaiming, so I'm not sure what you were doing there. I would've preferred a defense instead of a claim.