Open 83 - Polygamist Mafia (Game over!) before 628

[Adel]

What do you think about Zeek's play this game?

I don't like it. First there was that analysis which may or may not have been biased. Then he went from me to you all on admittedly weak cases. But I still feel there is distancing factor here, and that the scum team could be Harvey/Zeek/Adel/SpyreX

scumtell of the day: accusing your target of what you are guilty of.

if forbiddenlight is scum: she just made a couple of posts trying to distance herself from her partners, and now she is accusing them of trying to distance themselves from us. Distancing was on her mind, and so that tool was on top of her toolbox so she found a use for it.

Does that make sense to anyone?

[forbiddanlight]

Does that make sense to anyone?

Not really. I've said for quite awhile that I felt Zeek and SpyreX were distancing. Did you just now pick this up?

[Adel]

sadly, yes.

[Adel]

EBWOP: OMGUS scumtell of the day: doing what you've been accusing your target of

if forbiddenlight is scum: she has been accusing Zeek of trying to distance himself from me and SpyrX as a way of distancing herself from Zeek.

does that make sense to anyone?

[forbiddanlight]

PostPosted: Mon Jul 21, 2008 4:22 pm Post subject: 59


Now, you wanna know what I think might be an interesting combination? SpyreX/Adel/Zeek/Harvey. I mean, right now, it seems that you all are going to great lengths to distance from each other. I mean, it's just a feel given the way you are countering the attacks.

Just an impression. I'm not sure I could prove it. Just felt that way.

(responding to spyrex saying something about not distancing, same day as above quote)

Hmm, ok, I didn't say it as much as I thought, or I missed some of me saying it. I still say your toolbox argument fails.

[forbiddanlight]

does that make sense to anyone?

It's possible. I guess you could say my D1 lambasting of Zeek's analysis was distancing too.

[Adel]

yeah, the trick to this setup is determining who is town as much as it is determining who is scum.

I would really like chenshi to get replaced so that my stalled process of collecting data for quantitative analysis can continue.

chenshi: please read the thread, and post who you think is the most likely to be town, and which two players (non-lovers) you think are most likely to be scum

[forbiddanlight]

yeah, the trick to this setup is determining who is town as much as it is determining who is scum.

Well, so far, I've determined I'm town, and I've determined Shy Guy is town. Am I doing good yet ?

[Nameless]

Does that make sense to anyone?

Yeah. If forbidden is scum, that post would look scummy. Well done.

[Adel]

does it work as an explain for her observed behavior?
If "yes" then the conclusion would mean that she is slightly more likely to be scum. If the answer is "no" then the conclusion would a null-tell.

[chenhsi]

chenshi: please read the thread, and post who you think is the most likely to be town, and which two players (non-lovers) you think are most likely to be scum

Hmm...

Yeah, I'm reading... I need to go somewhere right now, and sleep afterwards, so I can tell you tomorrow...

[Adel]

thank you chenshi, I look foward to reading your post tomarrow.

[SpyreX]

Ohh, what a surprise... no content here.

[SpyreX]

There is still 10 of us, right? Isn't there anything that anyone has to say about anything at all?

[Adel]

mod:

please prod Shyguy and Zeek and Harvey Pew and Chelseafan. Please reconsider replacing chenshi for not being even close to active in this game.

[eldarad]

Vote Count

Chelseafan (1) -

Harvey Pew

Firestarter (1) -

Adel

ZeekLTK (1) -

SpyreX

Adel (1) -

ZeekLTK

Not voting (6) -

Firestarter, Shy Guy, Chelseafan, Nameless, forbiddanlight, chenhsi

With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch

Prodding:
Chelseafan (although he did mention having computer issues so I'll cut him some slack)
Harvey Pew
Shy Guy
ZeekLTK
Firestarter is LA, so I'll wait until Monday before prodding.

If anyone is unclear about my replacement policy, they can PM me for clarification.

[Chelseafan]

chenshi: please read the thread, and post who you think is the most likely to be town, and which two players (non-lovers) you think are most likely to be scum

Hmm...

Yeah, I'm reading... I need to go somewhere right now, and sleep afterwards, so I can tell you tomorrow...

Here and back for the moment.

Is it tomorrow yet chenhsi?
Re-reading the last few pages after I type this.

[Chelseafan]

I'd still like responses from well, anyone, about my statements about Zeek & Shy Guy.

There's been a definite connection made from Shy Guy ---> Zeek multiple times this game and I'd like an opinion on it.

There is a connection there, but it seems so apparent it's almost like Zeek is trying to create a connection, maybe in the hope that Shy Guy wold be lynched? That's just speculation on my part obviously.

After re-reading Zeel looks the scummiest to me, and well yea. He seems to have been a bit worried about SpyreX changing his opinion on him of being most townie, there were good reasons behindf that I think so it's not something that worries me.
Shy Guy's attack on Adel may be warranted and over-all I think Zeel is more likely to be scum than Shy Guy. They could be lovers but at this time if I had to pick it'd be Zeel as the scum.

[Harvey Pew]

Chesea, I am impressed with your perseverance, but not by your aim.

You have been trying to put the boot into me and my partner since post

9

. Initially your "gut" told you to attack me but when you couldn't find a grip you switched your aim to the more garrulous Zeek.

You

could

look beyond me and Zeek, you do know that?

[Chelseafan]

Chesea, I am impressed with your perseverance, but not by your aim.

You have been trying to put the boot into me and my partner since post

9

. Initially your "gut" told you to attack me but when you couldn't find a grip you switched your aim to the more garrulous Zeek.

You

could

look beyond me and Zeek, you do know that?

I'm aware I can, thanks for letting me know though.

I'm considering other options too, don't worry. I'll try not to tunnel vision.
Kinda hard when I think you're scum though.

[Nameless]

Adel - I think it's pretty obvious at this point we're not getting anything substantial from chenhsi, but since the nature of the setup allows us to judge her alignment from partners I'd suggest just moving on with your plan ... which IIRC, would be you posting the pairs you thought most scummy.

[Chelseafan]

Adel - I think it's pretty obvious at this point we're not getting anything substantial from chenhsi, but since the nature of the setup allows us to judge her alignment from partners I'd suggest just moving on with your plan ... which IIRC, would be you posting the pairs you thought most scummy.

We're getting nothing from chenhsi, this kinda seems the norm for him.
A replacement would be much better, but I suppose as long as he fulfills minimum posting this can't happen.

[Harvey Pew]

Chenhsi definitely chooses lurking as an actual strategy. I'm playing Newbie 643 and he has annoyed a number of people there with his low profile.

[Firestarter]

A player by player analysis from several of the last few pages and before is on its way guys...

[ZeekLTK]

I've been busy, don't really have anything to add.

Clearly SpyreX isn't willing to believe anything I say. And the fact that he is attacking me for things that he knows I do as town (we just played a game together where we were both town) pretty much confirms to me that he's not interested in scum hunting but just pushing a mislynch. So I'm keeping my vote...